The Fourth Revolution in our Self-Understanding | Luciano Florodi, in "Philosophy, Computing and Information", ed. Uwe V. Riss.
Basic point of depature:
To oversimplify, science has two fundamental ways of changing our understanding. One may be called extrovert, or about the world, and the other introvert, or about ourselves. Th ree scientific revolutions in the past had great impact both extrovertly and introvertly. In changing our understanding of the external world, they also modified our conception of who we are, that is, our self-understanding. (19)
After the three revolutions, we were left with our intelligent behaviour as the new line of defence of our uniqueness. Our special place in the universe was not a matter of astronomy, biology or mental transparency, but of superior thinking abilities. As Blaise Pascal poetically puts it in a famous quote: ‘man is but a reed, the most feeble thing in nature, but he is a thinking reed’. (22)
Because of Turing’s legacy, today we have been displaced from the privileged and unique position we thought we held in the realm of logical reasoning and corresponding smart behaviour. We are not the undisputed masters of the infosphere. Our digital devices carry out more and more tasks that would require intelligence if we were in charge. We have been forced to abandon once again a position that we thought was ‘unique’. (22-23)
History of the term "computer" shows this. Computer used to be a human, but Turing already deemed it necessary to specify a human as a human computer.
@inforg @infosphere
Floridi's perspective of being inforgs in the infosphere:
We are slowly accepting the post-Turing idea that we are not Newtonian, standalone and unique agents, some Robinson Crusoe on an island, but rather informational organisms (inforgs), mutually connected and embedded in an informational environment, the infosphere, which we share with other informational agents, both natural and artifi cial, that can process information logically and autonomously oft en better than we do. Such agents are not intelligent like us, but they can easily outsmart us. (23)
Inforgs
We are increasingly delegating or outsourcing our memories, decisions, routine tasks and other activities to artificial agents in ways that will be progressively integrated with us and with our understanding of what it means to be a smart agent. (23-24)
"the fourth revolution concerns, negatively, our newly lost 'uniqueness' (we are no longer at the centre of the infosphere) and, positively, our new way of understanding ourselves as inforgs.
Some warnings about what inforgs are not:
- Not a cyborg, this is science fiction
- "Walking around with something like a Bluetooth wireless headset implanted in your ear does not seem the best way forward, not least because it contradicts the social message it is also meant to be sending: being on call 24⁄7 is a form of slavery, and anyone so busy and important should have a personal assistant instead." (24)
- Not in line with "extended mind" and integration with daily tools
- "However, the view according to which devices, tools and other environmental supports or props may be enrolled as proper parts of our ‘extended minds’ is still based on a Cartesian agent, who is stand-alone and fully in charge of the cognitive environment, which it is controlling and using through its mental prostheses, from paper and pencil to a smartphone, from a diary to a tablet, from a knot in the handkerchief to a computer. Th is is an outdated perspective." (24)
- Not a "genetically modified humanity, in charge of its informational DNA" (24)
Less sensational, but more profound according to Floridi:
We have begun to understand ourselves as inforgs not through some biotechnological transformations in our bodies, but, more seriously and realistically, through the radical transformation of our environment and the agents operating within it. (24)
Enhancing, Augmenting and Re-Engineering Technologies
Human identity is informational according to Floridi:
The fourth revolution has brought to light the intrinsically informational nature of human identity. It is humbling, because we share such a nature with some of the smartest of our own artefacts. Whatever defines us, it can no longer be playing chess, checking the spelling of a document, calculating the orbit of a satellite, parking a car or landing an aircraft better than some ICT. And it is enlightening, because it enables us to understand ourselves better as a special kind of informational organism.
Informational identity is not:
- Digital identities, or alter egos
- Not our data traces / "data shadow"
This is because ICTs are not just enhancing technologies "with us still at the centre of the infosphere" (25).
But neither are they simply augmenting technologies.
Augmenting technologies interface between worlds.
E.g.:
The data and control panels of augmenting technologies are instead interfaces between different possible worlds. On the one hand, there is the human user’s outer world as it affects the agent inhabiting it. On the other hand, there is the dynamic, watery, soapy, hot and dark world of the dishwasher, for example.
The point is that these "robots can be successful because they have their environments ‘wrapped’ and tailored around their capacities, not vice versa." (25)
The idea of interface is very consistent with the idea of technological @mediation Digital mediation --> through interfaces that allow us to enter with digital entities.
ICTs are not enhancing nor augmenting!
Now, despite some superficial appearances, ICTs are not enhancing nor augmenting in the sense just explained. They are environmental forces because they are creating and re-engineering whole realities that the user is then enabled to enter through (possibly friendly) gateways. It is a form of initiation.(25)
Digital interface; :
To return to the initial distinction, while a dishwasher interface is a panel through which the machine enters into the user’s world, a digital interface is a gate through which a user can be present in the infosphere. This simple but fundamental difference underlies the many spatial metaphors of ‘cyberspace’, ‘virtual reality’, ‘being online’, ‘surfing the web’, ‘gateway’ and so forth. (26)
Our environment is itself reinterpreted and changing:
It follows that we are witnessing an epochal, unprecedented migration of humanity from its Newtonian, physical space to the infosphere itself as its new environment, not least because the latter is absorbing the former. As a result, humans will be inforgs among other (possibly artificial) inforgs and agents operating in an environment that is friendlier to informational creatures. (26)
Floridi's predictions for the future:
- Disappearance of sharp boundaries between the physical and the infosphere
- "And as digital immigrants like Generation X and Y are replaced by digital natives like Generation Z, the latter will come to recognize no fundamental difference between the infosphere and the physical world, only a change in perspective." (26)
- Being tuned to a digital environment will make being disconnected a physically traumatising experience
- "When the migration is complete, my guess is that new generations will increasingly feel deprived, excluded, handicapped or poor to the point of paralysis and psychological trauma whenever it is disconnected from the infosphere, like fish out of water." (26)
- "One day, being an inforg will be so natural that any disruption in our normal fl ow of information will make us sick." (26)
Conclusion
Conclusion is pretty irrelevant and not that related to the content of the article. From Gogols' "dead souls" to Google's "digital souls": on the value of inforgs. Also in Floridi's book on the fourth revolution.
N.B.
N.B. Floridi really seems like the type of thinker that heavily recycles his material in various publications.
This sentence for example also occurs perhaps even literally in his article on the ontological account of privacy: "This is not equivalent to saying that we have digital alter egos, some Messrs Hydes represented by their @ s, blogs, tweets or https." (25, N.B. I introduced the space between @ and s to not let this count as a tag) That whole section seems reproduced, actually, e.g. the examples on enhancing and augmenting technologies.