Heidegger - Principle of Reason
Leap
POR4: But it is even odder that we never wonder about the slowness with which the principle of
reason came to light. One would like to call the long time it needed for this its \"incubation period\": two thousand three hundred years for the positing [Set.zen] of this simple principle [Satz].
This order in history is seen only in recollection, from out o the leap.' (PoR 4)
Incubation
The first of the five main points was fleetingly touched upon when we were talking about the incubation period of the principle of reason. What the principle of reason states in its ordinary formulation has in some fashion always resounded in Western thought. Yet measured historiographically, two thousand three hundred years were needed until the principle of reason came to light and let itself be set up as a fundamental principle. Our reference to the unusual incubation period of the principle of reason included the following question: \"Where and
how did the principle of reason sleep for so long and presciently dream what
was unthought in it?\'\' We let the question go without an answer. (POR 53-4)
54: Namely, if the principle of reason is a principle of being, then the incubation of the principle of reason is connected with what the principle in truth says, namely, that being is really still sleeping. With this we in no way mean to say that there was no being during the incubation period of the principle of reason. The history of Ancient and Medieval metaphysics testifies to the fact that being has always already come to light in the questioning of beings as such. What we said about the sleeping of being means to say that being as such has not yet awakened so that It looks upon us from out of its wakened essence. So long as the essence of being withdraws, we also cannot bring into view what it presciently dreamed. However, if we experience the principle of reason in the sense of a leap into being as such , then we are afforded another perspective. What we called the incubation period of the principle of reason now reveals itself as an epoch in which being qua being withdraws. The essence of being conceals itself in this withdrawal. This in no way means that being simply remains concealed. For the shining of being is in play in the appearing of beings as soon as beings as such appear in their being. (...) And even if we thereby have an inkling of the essence of nature and grasp what we have inkling of in a definitive representation or even in a concept proper, then the essence of nature still keeps itself concealed, as does being. Yet the self-concealing of the essence of being at the same time is precisely the manner that being bestows itself, proffers itself to us in beings. From this proffering comes the Geschick, by virtue of which there is the incubation of the principle of reason.
Kehre
54-55: 'incubation must be due to the fact that, in the meantime, the Geschick of being has taken a turn, presumably in the sense that being as such has awakened and come to the fore. But it is precisely at this point that the end of the incubation period of the principle of reason does not come to an end. Indeed something in the Geschick of being has taken a turn, but in a totally different sense.
55: By being explicitly elevated to one of the supreme fundamental principles, the principle of reason first came to the fore and, so to speak, blossomed as a principle having the character of a principle. The incubation period of the principle of reason thereby came to an end. The incubation of the principle of reason happens by virtue of the Geschick of being, a Geschich in which being as such withdraws. Now if the incubation of the principle of reason finds its end with the setting up of the principle of reason as one of the supreme fundamental principles, thenĀ· this ending of theThe process determining a new epoch of the withdrawal is one in which being adapts itself to the objectness of objects, but which , in its essence as being, thereby withdraws. This epoch characterizes the innermost essence of the age we call modernity.
68 'Through this relinquishing the leap regains the leaping-off realm. The leap relinquishes this realm and nevertheless does not leave it behind. Through this relinquishing the leap regains the leaping-off realm in a new manner, and indeed not just incidentally, but necessarily. The leap is essentially a backward-glancing leap.'
68: 'Rather, its nature is such that it lays claim to us in our essence. Take notice: in our essence. This is to say that the claim of being first ushers humans into their essence. Only in the Geschick of being and from out of it are we Geschick-like, and as beings that are Geschick like, we are compelled to find what is fitting -- and that means at the same time to be enmeshed in missing what is fitting.'
Geschick needs us
68: 'Yet in view of what there is to think, all thinking must remain acquainted with an experience that is never only an experience of particulars and thus never lets itself be briefly articulated: seldom enough do we find ourselves expressly addressed by that which lays claim to us in our essence -- and that means needs us.'
68-9: 'If we spoke of "the history of being," then this way of speaking only makes sense if we think of history in terms of Geschick qua withdrawal, but not if we reverse it and, as is customary, represent Geschick in terms of history as a happening that has the character of a constantly on-going process.'
Het horen van de betekenis van zijn
69: 'What is called "being" addresses us from out of this self-revealing and as this self-revealing. We cannot arbitrarily make up on our own and, by decree, establish what "being" means [heiBt]. What "being" means is harbored in the bidding [GeheiB] that speaks in the basic words of Greek thinking. We can never scientifically demonstrate or hope to demonstrate what this bidding says. We either hear it or don't hear it. We can prepare for this hearing or neglect this preparation.'
