Religion after Detraditionalization: Christian Faith in a Post-Secular Europe - Boeve
Abstract:
The category of detraditionalization, in combination with the category of pluralization, it is argued, offers a conceptual framework to think anew the 'transformation of religion' in so-called postsecular Europe. Subsequently the impact of this transformation on Christian faith is investigated, and what the appropriate theological response may be. Beyond mere continuity and discontinuity between faith and contemporary context, the main lines are sketched of what the author calls a 'theology of interruption', understood as both 'interrupted theology' as well as 'interrupting theology'.
Post-Secular Europe
Zero-sum-theory of the secularization thesis: modernization excludes religion from modern society and culture. Therefore, the more religion, the less modernization and vice versa. (110)
The detraditionalization of Europe
'Desecularization'
"Modernization in Europe has caused a transformation of religion, not its disappearance" (p.101). Minder institutioneel en meetbaar, meer diffuse aanwezigheid religie.
Thesis Yves Lambert: "among young Christians a religious renewal is noticeable (...) there is an increase in 'believing without belonging' (p.102). And, 'the phenomenon of 'believing without belonging', as coined by Grace Davie, is becoming a permanent feature in the more secular countries of Europe."
Na algemene scepsis tegenover religie van de jaren 60 en 70, is er een selectieve terugkeer naar traditionele waarden. "The exceptions here are the ethical items which affect the private self-determination, as for example, the use of soft drugs, abortion and euthanasia, homosexuality, suicide, and so on. There are indications for a selective re-activation of traditions and a new openness to religion."
From 'secularization' to 'detraditionalization' and 'individualization'
Explanation of the concepts 'religion' and 'believing without belonging'
Religion: "to classical, traditional religion (most often even Christianity) and institutional religion (Christian Churches), but also to a kind of general religious attitude, maybe better referred to as 'religiosity', often more general than, or even to be distinguished from, Christian religion. In relation to the latter, 'believing without belonging' is probably too strong a definition'"
Believing without belonging: "As a general category, however, one can legitimately ask whether 'believing without belonging' really has to do with 'believing'. As a result of what Lambert coins as 'pluralistic secularization', one may therefore suggest that terms such a 'longing without belonging' or 'religiosity without tradition' serve to better describe the individualized 'off-piste' search for spirituality through which individuals strive to construct answers to questions of ultimate meaning and religious wonder."
"But neither can we deny secularization understood as the process of 'de-institutionalization' and 'individualization/subjectivization' of religion resulting in the transformation of religion in Europe. As a matter of fact, one could even suggest that the current situation may well be the realization of this process. The 'pluralistic secularization' (Lambert) of Europe results in a multi-faceted religious panorama in which traditional religions along with new religious movements both seem to find their place." (p 103).
"The term 'post-secular' describes the current European society along with the term 'detraditionalization' instead of 'secularization' (which in one way or another continues to refer to the secularization hypotheses), as a tool to refer to this process. Detraditionalization as a term hints at the socio-cultural interruption of traditions (religious as well as class, gender, ... traditions), which are no longer able to pass themselves from one generation to the next. The latter definitely applies to the Christian tradition in which the transmission process has been seriously hampered. Christianity no longer is the given and unquestioned horizon for individual and social identity. Identity formation is no longer the growing into pre-given ideological patterns, which condition one's perspective on meaning and social life. On the contrary, because of the absence of such unquestioned and quasi-automatic transmission of tradition, identity is no longer given but has to be constructed."
"detraditionalization is understood as a descriptive category, indicating the socio-cultural developments that have influenced Europe in modern times" (p. 105)
Detraditionalization and individualization: "In this regard, detraditionalization is the flip side of individualization. On the structural level, every individual is charged with the task of constructing his or her personal identity. Traditions no longer automatically steer this construction process, but are only possibilities together with other choices from which an individual must choose." (p. 105)
Reflexivity: In other words, personal identity has become more and more (structurally) reflexive. For each choice made, there are alternatives in relation to which it can either be questioned or argued for. Even the relation to tradition has changed and has become more reflexive due to the fact that those who choose traditional religions are all too aware of the fact that they do not have to choose this.
Cf. traditie als duidelijke ervaringshorizon, een sturende kracht waarin wij geworpen zijn. Wij kiezen onze traditie niet, wij zijn erin geworpen. De hedendaagse reflexiviteit van traditie staat hiermee op gespannen voet: zelfs bij tradities zijn wij ons ervan bewust dat wij hiervoor kiezen, en niet iets anders. Dat is andere relatie tot traditie, die de transmissie van traditie minder vanzelfsprekend maakt. Dit "keuze"-karakter lijkt me ook een fragmenterend karakter te hebben: we nemen wat aspecten van de ene traditie, wat aspecten van de andere traditie.
The pluralization of religion in Europe
"Often the many religious traditions are conceived of as reservoirs of narratives, rituals, practices, worldviews, etc. from which one can choose in order to construct one's religious identity." (p.106)
"To construct their religious identities, individuals use (fragments from) old and new religious traditions, which have been loosened from their original traditional connection." (p. 107)
"In doing so, the idea of 'tradition' itself, as a given into which people initiate themselves in order to receive their identity rather than constructing it, becomes lost."
"a significant amount of people can be qualified as post-Christians, religious individualists, for whom religion no longer has a link to being initiated in a religious tradition anterior to one's identity, but is the way one deals with a kind of basic religiosity, attached to contingency experiences, etc." (108).
