Tradition of the Immemorial

@tradition @transmission

Authors:

105

What is the ‘consitutive structure of all human tradition?’

What must be transmitted in order for tradition to be that: tradition. What must be transmitted is not one thing, but transmissibility itself.

‘It is, instead, the very unconcealment (a-lētheia), the very opening in which something like a tradition is possible.’

How is an unconcealment transmitted?

‘Implicit in every act of transmission, it must remain unfinished and, at the same time, unthematized.’

‘The tradition of transmissibility is therefore immemorially contained in every specific tradition, and this immemorial legacy, this transmission of unconcealment, constitutes human language as such.’

What is the impotentiality of history? In other words, what is the pure potentiality of a histories transmission, its tradition? Agamben: the immemorial of tradition.

--> the immemorial’s announcement of fulfillment.

‘Yet this means that the structure of language must be such that in all discourse, language can transmit—and betray, according the double sense of the Latin tradere, “to transmit”—the unconcealment that it is, leaving it concealed in what it brings to light.’

Philosophy ‘has presented knowledge as caught in a dialectic of memory and oblivion, unconcealment and concealment, alētheia and lēthē.’

106

‘The anamnestic structure of consciousness refers not to a chronological past or to ontic preeminence but, rather, to the very structure of truth. Being incapable of grasping itself and transmitting itself without becoming a remembered thing, this structure can preserve itself only by remaining immemorial in memory, by betraying itself, as Idea, in giving itself to sight—that is, in giving itself not as a teaching (didaskalia) but as a divine mission (theia moira). In modern terms: as historico-epochal opening.’

What is the tradition of truth?

‘Truth is, rather, a memory that, in its very taking place, forgets itself and destines itself, as both historical opening and chronothesis. This is why anamnesis is constituted in the Meno as a memory of “the time in which man was not yet man.” What must be grasped and transmitted is what is absolutely nonsubjective: oblivion as such.’

Chronothesis? The positing of times?

110

‘Let us now once again ask: how can there be a tradition of truth? How is it possible to transmit not a thing but an unconcealment?’

111

‘Today we find ourselves more and more thrown before this originary unconcealment of truth. We can neither transmit nor master this unconcealment, which, as a dark presupposition, is abandoned in the tradition to which it destines us.’

VS. Derrida, vgl. stuk dat ik heb geschreven over envoi and renvoi en trace.

‘The absence of a foundation for truth—that is, the radical crisis of the presupposition—is itself thought according to the form of the presupposition. (This is the structure of trace and originary writing in which our age has remained imprisoned. Truth is written—that is, it always remains presupposed and, at the same time, deferred in its very taking place.)’

Neoplatonisme en vormen van het ongeparticipeerde / het Ene / het onveronderstelbare

Quote van Proclus: ‘All that is unparticipated constitutes the participated out of itself. (...) For either it must remain fixed in sterility and isolation, and so must lack a place of honour; or else it will give something of itself, such that the receiver becomes a participant and the given subsists by participation.’

112

‘Have we moved even one step beyond this unparticipated threshing floor, where “no point can be distinguished from any other” and in which we nevertheless find both destiny and sending? Do we experience the principle of all things as anything other than an Unparticipated that destines and historically produces us as parts, im-parting us in its incessant participation?’

Hoofdvraag van Agamben, misschien mee aftrappen:

‘Are we capable of thinking of the tradition of truth and language as anything other than an unfounded and yet destining presupposition?’

‘The historico-social experience of our time is that of an original partition, an Ur-teilung, that has no appropriation to accomplish, a sending that has no message, a destiny that does not originate in any foundation.’ // *Not Ereignis, but Ent-eignis is central. *

Hier zie je duidelijk hoe Agamben’s eigen vertrekt tegen de achtergrond van Geschick. Geschick is precies de situatie waarin hij ons in een geschiedenis geworpen weten. Maar wanneer Geschichte Geschick wordt, lijken wij overgeleverd aan een historische zending die geen boodschap heeft, maar juist een verborgenheid bestemt, en die grondeloos is geworden, niets meer representeert.

‘Of the three categories by which Carl Schmitt articulates the political—“taking” (Nehmen), “dividing” (Teilen), and “pastoring” (Weiden)—Teilen is the one that is fundamental here. We are united only through our common participation in an Unparticipated; we are anticipated by a presupposition, but one without an origin; we are divided, without any inheritance.’

Kan bovenstaande gelezen worden in termen van het ordenen van Geschick?

113:

Met betrekking tot de blijkbare hedendaagse behoefte aan een gemeenschap zonder vooronderstellingen, met verwijzing naar Nancy en Blanchot, stelt Agamben:

‘Our time thus registers the demand for a community without presuppositions; yet without realizing it, it simultaneously maintains the empty form of presupposition beyond all foundations—presupposition of nothing, pure destination.’

‘This is the root of our discomfort and, at the same time, our only hope.’

115:

‘Are we capable today of no longer being philosophers of the letter (Buchstaben philosophen), without thereby becoming either philosophers of the voice or mere enthusiasts? Are we capable of reckoning with the poetic presentation of the vocation that, as a nonpresupposed principle, emerges only where no voice calls us? Only then would tradition cease to be the remission and betrayal of an unsayable transmission, affirming itself truly as Über-lieferung, self-liberation and self-offering: hen diapheron heatōi, “one transporting itself,” without vocation and without destiny. Tradition would then have truly for-given what cannot, in any sense, be presupposed.’