Meditating while in conversation
Typically, meditation is done in silence and is an activity where you sit still. However, when I started out with meditation, I recall a remark from Sam Harris that some meditation exercises can be done during the day, taking as little as a second, for example by becoming aware of your mood or any stress you experience. This form of mindfulness is however quite different from the formal activity of meditation.
The question then is, how can we "meditate" in daily life when it is not possible to be silent and sit still?
(Note, at 4:30 Shinzen Young really does call it "meditating while in conversation", not just "mindfulness" in conversation. That is, this talk is really about applying an intentional meditation technique in conversation. I emphasize this because I had a conversation with Alexander where he, I think rightfully so, distinguished just "being in the moment" from "meditation".)
If the conversation is substantive, it takes our focus and mental effort to engage with that conversation. Here it may not be possible to formulate an intentional strategy for mindfulness. However, many daily conversations do not require our full attention, and here we may practice an intentional strategy.
We notice a figure-ground inversion here: whereas normally the more substantive conversations are the great ones, now the less meaningful chit chat become great, because you have room for your practice. That does not mean you should "zoom out" and not engage with the person. But what can we do?
Strategy 1: "Anchor yourself in the sights and sounds of that person". Really look at that person, really listen at that person. I think Shinzen Young calls this a "focus out" strategy.
Strategy 2: Metta in the body. It is a social convention to smile etc. during conversation. You can practice this into a whole body experience of unconditional love towards all directions, including the conversation partner.
One of the questions I personally have, is whether you can really listen to the other while focusing on one of these strategies. I'd say my idea of a good conversation really aligns with the "substantive" type of conversation mentioned at the beginning. Ultimately, such a conversation is about me and you engaging with and developing the idea that is at stake in the conversation; idea not in the psychological sense, as my idea or your idea, but that which interests us (inter-esse, being between us and engaging us in the conversation). Shinzen Young already addressed this concern partially because he admitted from the get-go that this type of conversation leaves little to no room for an intentional meditation strategy.
However, my question remains even for less substantive conversations, because in meditation there is typically indeed this moment where you take a step back. Whereas in daily life you are engaged or can even be consumed by your experiences, in meditation you become aware of experiencing that experience, of being imprinted. So for example, when I meditate on a sound, I don't just hear the sound, I also become aware of the hearing itself. I assume this is what is meant by "focus out", because it is a movement of becoming disinvolved with your own experiences in a way that is nevertheless focused and with attention.
Now, back to my question: when I apply this strategy in conversation and I become aware of being imprinted with sound when the other talks, do I really listen? Listening is not the same as experiencing sounds. This question is important to me, because otherwise the point of this note becomes very cynical. It would be something like: "this is a shallow conversation, so I'm going to use it as a meditation object instead." I can think of two questions to formulate my concern:
How can we prevent "focusing out" from becoming "zooming out"?
How can we meditate in conversation, instead of on conversation?
Shinzen Young also mentions some of these worries. Can I be (socially) appropriate in conversation when applying these techniques? Will people notice I'm being weird?
His insights on this:
- We are very accustomed to preparing our response when listening to someone, which constantly pulls us back from the conversation into our own mind and emotions, which is reactive. This ironically often means we're not listening that well.
- The mentioned strategies are not to disengage with the other in the conversation, but to anchor on them. So actually, "focusing out" allows better listening by avoiding this reactive modus where you become preoccupied with responding rather than listening. Instead, people generally find the experience that you give them time and space attractive, as a ego vacuum that pulls them in like an "osmotic gradient".
So yes, people will notice, but that's not a bad thing. And yes, it takes getting used to not planning a response while listening, but you can get accustomed to this and ultimately feel confident enough to take a chance and "start flapping your lips without planning."