The Onlife Manifesto 2015 | edited by Floridi

Commentaries

Floridi

This citation describes the overall tactic of the manifesto: philosophy is conceptual design.

I suggested the phrase “Building the raft while swimming” in order to emphasise the radical nature of the philosophical task ahead of us, rather than stressing any anti-foundationalist philosophy. Understanding philosophy as conceptual design means giving up not on its foundationalist vocation, but rather on the possibility of outsourcing its task to any combination of logico-mathematical and empirical approaches. (22)

also cf. Pagallo: "our concept reengineering exercise" (33)

Mireille Hildebrandt

Though computational techniques may indeed require such digitization, the reduction of the analogue flux of life to digitizable bites has its own drawbacks. Hayles (1999) has described the flaws and the costs of early cybernetics in her How we became posthuman, focusing on the attempt to disembody and dematerialize information, abstracting from the content and the semantics to gain a better view of its processing and syntactics. (27)

Though we cannot deny that this attempt has yielded unprecedented results, we must also acknowledge that at some point the processed information must be reintegrated in what Stiegler (pace Husserl) has called our own primary retention (individual memory), to acquire meaning and to be part of our lifeworld (Stiegler 2013). (28)

Refs:

  • Hayles, N. K. 1999. How we became posthuman. Virtual bodies in cybernetics, literature, and informatics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
  • Stiegler, B., Hildebrandt M., O’Hara K., Waidner M. (eds.) 2013. Die Aufklärung in the Age of Philosophical Engineering. In The value of personal data. Digital Enlightenment Forum Yearbook 2013. Amsterdam: IOS Press 2013, p. 29–39.

Yiannis Laouris

I elaborate on the need to re-engineer the concept of life and how the emerging immortality of artifacts and information exerts pressure on achieving immortality of the mind and/or of the human; the blurring of concepts like “being human” or “being alive.” (31)

ICTs and the challenge of direct democracy: how can millions meaningfully participate in democracy?

We must guarantee that the individual will have access to all relevant information, alternatives, arguments, and predicted futures that might emerge according to the choices s/he makes. We will probably need to invent new liquid forms of democracy in which ideas can flow from crowds and are shaped through a process of open deliberation. Future citizens should somehow become capable of choosing alternatives by harvesting their collective intelligence and wisdom rather than allowing the personal interests and pathetic behaviors of individuals to prevail in the decisionmaking process. Since technology will be absolutely essential, the democratization of the processes of design and development of such new technologies also becomes a fundamental requirement. In addition, we must guarantee access and simplicity of interfaces. (32)

Ugo Pagallo

The background interests of this author seem to accord with mine, despite having mainly a legal background.

From http://www.lawandtechnology.net/ugo-pagallo/:

Ugo is also chairing the 2019 AI4People project, namely the first global forum in Europe on the Social Impacts of Artificial Intelligence set up by the European Institute for Science, Media, and Democracy (Atomium) in Bruxelles (2019)

Main interests: Artificial Intelligence, law, network and legal theory, governance, and information technology law (specially data protection law and copyright).

Found a link to a conference where Pim spoke: http://www.lawandtechnology.net/workshop-ai-robotics-and-responsibility-in-the-age-of-big-data/

Pim's talk was about "Mediated action and the risk of entrapment". Sounds interesting, but I can't find a publication.

Reaction to 1.1 which states that "the constraints and affordances of the computational era profoundly challenge some of modernity's assumptions."

§ 1.1 First, it is all about our understanding of the past and, hence, the very notion of “modernity.” I do agree that some assumptions of modernity are simply dead and, yet, thinking about the work of Spinoza, or of Leibniz, rather than Descartes and some advocates of the Enlightenment, I would say “Modernity is dead” and, still, long live Modernity and some of its venerable fruits! In Heideggerian terms, we should conceive the past as a matter of Gewesenheit, rather than Vergangenheit: Zuhanden, rather than passé depassé (Heidegger 1996). This different way of grasping what is gone reverberates on how we intend to address and project the future, namely the second of my problems: “this Manifesto aims to start a reflection on the way in which a hyperconnected world calls for rethinking the referential frameworks on which policies are built” (see the preface). (33)

Whilst the conclusion of our Manifesto mentions the relevance of “default settings and other designed aspects of our technologies,” in order to “respect and protect attentional capabilities,” we should have further insisted on this point, so as to test our debt to Modernity and, hence, to assess what is specific to the normative dimension of our concept reengineering exercise. (33)

The focus nevertheless seems to be too much on governance for my purposes.

Judith Simon

Nowadays, as the Manifesto correctly notes, new informational agents, new powerful players have emerged on the knowledge/power axes: big internet companies, such as Facebook, Google or Amazon, as much as the more hidden ones controlling the backbone of the internet traffic. These actors occupy enormously powerful nodes, and function as “obligatory passage points” (Callon 1986) in epistemic, just as much as in economic and political matters. (35)

Je kan wetten blijven verzinnen tot je een ons weegt, maar je moet ook de duivel van het consumentisme aanpakken: mensen snappen niet waarom je niet je data zou verpatsen voor een beetje gemak. Wat is daar zo ethisch problematisch aan? (Onderliggend, de vraag van het paternalisme: moeten mensen tegen zichzelf beschermd worden?)

Blaming the powerful agents alone however, merely requesting new laws and regulations will fall short of offering a remedy to these power games. Instead, we need to understand power as a network effect, power as a result and a cause of distributed agency—and therefore accept partial responsibility for the state of affairs ourselves. As Evgeny Morozov has aptly put it, we—each and every one of us—also need to confront the temptations of information consumerism. As long as we willingly trade our data for free or cheaper products, regulations will not solve the problems: we collude in the game ourselves. Morozov (2013) writes: “European politicians can try imposing whatever laws they want but as long as the consumerist spirit runs supreme and people have no clear ethical explanation as to why they shouldn’t benefit from trading off their data, the problem would persist.”

The power of internet giants depends on the compliance of the masses. The hyperconnection of our world also entails possibilities for "distributed collective action":

In our hyperconnected world, the alliances between the powerful critically depend upon the compliance of the masses. However, it has also never been easier to quit playing along, to change the game through distributed collective action. In principle, we have access to a wide variety of products and services and we can and should be more careful in our choices. We need to understand the relationship between buying and being sold and act accordingly. As consumers, we need to acknowledge that once we stop being willing to pay for products and services, we are paying simply with a different currency—our data. We need to act as citizens as well. We need to mobilize our politicians to stand up to our defense, to counter the on-going attacks to our privacy and to fulfill their responsibilities as our representatives in drafting and enforcing laws and regulations to secure our freedom. (36)

See Morozov 2013:

  • Morozov, E. 2013. The price of hypocrisy. Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung. http://www.faz.net/aktuell/feuilleton/debatten/ueberwachung/information-consumerism-the-price-ofhypocrisy-12292374.html . Accessed 05 Aug 2013. Highlight:

As consumers, we need to acknowledge that once we stop being willing to pay for products and services, we are paying simply with a different currency—our data. (36)