Understanding the Pulse of Existence: An Examination of Capurro’s Angeletics | Fernando Flores Morador
@angeletics @digital @hermeneutics @information
Abstract (page 247):
The contribution of Rafael Capurro to the clarification of the uses of the concept of information has a conceptual as well a historical dimension; in this last sense, there are few philosophers of information that can follow the history of the concept of information in the works of the Classics with the accuracy and erudition of Capurro.
We find that his contribution embraces the following fields: a) a clear differentiation between subjective and objective information and as a consequence of that b) a clear differentiation between information as order in the universe, different from matter and idea.
But the contribution he made has not only been analytical and historical, it has also been creative, opening up for us an understanding of the phenomena of “information” through the differentiation between the act of interpretation of a message (hermeneutics) and the proper act of communication as a specific kind of intentional act.
Capurro has opened up a new discipline named “angeletics.” As we understand the Capurrian framework, the key idea is to comprehend how “a message produces changes in both the emissary and in the receptor.”
According to Capurro, a message has two dimensions; one is information, and the other intentionality. It is the aim of our short article to take a closer look at Rafael Capurro’s contribution to the understanding of these two sides of the message.
Have a look at Capurro R., & Holgate J. (Eds.) (2011). Messages and messengers: Angeletics as an approach to the phenomenology of communication. Von Boten und Botschaften. Die Angeletik als Weg zur Phänomenologie der Kommunikation, ICIE, 5. Munich, Germany: Fink .
Intentionality and Information
Basic point of departure:
Rafael Capurro introduces a connection between the objective character of a message as information, and the subjective character of it as intentionality According to Capurro, information is fragmented intentionality (Mitcham, 2000) Th is observation is crucial to understand the complex nature of human communication Capurro applies the Greek-influenced term angeletics to delimit this new field of study (Capurro, 2011)
A proper message does not only inform but also persuade:
Capurro’s work, the angeletic perspective leaves behind the opposition between object and subject and substitutes it with inter-subjectivity in context as noema and pragma; a proper message will then, not only “inform,” but also “persuade.” The double nature of the human act explains also the relationship that exists between thinking and acting, between the psychological state of engagement in acting and the state of acedia proper to the processing of pure data. (247-248)
Capurro's understanding of information, complementing its purely technical interpretation:
Since Norbert Wiener’s introduction of cybernetics (Wiener, 1950), the technical understanding of information states that information is “not matter, nor energy”; following Capurro we say instead: it is “order” (Flores, 2009). This is a consequence of the angeletical perspective, which does not contradict the technical definition but complements it. To understand Capurro’s angeletics, we introduce the opposition between “order” and “information” (as the measurement of “disorder”) in relation to probabilities. “Order” arises together with certainty while information is the expression of uncertainty. (248)
The technical interpretation of information:
Angeletics can help us to overcome the “solipsistic” trap of the technical theory of communication. The solipsism of the technical theory of communication has its deeper philosophical roots in Descartes’ “methodic doubt.” The technical approach reduces communication to pure information. The angeletical reduction of solipsism opens for the study of the relation of order as meaningfulness against the fragmentation of meaning. (248)
A "data" or angeletic interpretation of the unconscious (in Lacan's terms):
Of course, Lacan’s concern about the communicative dialectics between the Self and the other are intrinsically angeletic. For Lacan, the unconscious is identical to an entropic world of pure data. He considered that this vast universe was structured as a reservoir of signifiers (pure data), accepting that signification (intentionality) fluctuates freely. According to Lacan, signifiers (pure information) build chains without fixed meaningful (intentional) references. As such, the structure of the Unconscious becomes then a chaotic reality which makes impossible any meaningful analysis of its contents based on a priori interpretation criteria. (248)
Very vague and I don't know why we are talking about Lacan, but ok but whatever:
For Lacan, it is the imprinting of a rhythm in the message that creates the interpretation. That means that “order” arises throughout the establishment of a rhythm inside chaos. For Lacan, to be “an adult,” is to find balances and harmony in the unconscious chaos of the Self. (248)
The Rhythm of the Communicative Act
Still quite vague:
This rhythm depends on the intentional “weights” present in the communicative act. For instance, from the logical cliché “p implies q,” angeletics allows us to distinguish “p implies Q” in which the capital letter “Q” stands for a heavier (or lighter) intentional weight that reinforces (or undermines) the logical deduction with intentionality. (149)
Leader and follower...
Furthermore, in a dialogue, someone controls the initiative and this is independent of who is actually acting (speaking and writing). As a consequence of that, in every communication there is a leader and a follower. The relationship between leader and follower is determined by two communicative states: the initiative or communicative-state, and the waiting-state or prompt. (149)
Command vs dialogue (later also asking and wishing):
A “command” for example would be a communicative act that monopolizes both the communicating-moments and the waiting-moments. On the other hand, in a “regular conversation” these states are distributed between the participants in the dialog.
Intentionality as the Rhythm of Acting
I have no idea what this is about, really.
Some concluding words
There seems to be something there, but nothing is explained in detail. The link with ICT is not made explicit. There seems to be something interesting there though, but I should have a look at Capurro himself.
The work of Capurro allows us to see the field of informatics from a new and bright perspective. He connected the technical world of machine communication with the world of human existence starting with the statement that “information is fragmented intentionality.” This short proclamation made intentionality the inverse of information and opened the way for an operative understanding of the meaningfulness of discourse as a process; in other words, the succession of moments during which different intentional fragments of different weights are organized and reorganized to create sense. That is the starting point of Angeletics, the discipline that studies diachronically the reorganization of intentionality in a discourse. This is going to have important consequences for the future development of artificial intelligence as the formalized pulse of existence. (251)