The Unassailed Voice

From "The Web and the Unassailable Voice", by PETER WALSH.

Davis Museum and Art Center, Wellesley College, Wellesley, MA, USAwww.wellesley.edu/DavisMuseum/davismenu.html

@unassailed voice @voice @museum

This Unassailable Voice has, for many decades, been an essential part of the museum experience. It is a tone and attitude that pervades museum labels,brochures, exhibitions, catalogues, the guided tour, audio-visual presentations, and now Web sites. For the most part, it is both impersonal and disembodied: it is usually not a true human voice, connected to a real identity and personality, but a bureaucratic composite, in some ways closer to an IRS form than a living art historian or scientist. (77)

Those of us who actually work in museums, of course, realize that the Unassailable Voice is a myth. Like the floating head and thundering words of the Wizard of Oz, the Unassailable Voice is created by smoke and high-tech projections, designed to hide most of the human activity and frailties behind it (78)

The words of the Unassailable Voice, for all its apparent unflappable confidence, often represent a series of compromises: compromises between the views of different experts or compromises between simple, understandable, and apparently fixed explanations on the one hand and, on the other hand, the complex and ever changing, but richer and truer, accounts of reality. These complex and hid-den accounts, however, are the ones historians and scientists actually grapple with every day of their professional lives. (78)

Thus the Unassailable Voice has the flattened, vaguely evasive tone of a text created by committee. The voice itself often doesn’t even believe or understand what it says. Sometimes borrowed from a professional presenter or actor, the voice merely mouths words of a disembodied, anonymous authority. In most cases, this authority is not the property of a single person but a group. (78)

As you may have guessed by now, in my opinion, the Unassailable Voice is not an entirely benevolent presence in the museum. It tends to enhance the slightly patronizing, intimidating atmosphere found particularly in larger institutions,sometimes aided and abetted by their monumental architecture. This institutional atmosphere keeps some people out of museums altogether and vaguely irritates others. In its attempts to smooth over and conceal the complex and often con-tentious intellectual processes that really go into creating a museum, the string pullers behind the Unassailable Voice often edit out some of the most interesting and compelling parts of what a museum truly is. (78)

Instead, we should use the possibilities of the web for generating true dialogue:

I think that the World Wide Web has a great potential, one not yet fully exploited,of changing the partly falsified monologue most museums carry on with the world into an infinitely richer and truer dialogue (81)

Museums have traditionally ignored an important aspect of communication: that communication is not a monologue, but a dialogue. In order for true communication to exist, information must pass from both sides, like a conversation, so that each side can check and question the message. (83)