AI Ethics guidelines as a way to avoid actual legislation

When reading up on academic literature on AI Ethics guidelines, I noticed repeated critical remarks that all the good intentions proclaimed in ethics guidelines for AI are ultimately often not more than that: some pretty promises.

Because ethics as such does not include any mechanisms for its own enforcement, the active promotion of ethics guidelines can ipso facto be seen as an attempt to preemptively stifle the development of AI legislation that does enforce compliance: "No need to forbid that, we are being responsible over here. You can trust us.".

In Hagendorff - the Ethics of AI Ethics Evaluation of Guidelines :

When companies or research institutes formulate their own ethical guidelines, regularly incorporate ethical considerations into their public relations work, or adopt ethically motivated “self-commitments”, efforts to create a truly binding legal framework are continuously discouraged. (100)

In "From Ethics Washing to Ethics Bashing: A View on Tech Ethics from Within Moral Philosophy" by Elettra Bietti (2019) a similar point is made. In ethics washing tech companies use the term "ethics" abundantly to avoid regulation and fend of criticism.

Notwithstanding good intentions, embedding philosophers or ethicists within technology companies is a double-edged sword and could shield these companies from capacious regulation more protective for consumers. (Bietti 2020)

In this sense, ethics is really part of a business strategy and you may ask to what extent AI ethics is a form of business ethics .

Hagendorff also cites a similar point made in the AI NOW 2017 report:

In their AI Now 2017 Report, Kate Crawford and her team state that ethics and forms of soft governance “face real challenges” (Campolo et al. 2017, 5). This is mainly due to the fact that ethics has no enforcement mechanisms reaching beyond a voluntary and non-binding cooperation between ethicists and individuals working in research and industry. (108)

To check:

  • Ben Wagner, Ethics as an Escape from Regulation: From ethics-washing to ethics shopping? in MIREILLE HILDEBRANDT (ED.), BEING PROFILING. COGITAS ERGO SUM (2018).