The hermeneutics of databases

@hermeneutics @databases

See Kelly-Hermeneutics_and_Information_Science.md

There needs to be some pre-agreement in order for data to convey information. This seems to translate into the issue that the frame or reference of intended users need to be taken into account in order for data to represent information/knowledge, i.e. the hermeneutic idea of pre-understanding is relevant here.

  • Databases thus also have an hermeneutical basis (cf. Kelly 2016, p.92)
    • Databases are designed and structured with a future recovery in mind, i.e. based on a pre-understanding of this purpose.
    • Information retrieval is a "fusion of horizons" with these objectified preconceptions and the preconceptions of those with an information need.
    • This is super interesting! An example I think of: when you are Googling something you need to already kind of know what you are looking for. Without this pre-understanding you won't find what you are looking for. On the side of the database, the need of the user need to match the objectified pre-understanding that determines what is retrievable and in what manner.
    • See Capurro "Hermeneutical questions concerning the construction of databases", Chapter 3.1, paragraph 1-6.

Citation from Capurro's "Hermeneutical questions concerning the construction of databases", Chapter 3.2, paragraph 3:

The meeting between a questioner and an (information) system is to be interpreted as a hermeneutic process, during which the open horizon of the questioner and the fixed horizon of the system itself provisionally “merge,” that is, the objectified preconception is published as a (possible) answer to a question, and thus understanding is recovered in the online dialogue. In this “fusion of horizons,” the identity and difference in their blending and contrasting simultaneously become apparent. (3.2.a, para. 3) Capurro also takes this interest in the hermeneutics of the constitution of online dialogue. (94)

Also interesting is Swanson:

we might look upon the process of information retrieval as a trial or a conjecture, guided by some idea of what one is seeking. The principal value of the process lies not so much in the direct use of the retrieved documents but rather in the indirect function which they serve of stimulating a reformulation of the request… The retrieval of irrelevant documents may therefore sometimes play as significant a role in stimulating research as does the retrieval of relevant documents. Errors or mistakes are not to be thought of in a pejorative sense, but rather as essential components of the research process (Swanson, 1977, pp. 138-139). (94)

See Swanson, D.R. (1977). Information retrieval as a trial-and-error process. The Library Quarterly: Information, Community, Policy,47(2), 128-148.