Dialectics of the jump
86'As the ones bestowed by being in the Geschick of being we stand -- and indeed do so in accordance with our essential nature -- in a clearing and lighting of being. But we do not just stand around in this clearing and lighting without being addressed [unangesprochen]; rather we stand in it as those who are claimed [Anspruch] by the being of beings. As the ones standing in the clearing and lighting of being we are the ones bestowed, the ones ushered into the time play-space.
88-9 - 'Nevertheless the history of Western thinking shows itself as the Geschick of being when and only when we glance back upon the whole of Western thinking from the point of view of the leap and when we recollectively preserve it as the Geschick of being that has-been. At the same time we can prepare for the leap only by speaking in terms of the history of being, a history that has been experienced in terms of Geschick. The leap leaves the realm from which one leaps while the same time recollectively regaining anew what has been left such that what has-been becomes, for the first time, something we cannot lose. That into which the leap anticipatorily leaps is not some region of things present at hand into which one can simply step. Rather, it is the realm of what first approaches as worthy of thought. But this approach is also shaped by the traits of what has-been, and only because of this is it discernible.' ]
Spiel
14: 'The enigma does not lie in the title, as though we were playing an empty game with words.'
Over het gevaar van het spel in de moderne tijd. Onze essentie staat op het spel. PoR 30-1: 'So we see the extreme odd position of modern humanity, a position the likes of which runs counter to all the popular sentiments that belong to the pedestrian notions we rund around with, as though blind and deaf: the claim of the mighty Principle of rendering reasons withdraws the subsistence from contemporary humanity. We could also say that the more decisively humans try to harness the "mega-energies" that would, once and for all, satisfy all human energy needs, the more impoverished becomes the human faculty for building and dwelling in the realm of what is essential. There is an enigmatic interconnection between the demand to render reasons and the withdrawal of roots.' [Essential -- What subsists]
86: 'The history of thinking is something different than the mere chronicle of changing opinions and doctrines of philosophers. The history of thinking is the bestowing of the essence of humans by the Geschick of being.'
- Dit aspect kan ik ook al aan het begin van mijn tekst gebruiken om het belang van Geschick uit te leggen.
111-2: 'If we aver that this play wherein being qua being finds its repose is an elevated and even the most elevated play, and is free from everything arbitrary, then very little has been said as long as this elevation and that which is most elevated about it is not thought in terms of the mystery of the play.'
112: 'So just as a ground/reason belongs to the being of a being, so it belongs to the play.'
112: 'Thus the nature of the play is determined as it is everywhere determined, namely as the dialectic of freedom and necessity within the horizon of ground/reason, of ratio, of rules, of rules of play, of calculus. Perhaps one might have more appropriately translated the Leibnizian sentence Cum Deus calculat fit mundus with: When God plays, a world comes to be.'
Play of withdrawal
31: 'It is important to see the form of the movement occurring in this lofty play between rendering and withdrawal. It is important to think for a moment about the provenance of this play. it is important to ask to what extent the inconspicuous reign of the mighty Principle of reason plays along in this play. It is important to note in which province we reside when we pursue and think through the principle of reason.'
54: Play of 'hide and seek': 'What we called the incubation period of the principle of reason now reveals itself as an epoch in which being qua being withdraws. The essence of being conceals itself in this withdrawal. This in no way means that being simply remains concealed. For the shining of being is in play in the appearing of beings as soon as beings as such appear in their being. This can be made clear through any randomly chosen everyday experience'
Play & Participation
86: 'As the ones bestowed by being in the Geschick of being we stand -- and indeed do so in accordance with our essential nature -- in a clearing and lighting of being. But we do not just stand around in this clearing and lighting without being addressed [unangesprochen]; rather we stand in it as those who are claimed [Anspruch] by the being of beings. As the ones standing in the clearing and lighting of being we are the ones bestowed, the ones ushered into the time play-space. This means we are the ones engaged in and for this play-space, engaged in building on and giving shape to the clearing and lighting of being -- in the broadest and multiple sense, in preserving it.'
-
Vervolgens, significant, Heidegger legt uit dat dit in SZ ook al op het spel stond, maar hij doet dat hier met een vergelijking van deze thematiek in termen van 'dialoog' die ik hierboven aanhaal! 'According to their essential nature, humans are thinking beings only insofar as they stand in a clearing and lighting of being. For, in our history of thinking this has meant to respond to the bidding of being, and on the basis of this response to have a dialogue about beings in their being. In the history of Western thinking this "having a dialogue" (dialegestai) develops into dialectics.' (PoR 86)
-
Dit kan ik verwerken aan het begin van dit essay om uit te leggen waarom Heidegger uberhaupt over Geschick gaat spreken, i.p.v. bijv. blijven bij de stem van het geweten.