Subjective vs. Objective Bayesianism

Subjective conditionalization

Degree of belief dependent on:

Subjectivist Conditionalization makes your new degree of belief in a hypothesis a function of two things: the new evidence and your conditional degree of belief prior to acquiring that evidence. (127)

Why is this "subjective"?

  1. Probabilities express degrees of belief
  2. Rational inter-subjective disagreement is possible
    • i.e. agents might reach different conclusions that are rational from their viewpoint (given different background knowledge and updating based on evidence)

This is a “subjective” policy in two senses. First, probabilities here are understood as the subjective state of an agent, namely her degrees of belief. Second, to the extent that rational agents may have different prior degrees of belief, there is room for rational inter-subjective disagreement. If you rationally hold degree of belief p'(H|E)=x, while I rationally hold p'(H|E)!=x, then we will be rationally obliged to draw different conclusions given evidence E. (127)