Universal Basic Income (UBI)

From Russell - Human Compatible :

"For some, UBI represents a version of paradise. For others, it represents an admission of failure—an assertion that most people will have nothing of economic value to contribute to society. They can be fed and housed—mostly by machines—but otherwise left to their own devices. The truth, as always, lies somewhere in between, and it depends largely on how one views human psychology. Keynes, in his essay, made a clear distinction between those who strive and those who enjoy—those “purposive” people for whom “jam is not jam unless it is a case of jam to-morrow and never jam to-day” and those “delightful” people who are “capable of taking direct enjoyment in things.” The UBI proposal assumes that the great majority of people are of the delightful variety." --- 0.330, 2020-05-07

The question is whether this assumption holds. Is the coupling of work and purpose essential or something we can unlearn?

"Keynes suggests that striving is one of the “habits and instincts of the ordinary man, bred into him for countless generations” rather than one of the “real values of life.” He predicts that this instinct will gradually disappear. Against this view, one may suggest that striving is intrinsic to what it means to be truly human. Rather than striving and enjoying being mutually exclusive, they are often inseparable: true enjoyment and lasting fulfillment come from having a purpose and achieving it (or at least trying), usually in the face of obstacles, rather than from passive consumption of immediate pleasure. There is a difference between climbing Everest and being deposited on top by helicopter." --- 0.333, 2020-05-07

Is happiness without strive and adversity meaningful?

Keynes, in Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren (1930):

"It will be those peoples, who can keep alive, and cultivate into a fuller perfection, the art of life itself and do not sell themselves for the means of life, who will be able to enjoy the abundance when it comes."

UBI and the ultra-rich

In a discussion, Pim Haselager mentioned the interesting example of Gerald Ford who priced the cars he produced such that his own employees could buy them. This strategy is quite genius: you greatly expand the size of your market, and moreover the money you pay to your workers comes back into the company as sales revenue.

When ultra-rich people such as Jeff Bezos advocate UBI, you may argue this is a similar strategy for keeping their vast empire sustainable: the costs for UBI would be paid by the government via taxes (that they are good at evading) but the money likely goes to buying stuff in Amazon online shops.

Additionally, a push for UBI could be a move to push out competitors that rely on low-wage labour instead of automation.