Ethics Lobbying

From Floridi, L. (2019). Translating principles into practices of digital ethics: Five risks of being unethical. Philosophy & Technology. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13347-019-00354-x :

Digital ethics lobbying is...

the malpractice of exploiting digital ethics to delay, revise, replace, or avoid good and necessary legislation (or its enforcement) about the design, development, and deployment of digital processes, products, services, or other solutions. (188)

Why is this particularly prevalent with digital technology?

This specific malpractice affects many sectors, but it seems more likely in the digital one (Benkler 2019), where ethics may be exploited as if it were an alternative to legislation, and in the name of technological innovation and its positive impact on economic growth, a line of reasoning that cannot be easily supported in environmental or biomedical contexts. (188)

Another harmful effect is that it makes legitimate digital ethical self-regulation suspect and hurts its credibility. That's a shame, because genuine self-regulation has value and can be complementary to good legislation when (see p. 189):

1) legislation is unavailable, 2) legislation is there but requires additional interpretation effort 3) legislation is available "but also in need of some ethical counterbalancing" (?) * Not sure what this means 4) it's better to not do something even though it's not illegal 5) it's better to do something even though it's legally not required.

Counterstrategy:

  • "good legislation and effective enforcement" (189)
    • difficult when actors are influential and perhaps even have influence on law through lobbying
  • expose digital ethics lobbying (and make exposing this beneficial e.g. for a whole sector; i.e. they have an interest in defending the credibility of self-regulation)