"Alexa who am I?", Tech. mediation of moral meaning making | by Olya Kudina

-VAs * Short functional - Patient, never say no - Assisstive with impairment: autism, dyslexic, illiterate * No problem answering questions on turtles for 3h * Elderly: feel freer to share their issues without burdening relatives; machine does not mind - Also great for kids

  • Impatient responses
  • Parent in digital age: kids learn bossing around: giving commands

Tech also influence on our meanings: e.g. what does it mean to be a good parent (in a digital era?)

Appropriation of tech implies negotiation and explication of one's values.

Hermeneutic landscape: trying to make sense of tech.

Lambda scape: back and forth between action and perception.

We appropriate tech even before we have used it themselves. We get in touch with vision of the tech before its implementation. E.g. me with AVs. Somewhere in this process of appropriation our own values come up. E.g. Aha, apparently I care about privacy.

Co-shaping moral perceptions

Moral intuitions.

AV often have female voices. Predisposed to being disclosive and open. Soothing rather than bossy. We like the idea that we own the tech.

Does this reinforce gender stereotypes?

You're a slut! Sire: I'd blush if I could.

Does this interaction with a female voice mediate the perception of ourselves, gender roles?

Elle Hunt: faking it, how selfie dysmorphia is driving people to seek surgery

Filter mediate what we perceive as beauty. People seeks surgery to look like their filtered selves.

Co-shaping moral actions

Apple credit cards with discrimination case. Why? Trained on user of Goldman Sachs -> man historically got more credit limits. And it was men that mainly made big finance deals.

So implicitly tech takes over bias. We need oversight and intervention. Currently intervention is only manual when things go wrong.

Recommendation systems for high jobs; only men recommended. Gender difference between ways people pitch themselves on resumes.

Co-shaping values

Shape meaning of values, redirect them, reshape them.

Big concern about camera in the glass.

"Are you filming me right now?"

Changes interaction between humans.

Don't be a "Glasshole". She used comments on this Youtube video to get a feel for the cultural demography of comments.

Roberto Torez: wearable Itnernet is certainly the future, and rbably the nail in the coffin of social grace.

New topic:

20 years ago: internet as remembering everything, globally accessible.

"Why do I still need to learn history?"

Moral shift: now we have the right to be forgotten.

Digital era gave a new meaning to remembering compared to 18th century. Idem for forgetting.

2019: year of regulating people listening in through smart speakers. 1. People thought they were only sharing with a machine. 2. Alexa listened without the wake up word. Understood command to call someone. Transmitted private conversation over phone. * Misunderstanding any word as wake word.

How can we move beyond "Accept / Dont' use". Corporate story.

People do not like this. Find way to negotiate how to still use without losing privacy.

Example: Project Alias, related to voice assistants, on raspberry pi.

  • white noise filter
  • custom wake up

And vs the female voice: can there be a genderless VA? "Q" is a genderless VA.

Vs. top-down interaction: Zara the Supergirl. Human, sarcasm, laughter.

Interesting concept: organized irresponsibly.