How to write a PhD research proposal?
@phd @proposal
There is no universal format, so always check if there are formats and requirements available of the particular organization you are applying to.
How to write a PhD proposal | Dr. Craig Harper
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2EjOte1BTw
What are focus points for a reviewer?
1) Do you display knowledge of the relevant field? 2) Do you have an interesting research question? 3) Do you know how to examine your research question in an appropriate way? 4) Does your proposal tell a nice and coherent story that adds value to your specific field? 5) Will you finish your PhD in the time allowed?
Knowledge of relevant field
Set the first portion of the research proposal to set the context of your field of expertise. What's already known? What are main theories and researchers?
- Review literature
- Mention key theories
- Mention key researchers
This displays the academic skills of literature research and evaluating them in a coherent way.
State your research question
- Where is the knowledge gap?
- What type of question are you posing?
- Theoretical or problem-focused
- Make it sound impactful
- Make it sound grounded in your literature review
Methods
How will you answer your research question? Justify your approach!
Demonstrate a few key skills:
- Show awareness of different approaches
- Show that you aware of limits of your chosen approach
- Demonstrate that you are aware that different types of questions require different methods
- There can be different methods for different subquestions, but don't spend time explaining tangential issues
Tell a coherent story
This aspect is perhaps quickly overlooked. Harper suggests two main narratives for PhD research:
1) A story of discovery * A flow from study A to study B etc. * Study B follows up on something from study A * This structure is easy to follow while reading 2) A story of development * Have a series of studies lined up from the outset * Narrate what insights you have gathered from these experiments * (Cf. so the structure is not guided by the order of experiments)
The particular choice for structure will only be clear once you do the actual research.
But for a proposal the story of discovery is probably easiest to show a clear coherent story of what your research might look like. The second approach relies more on already having done more research.
Timing
- More than just a Gantt chart
- Not just deadlines and word counts
- What are potential challenges?
- Have a contingency plan!
- E.g. what if you have to wait for ethical approval? What do you do then?
This section could look very methodical, but this can actually make you stand out.
Writing a Winning Research Proposal - Ray Boxman
Objective
The goal is to convince someone to allocate you resources for the research. It is thus not enough to write a (scientifically) good proposal.
What does the "granter" need to know to decide?
Value of the research:
Also differs per type of granter:
- Scientific advancement (mainly scientific institutes)
- Application (Technological companies / organizations)
- Linked to potential job creation
- Adherence to a particular subject area (E.g. a cancer organization)
Probability of success:
- Methodology / work program
- Are you familiar with the subject?
- Shows in literature review
- Do you have a qualified team and adequate resources?
Required resources:
A granter will look into getting the most bang for buck, which is especially important because many proposals are competing for the same limited grants.
How long will the research take?
Proposal Structure
Guidelines are provided by the granting agency you are applying to, but they often share the following main components:
1) Abstract 2) Subject area 3) (Scientific/Technological) Background / Literature survey 4) Objectives 5) Expected Results and Significance 6) Methodology 7) Work plan 8) Resources 9) References 10) Budget 11) CVs of key personnel 12) Letters of cooperation
The main differences with an actual journal article are:
- (5) expected results, because we do not have any results yet
- (6) and (7) both in future tense
Abstract
Summarize:
- Subject area
- Objectives
- Methodology
- Expected results and significance
- Resources required
Typically 0.5-1 page.
Style guide:
- Write in the 3rd person
- Use passive sentences
- Write it or rewrite it after finishing the body of the proposal
Subject area
This section is actually not written for the evaluators, but for various administrators that decide on who should review your proposal. This means that this should be extremely accessible for non-specialists.
Very short description or definition of the subject area (max. half page).