Notes on Wittgenstein's view on religion

@Wittgenstein @religion

Transcript "Sea of Faith" video, by Don Cuppitt

From 12:38 on, when discussing the "later" Wittgenstein. Wittgenstein's standpoint with respect to the ontological questions such as "what is the soul?", is that those questions rest on a language confusion that substantives correspond to some thing in the world. So Wittgenstein's own correspondence theory was also fundamentally complicit to this confusion.

"So what would become of morality and religion on this new point of view? Wittgenstein has a deep respect for the practice of morality and religion, but like Tolstoj he is deeply mistrustful of the theory. On the whole, he thinks of religious beliefs not as being factual, but in terms of the job they do in shaping in our lives. Until recently not much more was known until that. Recently surfaced notes show how deeply his thought about religion was embedded in everyday life."

"What is the use of studying philosophy (...) if it does not improve your thinking about the important questions of everyday life. It is possible even more hard to think honestly about your life and other people's life. The problem is that thinking about these things is not thrilling but downright nasty. God grant the philosopher insight in what lies in front of everyone's eyes. Not how the world is, is the mystical, but that it is. To renounce the pumps and vanities of this wicked world, just think what that would really involve. Who of us today even thinks of doing such a thing? We all want to be admired. Saint Paul said, "I die daily". Just think of what that must have meant. For all you and I can tell the religion of the future will be without any priests or ministers."

"Christianity is not a doctrine, not I mean a theory a theory of what has happened and will happen to the human soul, but a description of something that actually takes place in human life. For consciousness of sin is a real event, and so is despair and salvation through faith. Perhaps we can say, only love can believe the resurrection. This can come about only if you no longer rest your weight on the earth, but suspend yourself from heaven. Then everything will be different, and it will be no wonder if you can do things you cannot do now. A man who is suspended looks the same as one who is standing, but the interplay of forces within is nevertheless quite different, so he can act different from a standing man. An honest religious thinker is like a tightrope walker: it almost looks as if he is walking on nothing but air; his support is the slendest imaginable, and yet it is really possible to walk on it." (Quote from W himself)

C: "the answer to the riddle of life lies in the disappearance of the question, so he (W) patiently unravels our illusions and forces us to return to the ethical reality of the everyday. When we see that our common life is all, that realization is religion. Wittgenstein's point of view is very down to earth, and very agnostic. All we can see clearly is the way our language works in the games we play. So we can see how belief in God works and how it ought to shape our lives, but then we must stop at that."

"Wittgenstein is so clear that the belief in God requires conversion of life, thruthfulness, inner integrity. He is equally clear that that is all there is to be said. We must be cured of the old speculative metaphysical impuls. So what would you call him? Is this religious agnosticism? A mysticism of the everyday? Or simply that it is and always was just the truth of the matter?"