Mediating Technology : How ICT influences the morality of the digital generation | Bats, Valkenburg, Verbeek, International Conference on Engineering Design 2013
Research Question: In what way does ICT interfere with moral reasoning?
Goal: study the perceived impact of ICT on daily lives and the level of cognitive moral reasoning in ICT-related situations.
Method: focus groups and diary research.
Conclusions:
We observed, conform our theoretical outline, that when ICT is considered impersonal and does not strongly obstruct the own perception of freedom most of our respondents reasoned in a consequentialist and pre-conventional way. Simultaneously, when ICT mediates in personal relations and interferes more with the own perceived freedom, higher moral arguments were demonstrated. This was particularly the case with the older age group. They were better able to identify the impact of ICT on their lives.
Introduction
The central objective of this article is to provide an insight into the relationship between the ICT-context and moral reasoning. Within contemporary moral psychology the connection between the affective part and the cognitive part of morality is a significant research theme (Sie, 2009). In this article we will focus mainly on the latter, cognitive morality.
Theory
Kohlberg (1984) identifies three levels of moral reasoning, the pre-conventional, conventional and post-conventional level, which have an upward development in an invariant hierarchical order (Boom, Wouters, Keller, 2007). Individuals process information about a situation according to a pre-existing moral schema or reasons. These moral reasons are different at each moral development level. Subsequently, these three levels are divided in two different stages each; six stages in total. Kohlberg argues that the hierarchal transition from stage to stage works as a result of moral conflict and confrontation together with exposure to higher level moral reasoning. Because of the exploratory character of this study we will limit our analysis to the three comprehensive levels. (3)
Level 1:
In the pre-conventional level the individual is exclusively concerned with the self in an ego-centric manner. The individual assumes that a powerful authority hands down rules that he or she has to obey. Punishment is a central motive for behaving a certain way, which means that individuals see morality as something external to themselves (Crain, 1985). In this level, next to authority, the individual’s own interest, possible reciprocity and future gains are the basis for judging moral dilemmas. (3)
Level 2:
In the second level, the conventional level, identification with the values of community and family are essential. Good interpersonal relationships becomes important, and not only because of a possible return of investment. Individuals start to believe that people should live up to social expectations and roles. Good behavior means having good motives and interpersonal feelings such as love and empathy (Crain, 1985). There is an emphasis on conformity and how behavior effects relations between people. In addition, the individual becomes more widely concerned with society as a whole. Social conventions and maintaining law and order is crucial for a functioning society. (3)
Level 3:
In the post-conventional level, people start to think about society in a very theoretical manner. In the post-conventional level laws are regarded as social contracts rather than decrees. Individuals recognize that different social groups have different social values and believe that all people would agree on (1) the existence of certain rights and (2) democratic processes for changing unfair laws and conditions (Crain, 1985). In most cases different perspectives between people should be respected as unique traits. In this level individuals will follow internalized principles of justice, even if it conflicts with existing laws and rules. It is understand as advanced existential or reflective (Boom, 2011). The post-conventional level complies with a higher existential and personally binding moral reasoning which distances itself from convention, outside force and self-interest. In terms of Piaget’s epistemic types of cognitive knowledge it asks for “necessary” cognitive knowledge to analyze a moral situation. (3)
Theoretical predictions:
1) "With the ever-growing possibilities, our ICT mediated actions are clearly increasing, and so are the consequences of these actions. The specific environment and the ICT-context could enable new and unethical behavior (Roberts and Wasieleski, 2012) partly because it is becoming increasingly difficult to predict the results of our actions (van der Wal, 2011)." (4) 2) "Furthermore, a technology-mediated context may feel less personal and in an impersonal situation utilitarian rational may be more easily demonstrated because an action is not directed to a specific person or is merely the (unforeseen) side effect of another action (Greene et al., 2001). Because of the mediation of ICT that creates an abstract context for users, these users may lose grip with the behavioral subjectivity and validity of their acts." (4)
Research questions:
RQ1: In terms of moral reasoning, which relation exists between morality and ICT among adolescents and young adults?
RQ2: In what way does ICT influences moral reasoning among adolescents and young adults?
Conclusion
What interests me specifically are reports on how people have the feeling that technology sometimes takes over control.
The focus groups and diaries clearly showed that adolescents and young adults spend a lot of time and effort to position ICT in their lives in a satisfying way. The norm that technology should not control their life is essential in this effort. However, especially group 20-24 acknowledged that this norm was often difficult to comply, with group 20-24 stating that they did not always have control over their ICT use and that technology can ‘take over’. (8)
That aspect is most clear in the older age group:
Respondents from group 20-24 were able to reason on a higher moral level, according to Kohlberg’s model. They clearly provided examples out of their own lives about how ICT could provoke certain behavior which they did not like. They were better able to judge the implications of technology like certain behavior of which they thought it was important to minimalize because of the personal and societal implications. They mentioned the loss of control to ICT and its impersonality. (8)
Although from this cross-section study no conclusions about causality can be made, the indication that unclear consequences for society and impersonality relates to lower moral reasoning seems consistent with the idea that when the consequences of our ICT activities are more difficult to overlook it could lead to a decreasing moral.
E.g. downloading does not have a direct social relevance (impersonality) and here all age groups score similar. Consider:
When impersonal ICT situations were discussed this perceived loss of freedom was considered less relevant by the respondents, like downloading content, only minor differences between the groups were found. In this case both groups showed predominantly consequential moral reasoning. Only the outcome of free content mattered, and the easy access and opportunity justified the action. (9)
The theoretical aspect of technology mediation could be used to clarify this explanation. As Swierstra (2011) specified: technology changes the framework of action. The respondents indicated that sometimes it feels as ICT provoked certain behavior which has influence on, for example, interpersonal relationships. For group 15-19 this was foremost important if it concerns behavior, which influenced the own social circle, while for group 20- 24 this was also important, if it undermined general values. In both cases, not the possibilities of technology are experienced but, ironically, a reduced freedom because of this technology. Dorrestijn (2012) explains that this freedom from technology should not be seen as a state of independence, but as a situation in which the user has control of the situation and its consequences. The focus groups and the diaries showed that this loss of control was mostly perceived when technology was capable of directly affecting personal relations. (8)