Enculturating Algorithms | by Rafael Capurro, Nanoethics 13:131-137, 2019

@algorithms @digital @ethics

Author: Rafael Capurro

This paper has some nice insights, but I'm in a rush right now, so I'll only record some highlights. Worth it to revisit later.

What is ethically at stake when dealing with algorithms becomes part of human mores? What is the nature of this entanglement between human mores and algorithms? (132)

The present casting of homo digitalis ourselves as [6] opens the possibility of reifying ourselves algorithmically. (132)

Ethical hesitation in decision-making:

According to Ostermeier, many of the catastrophes of the last century were due to a lack of time for hesitation that would have given place for thinking over and for reflection [11, p. 99]. Algorithms know nothing about hesitation. In fact, they know nothing at all and they do not learn. They are heteronomous. (133)

When it comes to human beings, their being is a matter of interpretation who one is as a player with other players in the drama of life. (133)

Algorithms can reify us digitally. What role do these digital reifications play in our lives?

Algorithms implement digital reifications of who we are and what roles we play in the drama of life. Ethics of algorithms faces the challenge of the extent to which and under what rules we (who?) want algorithms to play a role in the human interplay on the stage that is the world. (133)

Enculturating algorithms

The implicit and explicit moral and legal norms and values of human interplay can today be reified in the digital medium through algorithms that shine back onto the players when personal digital data of whatever kind are at stake. (133)

From the perspective of algorithmic search, we are nothing but a bunch of data. Algorithms can map and track our digital identities, but nobody can guarantee that such a public persona matches me and not someone else. (134)

Auto-immunity, using algorithms against algorithms:

Algorithms might strengthen or weaken our ‘symbolic immune systems’ such as moral and legal norms and values [14]. As in the case of biological immune systems, we must pay attention to the changing environment not only by using but also by observing algorithms, using them, paradoxically, for such a purpose [15]. To be digitally observed, or not to be, that is the question. (134)

What does resistance against algorithms look like? @Nissenbaum 's obfusciation:

Protecting us from algorithms means to resist becoming identified by algorithmic observation everywhere, all the time, using and being (ab-)used, for instance, through mobile phones. To resist means learning to reveal and conceal ourselves through the kind of guerrilla tactics that Brunton and Nissenbaum call ‘obfuscation’ [17]. (134)

The ethical and legal challenge is about explicitly enculturating algorithms, paying attention to the contexts in which, for what, by whom, and for whom they are created and used. (134)

The temporality of algorithms:

Unveiling the temporality shaped by algorithms is a key task for a future phenomenology of algorithms.

Algorithms need to be hermeneutically questioned:

Algorithms are reified social practices whose norms and regulations must be hermeneutically questioned and reconsidered in view of the operations and intentions of their users and producers [21].

One page 134 Capurro has attention for the contrast with eastern culture.

Enculturating autonomous cars

From Johnson DG, Miller KW (2008) Un-making artificial moral agents. Ethics Inf Technol 10:123–133; from page 28:

‘Obviously, there are levels of abstraction in which computer behaviour appears autonomous, but the appropriate use of the term “autonomous” at one level of abstraction does not mean that computer systems are, therefore, “autonomous” in some broad and general sense. We should not allow the existence of a particular level of abstraction to determine the outcome of the broader de bate about the moral agency of computer systems.’

Enculturating algorithms is a key issue for ADS:

In other words, enculturating algorithms is a key issue with regard to autonomous driving. With the invention of the car, we defined ourselves as car drivers following the long tradition of reflection on the tasks and qualities (kybernetes) of steering ships ( or the 6000-year tradition of learning how to handle horses [30]. (135)

Prospects

Interpreting algorithms as ways of being means taking a critical stance with regard not only to calculating thinking in general and algorithms in particular, but also to our belief in them that becomes exacerbated in the twenty-first century. (136)

Haha, Hegel quote!

‘Since calculation is so much of an external and therefore mechanical business, it has been possible to manufacture machines that perform arithmetical operations with complete accuracy. It is enough to know this fact alone about the nature of calculation to decide on the merit of the idea of making it the main instrument of the education of spirit/mind, of stretching spirit/mind on the rack in order to perfect it as a machine.’ [32, pp. 181–182].

Conclusion, a defence of human thinking, against stretching it "on the rack of algorithmically controlled computers":

In the last 200 years, the concept of spirit/mind (Geist) has been the object of theoretical and practical critique in such a way that it lost its meaning as dynamis or capacity for changing the relationship between ourselves and the world. The Marxian demand to change the world instead of just interpreting it [33] begs the question, since no change of the relationship between ourselves and the world is possible if not based on a previous recasting of it. Geist, our historical mind, is our original and originating capacity for such recasting. Only if we acknowledge this capacity can we cope with the challenges of an age in which human mental creativity is to be ostensibly perfected as an algorithm. In doing so, we give up what enables us to originate different castings of ourselves and the world, including the present digital one. The power of calculation might become a source of liberation by enculturating algorithms instead of stretching human mental creativity on the rack of algorithmically controlled computers