The structure of a scientific paper
This note is intended to capture typical structures for scientific papers and specifically to track how conventions differ between research fields (e.g. humanities vs. computer science).
A paper that presents experimental work is often structured as follows:
- Title, abstract, keywords
- Introduction: What is the problem / research question?
- Materials and methods: How is the question addressed or solved?
- Results: What did I find out?
- Discussion: What does it mean?
- Acknowledgements
- Literature cited
- Appendices
Ok, some questions and remarks:
- I often see that a discussion of literature goes in its own "background" or "literature review" section
- This is very common in theses, because here showing a good understanding of the field is one of the learning goals
- I see a possible meaningful difference between a "methods" section and an "experiment" section
- E.g. "methods" section could contain an explanation of used algorithms
- Whereas an "experiments" section could outline the details of experiments (and their hypotheses?)
TODO:
- Thesis structure
- Paper structure in non-experimental papers, e.g. philosophy
Tips on writing order
- Start with having your figures and tables ready as soon as possible. This is the stuff you write about, so it's most efficient if they are already in good order
- Personally, for course papers I have often had to rewrite quite a lot because I didn't have my results finalized yet; sometimes results changed, hence figures changed, hence the accompanying text needed to be rewritten.
- Write methods and results next
- Write the discussion before the introduction. This way you avoid making claims in the introduction that are not sufficiently supported by the discussion of your results
- Then write conclusion and introduction
- Then abstract and a catchy title
- etc.
The discussion is key
The discussion section is arguably the most important section of an article.
Tips and thoughts:
- The discussion needs to correspond to the results, but without just repeating the results. Don't make claims not backed by the results.
- Compare your results with previous results (stated as relevant literature e.g. in the literature or a background section)
- Avoid unspecific expressions, try to be precise and quantitative
- Do not introduce new ideas; the proper place to do this is the introduction
- If multiple possible interpretations of the results are possible, you still need grounding of these interpretations (i.e. you should show why they are good and plausible interpretations; this is not just a work of imagination)
- If you cannot clarify an idea, this may mean that you need more results and that more work is needed there.
Tips for a good introduction
- It is good to state the purpose and the general research strategy, but make sure to not overlap with methods and results etc.
- State your contribution but without overpromising. It is probably not "paradigm-shifting" work and even if it is, this is probably for others to determine. (I suspect no paradigm shifting article has called itself such; it's shitty writing and moreover, whether it actually achieves something also largely depends on its reception).
- Sketch the bigger picture first and guide towards your research problem; zoom in gradually
- State hypotheses and objectives at the end of the introduction!
Sources
- https://www.elsevier.com/connect/11-steps-to-structuring-a-science-paper-editors-will-take-seriously