Digital Hermeneutics: Agora and the Online Understanding of Cultural Heritage | Chiel van den Akker, Susan Legêne, Van Erp, Aroyo, Segers, Van der Meij, Van Ossenbruggen, Schreiber, Wielinga, Oomen, Jacobs. ACM Web Science Conference 2011

@digital_hermeneutics @cultural_heritage @collection_enrichment

The Agora project: allow interpretation of collections/cultural heritage using web technology.

In this contribution, we focus on defining and modeling prototypical object-event and event-event relationships that support the interpretation of objects in cultural heritage collections. (2)

Introduction

The web as a place of dialogue with a two-way information stream:

  • online information providers need to provide meaningful access to information
  • but also should think "about how users may enrich their collection descriptions with their personal perspectives" (1)

See for the Web as a place of dialogue:

P. Walsh. The web and the unassailable voice. Archives and Museum Informatics, 11(2):77-85, 1997.

Digital hermeneutics: Old school hermeneutics "needs to be amended to account for the interpretation of information in a digital environment" (1)

Main aim:

to investigate the relation between the human interpretation process and Web applications supporting that interpretation process." (1)

Main architecture:

The main building blocks in the interpretation process of history and collection objects are historical events and the relations between these events and the objects. A collection object on its own, has no meaning; by adding events to the object's description we provide its historical context. This gives the object meaning and makes it possible to interpret it. A single historical event often gives only a part of the whole historical context of an object, therefore narratives are important in the interpretation process. A narrative is formed by a chain of historical events. In principle, any sequence of historical events can form a narrative, however, we define a set of event-event-relationships from which narratives follow that are meaningful from a historical perspective. We call these narratives proto-narratives, as they are key to the interpretation process of users. (1-2)

Research questions:

1) "what object-event-relations and event-event-relations support and enhance access to and interpretation of cultural heritage collections?" (2) 2) "how can we model historical event descriptions to facilitate this access and interpretation?" (2)

These questions are addressed in a real use case with the Rijksmuseum Amsterdam.

Digital hermeneutics

Main components:

The core of digital hermeneutics is formed by two components: object-event relationships and event-event relationships. By making explicit relationships between the objects and events, and between the events themselves we can facilitate users in their access and interpretation processes of objects in online cultural heritage collections. (2)

It is not entirely clear to me whether this is e.g. based on a definition of Capurro of if these are original definitions.

Object-Event Relationship

  • Between object and event
  • But meaningful from a historical perspective
  • Thus is helpful for users to understand objects

The "event dimension of objects" (2):

1) historical context as perceivable by majority of general public 2) what historical event is related to the object? * depicts an event or an aspect of an event * depicts something used or functioning in an event 3) object history, e.g. its creation or display history * the "making/collecting/exhibiting is in itself an event" (3)

Four "event properties" (3):

1) actor 2) place 3) time 4) type

By relating and event to an object a object is assigned an event dimension (cf. 3)

Important insight: different event dimensions lead to different interpretations of the object (clear hermeneutic aspect!).

It is thus useful for the user to know relations between events in the event space of an object. This guides the interpretation of the object.

Event-Event Relationships

1) Topological, location-based: events occurred in the same place 2) Conceptual, type-based: events related because they are of the same type (e.g. wars) 3) Biographical, actor-based: events related because they involve the same actor

These three elements can be used to build prototypical historical narratives.

A narrative includes:

1) A topic 2) A type of event-event relationship 3) Sequence of related events, given 2.

Depending on the type of 2, we have a conceptual narrative, topological narrative or biographical narrative. (cf. 4)

Sections skipped. Discuss details and technical challenges. Refer to paper.

Future work

On the increasing relevance of digital hermeneutics in the humanities:

With the current explosion of online collection portals and increasing role of technology in the humanities, it is to be expected that in the near future digital hermeneutics will be at the center of attention of both humanity scholars and computer scientists. It will do so as a theory of interpretation of information and communication in a digital environment, as well as a context for the development of Web applications with the goal of supporting the interpretation process for its users. (7 )

Such programs as Agora as a way of entering into a digital dialogue:

We are working towards a user-curated environment where users will be able to (i) contribute additional event-related metadata to objects, (ii) identify links between events, and (iii) create, save and share historical narratives. This is a step towards making the Web a place of dialogue between cultural heritage institutions and their audience. Such a dialogue could lead to a new understanding of cultural heritage collections, both for the general public, and expert historians. (7)