Böckenförde-paradox: "European democracies consume their ideological (re)sources without being able to substantially renew them" (p. 108)
Gegeven: detraditionalizering, en pluralisering van religie. Wat is het gevolg? Twee tegengestelde posities:
1) Relativize bonds to Christianity and claim to anteriority. 'religiosity without belonging' 2) "turn to more traditionalist and fundamentalist positions, stringently reinforcing the bond between social and individual identity and the traditoin transmitted from the past. Their appeal to a 'pure' tradition, a construction from the past which never historically existed, however, also jeopardizes the very concept of tradition, both in its active and passive meaning."
"are there ways to productively engage this structural reflexivity in theological reflections on what it is to be a Christian today, in a religiously transformed society? Or does this structural reflexivity indeed automatically lead towards 'religiosity without belonging' and its counterpart in traditionalism and fundamentalism?"
Christian faith in a post-secular Europe
What is the meaning of something-ism (ietsism)? Is it an authentic religious experience? Or a new form of Christian faith?
Erik Borgman: "this new situation (i.e. the transformation of religion in Europe) should be theologically interpreted as the transformation or metamorphosis of God (the 'transfiguration' of God), namely, the new way in which God relates to history and society." (p.111)
Borgman: "human beings are all too aware that they are themselves responsible for their identity and life, but at the same time, that this responsibility overtakes them, and that meaning and happiness are rather given than constructed." (p. 111)
Borgman tries to argue that the current diffuse religious situation can be interpreted as a new manner in which God relates through the world. Consequently, he tries to read the contemporary context in continuity with Christian faith. However:
"First of all (and this has become obvious from the first part of this contribution), due to detraditionalization, this factual overlap does not exist anymore, and what is more, because of pluralization one can even question whether theology's dialogue with the context is still to be conceived of as between two partners needing to be correlated." (p. 113)
Boeve's contribution: "I am convinced that when the aspect of pluralization is also taken into account, together with the renewed cultural sensibilities for particularity, contextuality, historicity, and contingency as well as otherness and difference, a recontextualization of Christian tradition may lead to a self-conscious and profiled Christian faith, open to dialogue and challenged by otherness." (p. 114)
Towards a radical hermeneutical theology of Christian particularity
Uneasiness with a particular Christian faith: "this uneasiness also pertains to Christian 'faith', answering the appeal of the Other, revealed in this concrete history, contingency and particularity: the appeal of a God who both comes into history, and escapes it" (p. 115)
Cf. de Heideggeriaanse structuur van de gift van het zijn. Vraag: is de structuur van verborgenheid theologisch, of hermeneutisch? Oftewel, behalve dat een dergelijke theologie hermeneutisch genoemd kan worden, tot op welke hoogte kan Heidegger's filosofie van het zijn theologisch genoemd worden?
One aspect of detraditionalization is diminishing communicability: the "Christian experience of reality can only be adequately communicated to those who have a minimal familiarity with the Christian narrative or are at least prepared to become acquainted with it."
The recontextualization of theology through the category of interruption
"What I would like to stress here is not only that the category of interruption structures the mediation between tradition and context in an adequate contextual manner, but also that it does so in a theologically legitimate manner" (p. 119)
"the category of interruption holds continuity and discontinuity together in a tensive relationship. Interruption is after all not identical with rupture, but implies that what is interrupted does not simply continue as though nothing had happened" (p. 119).
a) "The confrontation with religious otherness alerts the Christian narrative very specifically to the particularity of its own truth claim and interrupts any such pretence towards absoluteness" (p. 119) b) "In line with contextual cirtical consciousness, the confrontation with the other interrupts the Christian narrative at the point where it tends to close itself off hegemonically." (p. 120)
"Only when interruption is also a theological category can the Christian narrative allow itself to be interrupted and become a narrative of interruption. As a theological category, interruption structures the way in which we reflect upon the relationship in which God is engaged with God's creation. (...) in the concreteness of particular histories, the God professed by Christians repeatedly breaks open the narratives of human beings and communities, including the ones about this God. (...) For Christians, professing Christ is then also the interruption par excellence of history. It is this God and this interruption that the Christian narrative bears witness to, a witness that never attempts to apprehend or comprehend this God or this interruption." (p. 120-1)
"From a theological-epistemological point of view, the encounter with the other is in fact the place where God's interruption can be revealed and where the borders of one's own Christian narrative in naming this God can become visible That is why today inter-religious communication, for instance, is not only a contextual necessity, but also a theological one." (p. 121)
"The 'peculiarity' of the Christian truth claim, therefore, is that Christians cannot claim the truth, and yet they are always already living in relation to it in a radical-hermeneutical tension that concerns God and is interrupted by God. It is this claim which is problematic for contemporary post-Christian religiosity, for it is a claim of faith in a God who interrupts our longing for comfort, wholeness, security." (p. 121).
"A radical theological hermeneutic of contingency thus implies an equally radical theological hermeneutic of suspicion. Certainly, wherever diversity and otherness are being stealthily reduced to the multiplicity of market goods or diabolized by an inviolable hegemonic truth claim, Christians need to interrupt on behalf of God the 'Interrupter'." (p. 122)
Keywords and -insights:
- Detraditionalization leads to opposing reactions: relativism/constructive identities vs. restorative accentuation of traditions and communities.
- The latter reaction risk degrading into neo-traditionalism, the nostalgia for a past that did not even exist.
- Recontextualization