Gopen and Swan Science of scientific writing

The Science of Scientific Writing | George Gopen, Judith Swan, American Scientist 1990

This article has special focus for the study of reader expectations, in order to inform how to write.

The substance of science comprises more than the discovery and recording of data; it extends crucially to include the act of interpretation. It may seem obvious that a scientific document is incomplete without the interpretation of the writer; it may not be so obvious that the document cannot "exist" without the interpretation of each reader. In other words, writers cannot "merely" record data, even if they try. In any recording or articulation, no matter how haphazard or confused, each word resides in one or more distinct structural locations. The resulting structure, even more than the meanings of individual words, significantly influences the reader during the act of interpretation. The question then becomes whether the structure created by the writer (intentionally or not) helps or hinders the reader in the process of interpreting the scientific writing.

1) If the reader is to grasp what the writer means, the writer must understand what the reader needs. 2) Information is interpreted more easily and more uniformly if it is placed where most readers expect to find it. 3) Beginning with the exciting material and ending with a lack of luster often leaves us disappointed and destroys our sense of momentum. * Use "stress positions" to present the most important information. * "The stress position coincides with the moment of syntactic closure", which is usually but not necessarily the end of the sentence. * Main insight: do not place the most important information within a subject-verb separation.
4) We cannot succeed in making even a single sentence mean one and only one thing; we can only increase the odds that a large majority of readers will tend to interpret our discourse according to our intentions. * A sentence is too long when it has more viable candidates for stress positions than there are stress positions available. 5) Put in the topic position the old information that links backward; put in the stress position the new information you want the reader to emphasize.

Taking into account these principles, the authors formulate the following recommendation (cited in full):

  1. Follow a grammatical subject as soon as possible with its verb.
  2. Place in the stress position the "new information" you want the reader to emphasize.
  3. Place the person or thing whose "story" a sentence is telling at the beginning of the sentence, in the topic position.
  4. Place appropriate "old information" (material already stated in the discourse) in the topic position for linkage backward and contextualization forward.
  5. Articulate the action of every clause or sentence in its verb.
  6. In general, provide context for your reader before asking that reader to consider anything new.
  7. In general, try to ensure that the relative emphases of the substance coincide with the relative expectations for emphasis raised by the structure.