Toulmin's Argumentation Model
Original source: S.E. Toulmin, The Uses of Argument, Cambridge University Press, 1958.
I've not read the original, but I encountered this in argumentation mining papers, e.g. Lippie (2016) .
Toulmin proposes that human argumentation and reasoning have a structure with six categories:
- incontrovertible datum (i.e. it cannot be disputed; is recognized as fact), which is the basis of ...
- a claim
- that follows from the datum by a rule of inference (warrant)
- with some qualifiers that indicate how certain we are of the claim
- or with conditions in which the claim holds (rebuttal)
- or with a justification to the warrant (backing)
This model is relatively complex and thus not always used in actual applications. The first (afaik) argument mining paper from Mochales and Moens simplifies Toulmin's model to a relation between at least one premise and at most one conclusion.
A related simplified model further distinguishes attacking and supporting premises, e.g. see I. Habernal and I. Gurevych, Argumentation mining in user-generated Web discourse, Computational Linguistics (2017) abs/1601.02403.
The ideas of warrant and rebuttal are a natural fit with legal argumentation. In the legal field you can have a claim that is warranted by legal rules. But whereas a "deductive" view on this situation might then view the case as settled, in a legal case there may still be exceptional facts that change the outcome (e.g. the defendant being insane). As opposed to classic deductive logic, styles like defeasible logic are better able to capture this type of inference as a competition between logical arguments and counterarguments. That is, the quality of arguments is not a matter of evaluating their syntactic form (deductive logica approach), but a question of whether arguments "can be defended in a properly conducted dispute." (Prakken 2018, 127).
From Prakken, H. (2018). Historical overview of formal argumentation. In P. Baroni, D. Gabbay, M. Giacomin, & L. van der Torre (Eds.), Handbook of Formal Argumentation (Vol. 1, pp. 73-141). College Publications:
Stephen Toulmin, whose 1958 book The Uses of Argument is generally regarded as the origin of informal logic and argumentation theory, criticised the logicians of his days for neglecting many features of ordinary reasoning. In his well-known pictorial scheme for arguments (see Figure 1) he left room for “rebuttals” of an argument on the basis of exceptions to the “warrant” connecting the arguments “data” to its “claim”. The idea of rebuttals is clearly related to Hart’s [1949] ideas on exceptional circumstances that can defeat the application of a legal concept. (Prakken 2018, 80)
Toulmin "also argued that outside mathematics the validity of an argument does not depend on its syntactic form but on whether it can be defended in a properly conducted dispute, and that the task of logicians is to study the criteria for properly conducted disputes." (Prakken 2018, 80).
That is, argumentation theory and nonmonotonic logic can be connected by doing nonmonotonic logic in an "argumentation way" (cf. Prakken 2018, 81) and conversely, by not requiring arguments to be deductively valid.
Toulmin's work forms the basis of a lot of subsequent work on argumentation schemes. When discussed elsewhere, e.g. in argument mining papers, I often find that the "rebuttal" is identified as a list of critical questions. Prakken also mentions this with the relevant source:
Toulmin’s notion of a warrant was in informal logic and argumentation theory generalised into rich classifications of argument schemes for presumptive forms of reasoning, while his notion of a rebuttal was generalised into lists of critical questions attached to argument schemes [Walton, 1996]. The idea of argumentation schemes with critical questions has since the above-mentioned Bonskeid 2000 event often been used in formal and computational models of argumentation-based inference and dialogue. (Prakken 2018, 80)