The Art and Fun of EU Proposals

This is a lunch seminar by Adam Schmidt, Christopher Brewster on writing EU grant proposals.

Personal motivation for writing proposals

Adam:

  • I like developing concepts and ideas and handing them off to researchers to slave away at it for years.
  • This fits my attention span for projects of about 6 months

Christopher:

My professor told me that the whole point of research has nothing to do with research, but with having dinner in a really nice place, let's say Casablanca. Then you ask: can I write a paper that allows me to go there? Okay, but who's paying me for my time? Let's get a grant!

There's an enjoyable creative element of building a concept, developing an idea, and finding the right group of people to work it out.

After his first academic appointment, Christopher wrote a overly ambitious and mad European proposal. It did not get funded, but the overall point is that nevertheless this has secondary effects. You build a huge network and people pick up ideas nevertheless, and in the case of Christopher this led to his second project being funded and an entry in the domain of agri food in Wageningen.

How do you do it?

Adam takes a pretty systematic approach.

Context: EU publishes "work programs" for subareas. Typically 500 page documents with more or less a 100 calls for research topics with buzzwords etc. So you are looking for a call that fits your interest.

Some people put a lot of effort into strategically selling their research to fit a call, but you should make a trade-off into the effort it takes. If it just doesn't fit, it's probably wasted effort to oversell yourself.

Christopher: a less systematic way is that people invite you. Either start with a shared idea, or someone approaches you with a call text in mind asking you to collaborate.

Cynicism check: don't just go for grants just because a friend asks you. Evaluate your partners and yourself critically: who brings what to the table in a consortium? Will it be a winning consortium?

Strategical call

Is it worth putting in the effort?

This call is mainly based on experience and "business intelligence".

Take a 5 mil grant on a popular topic, that covers a single 5 mil project. This means that from the outset there's very small chances of success.

With 20 mil for 4 projects (still 5 each!), your chances are larger with the outcome being identical! You don't have to be the very very best, but you can be the third best as well.

Dongle effect: There are some calls where there is an important aspect to have. "Sometimes you need to have a USB-dongle to unlock other things". E.g. some calls may ask to build on the results of a previous project. This helps you assess whether it's worth it to pursue this. If you are an outsider going to revolutionize an existing project... not going to happen! On the other hand, having good contacts in that area is a plus and something you can bring that to the table.

Technology readiness level

For TNO it is easier to compete where applications also matter, whereas purely on the research side there is a lot of competition from universities.

At TNO your performance is not measured by the amount of publications and generally speaking TNO employees will be out competed by academics on this point, because publications scientist's main evaluation metric.

TNO has a high technological readiness level though, which universities do not have.

Concept note

Have you written a concept note? A concept note is a 2-5 page text that describes, in dialogue with a call text:

  • Why is this an important problem?
  • Who is going to do it (either actual partners or a "type" of partner)

A lot of concept notes focus too much on the what: we are going to do A,B,C etc.

Instead, focus on why is the call and your unique approach to it relevant? Don't be like: we are going to be (yet another) system. E.g. there have been calls for digitalization for 20 years. So... tell a story by starting with the question: Why are these calls still there?

Nobody gets to the what and who if you don't see the why.

Infographics do well!

Organisation

  • What are the gaps in consortium expertise, and who is going to fill them?
  • Having a coordinator is very important
    • Christopher: if the coordinator is not doing much, he prefers to just drop out.
    • Coordinator should have enough expertise on the research topic
    • Should also listen to experts, but also present a clear line. There is a point where democracy stops, especially in very large consortiums of 30+ partners.

Adam: we have blacklists of coordinators that we will not work with; same for partners.

Writing the proposal

Getting the network together really requires a different skill set than writing.

A EU proposal is nowadays about 45 pages (used to be 70) with three sections:

  • Scientific Excellence
  • Impact
  • Implementation

Impact is very important in Horizon Europe. The coordinator has to keep oversights but will not write the whole thing.

Some tasks:

  • Ability to summarize state-of-the-art in short notice in 200-300 words.
  • Concept part: selling proposal in three pages
  • Methodology:
  • Impact & promise (preferably let a "business person" / someone with inside knowledge of the "eco system" do this)
  • Work plan

The archetypical scientists isn't able to write a proposal on his/her own.

A lot of boilerplate text will be used, e.g. method for dissemination, social media, gender diversity ambitions.

Adam e.g. can write most of those sections, but doesn't want to do state of the art summaries because he doesn't want to get into five subdomains per proposal.

Negotiate budget

  • Either cut down on promises for less money
  • Agree on vague extra responsibilities for more money

Done! And now what?

Then you wait for 5+ months.

Success rate is very low, especially for research oriented calls, about 5%.

Example Christopher: 14.5/15 marks, still didn't get funded.

Okay maybe you don't get funded, but you organized a whole consortium that will probably flourish into other projects and results.

SMO (Samenwerkingsmiddelen onderzoek):

  • For external grants the money is usually matched internally
  • This requires convincing PMC leaders to convince them why the research is relevant
  • Good strategy is also to start with the PMC to get the internal funnel set up, then take this into account when applying to calls

"80% of life is just turning up" -> remark w.r.t. building network in meetings.