Explanatory virtues

Candidates for explanatory virtues. Lipton-Inference_to_the_best_explanation.md , p. 6:

  • Scope (explain more types of phenomena)
  • Precision
  • Mechanism (provide information about underlying mechanisms)
  • Unification (unify apparently disparate phenomena)
  • Simplicity (cf. Ockham's Razor)

Example: there is no "uncontroversial analysis of unification or simplicity"; and are these artefacts of the specific formulation of the explanation or the explained hypothesis?

Leah Henderson. "Bayesianism and IBE" in Best Explanation: New Essays on Inference to the Best Explanation:

On the other hand, scientific arguments for one theory over another often appeal more or less explicitly to explanatory advantages of that theory. For example, Darwin argues very explicitly in The Origin of the Species that the theory of natural selection provides a better explanation of ‘large classes of facts’ than special creationism (Darwin 1962 [1859]). Copernicus argues that his heliocentric theory possesses greater ‘harmony’ than its Ptolemaic rival, which may be seen as an appeal to a kind of explanatory virtue (Copernicus 1543). (250)