John Loscerbo - Being and Technology

Bergen / recovering / saving

121:The Danger consists in the threat which concerns the essence of man in his relation to Being itself. This Danger is the Danger. As Heidegger will later clarify, the Danger is the Danger of Being (active genitive) - or in less poetical language, the \"selfconcealing\" of Being. Indeed, this is suggested in the sentence which directly follows the saying: \"this Danger is the Danger\". Heidegger writes: \"It (the Danger) conceals itself in the groundless Ground for all beings\". We wonder whether the word \"Abgrund\" may be thought of here as some sort of \"Abyss\" (the current translation) - granting that the term \"Abgrund\" is used by Heidegger as a designation of primordial Being - and this long before the essay \"Wozu Dichter\".26 Moreover, the term \"Abgrund\" is a designation of one sense of \"Ereignis\" , as we will show in Chapter III of Part Three, and names essentially the \"recovery\" of \"Ground\" (a traditional notion of \"Being\").' --> ZIE NOTEN 25 tm 27

122: 'In addition to these words regarding "the Danger", "Wozu Dichter" also offers a general sketch of what Heidegger will later call "this turn" ("Diese Kehre"). [n.31] The latter is conceived of as the "recovery" of Being as Gestell which, in the essay "Die Frage nach der Technik", is used to designate the "essence" of modern technology (cf. the following chapter). The "recovery" in question as it is outlined in "Die Kehre" comprises two movements: first a movement into the "Oblivion of Being", which is mirrored in and maintained by traditional Metaphysics; and secondly a movement out of this "Oblivion" to Being's "Wahrnis" (or "World" as "Geviert").'

123: 'For the English reader it would be helpful to point out that the word "Bergen" means "to save", "to shelter", but also, used reflexively, "to conceal".'

123: 'The attitude which drives man, that is, the technological Her-stellen or Wollen, which then constitutes the "Abkehr" or "Abschied gegen", must be revised -- a mode of comportment resembling Gelassenheit must take charge. And thus "being-without-protection" is converted into the saving. Certainly, this sounds correct. Nevertheless we must feel uneasy, for according to later texts it is Being which institutes, which initiates, what Heidegger will call "Das Rettende". (The "recovery" of Metaphysics is a matter for Being, even though man is "needed".)'

Danger and possibility of 'recovery'

The key word is "Blick", for as we will show, it is the "Einblick in das, was ist" which first accords a glimpse into the essence of Gestell, that is to say, accords the initial possibility of experiencing the Danger as the Danger which implies the possibility of "recovery".

The notion of essence (Gewähren)

244: 'By way of a first approach, Heidegger mentions only and quite generally the traditional notion of "essentia" [26] for the purpose of showing up the notion of essence as "that which accords" ("das Gewährende"). For Heidegger, Gestell, as the essence of technology, cannot signify a universal genus, applying randomly and indifferently to everything technological, for (...)'

Recovery & Gewesenes

208. 'It is not only Being itself, the self-preserving Gewesenes, which of itself withdraws, but it is equally Being which must initiate its own coming, its own arrival. From the years 1936 onward, it is clear that Heidegger's determination of Being, in order to be adequate to a "recovery" of the Metaphysics of subjectivity, must display Being in its self-determination -- which however is not to impose a sort of "dualism" into the Heideggerian Philosophy [n.284] but rather intends to assert a priority.'

--> Note 284: 'That between Being as self-determining and man. Actually, we admit, the term "self-determining" is precarious, for Being does not determine itself in independence from man. Moreover, we point out that this manner of priority has been noticed and well put by [BRON]'

Source of giving

212 -- 'This is obvious, for in order that "beings" appear in any manner whatsoever, a "place" for this appearing must already be given, or concomitantly given. However, it is the source of this giving which is crucial. As the text says: Being lights itself. Now it is tempting -- and it would even be consistent with other texts -- to identify this self-lighting of Being with the illuminated clearing itself for beings and then to proceed to interpret the passages in question as simply expressive of the "ontological difference". Furthermore, a yet greater temptation ensues, namely, to interpret the "ontological difference" as a simple declaration about the distinction between Being and beings, but as the difference (a third element as it were) which grounds the possibility of the union between Being and beings, [302noot] the difference as difference which grants the possibility of the distinction between the two, while at the same time providing for their unity (occasionally called the "Austrag").'

  • Nadruk op de bron van het geven. Kan niet simpelweg in termen van de ontologische differentie worden begrepen.

252: QUOTE HEIDEGGER: 'What happens (in the History of Being)? ... Nothing happens, but Ereignis comes to pass. Carrying out the Illumination, the Inception takes leave... The History of Being, which historically is known as Metaphysics, has its essence therein that a progression out of the Inception comes to pass. In this progression Being releases itself in beingness and refuses the Illumination of the primordialness of the Inception. Beingness, beginning as idea [Grieks] initiates the primacy of beings.' --> N II, pp. 585-486. N --> Nietzsche, Zweiter Band