Writing a research brief (or policy brief, based on research)
@writing @brief
This information is based on a lecture by Giulio Mecacci in the course Ethics for AI at Radboud University, 2019-2020.
What
A research brief is a short, to the point and jargon free document, written for non-specialists, that presents research findings to particular policy actors or stakeholders.
The emphasis is on showing relevant main implications of the research and providing a relevant recommendation for action. This can also be positive! For example, there could be an possibility that we should act on, e.g. stimulate through research grants.
Examples of stakeholders: policy makers, NGO's, companies, legal institutions, general public.
Why
- 79% of policy actors rated policy briefs as a "key tool" (Jones & Walsh 2008: 3)
- Making research findings easily accessible increases the change that the research is read and acted upon.
- This in turn increases visibility and the chance that future research will be funded
- Policy brief is a suitable way to do outreach, with a focus on the impact of research.
How
It is crucial to have a clear aim and target into mind.
The aim can be to change a policy or simply to raise awareness on an important issue.
The aim largely determines who the appropriate target audience is.
Choosing your audience in turn determines what language is appropriate.
Policy actors want relevant solutions to policy problems. A policy brief should clearly lay out evidence informed solutions to a problem that the specific actor is interested in. These solutions should be:
- realistic,
- feasible within the current political climate
- cost effective
It is a good exercise to imagine yourself in the shoes of the policy actor.
Submit your policy brief to the breakfast test.
The main concern here is: how do you connect the information with your target audience.
Formatting / style
A good page layout can be very helpful in making the information digestible. Differentiate different sections. Highlight title etc.
Choosing stakeholders
Start broadly, e.g. "government" and then narrow it down.
Government of a specific country? Which department? Economics of defense?
Within that department, find out what kind of reports they write and institutions they have. Do some background research to get a feel for what these institutions are interested in.
One sentence summary
You should be able to answer the following question:
Something X that stakeholder Y needs to know about topic Z in order to do (or consider doing) P to achieve/avoid Q, to the benefit of R, or to uphold the value(s) V
Structure
This is a typical structure of a research brief from the Rathenau Institute, adjusted for the ethics AI course I followed. For example, normally you would not dedicate a separate section to mention the target audience.
In a conversation of Pim Haselager with an employee from the Rathenau Institute, they said their main concern was busy politicians not reading their reports.
Assumes a length of about 2/3 pages, 1500 words content. Professional research briefs often are max. 2 pages, i.e. around 1000 words.
- Title
- Snappy, short, informative
- Target audience (100 words)
- Specify your target audience
- This is not explicit if you would write a search brief outside of the scope of this course.
- Executive summary (200 words)
- Two/three sentences summing up the entire research brief. Use recognizable buzzwords and emphasize the relevance of the research to policy to draw the policy actor's attention.
- Introduction/Problem summary (450 words)
- Explain the policy issue and why it is particularly important or current.
- Put the research into context
- Methods, Approaches, and Results (450 words)
- Present the research/project findings in an accessible way for a non-specialist
- Explain the methodology used to reach the results, e.g. synthesis of existing research, or new research data?
- A policy actor actor wants to see robust results: repeatable and corroborated by others.
- Conclusions (100 words)
- Note that the executive summary section already contains what we normally call a conclusion
- So do not repeat yourself, but reinforce the key message here.
- Policy recommendations (200 words)
- Try to make one feasible policy recommendation
- If you have more, differentiate them clearly, e.g. with bullet points
- References and suggested sources
- Use references sparingly
- Suggest additional sources either for relevant background information or instead to dive into further details.
- Acknowledgements, Author Details, Disclaimers
- Mention any used funding
- Author's current position and contact details.
Number of references: rule of thumb between 3/5 references. Does not necessarily have to be all academic, depending on your topic. Could be an informative blog.