Ethical Issues to Consider Before Introducing Neurotechnological Thought Apprehension in Psychiatry | Gerben Meynen
NTA techniques: Neurotechnical thought apprehension.
- Discusses limitations of the technique.
- Focus on forensic psychiatry
- Identifies ethical priorities for future psychiatric use
- What is the ecological validity of NTA in the context of psychiatry?
Keywords:
- (Bio)ethical issues
- Confidentiality
- Trust & Distrust
- Consent
- Coercion
- Responsibility
Current state of the art
NTA a.k.a. "brain reading".
Overall goal is "apprehending mental states, such a sthoughts, intentions, inclinations, biases, desires, feelings, or levels of consciousness."
NTA is very pragmatic and not connected to a particular theory of the mind-brain relationship. Minimal requirement is that NTA provides some information on someone's thoughts.
Current applications are basically only in a research setting.
- Yes no decisions by thinking of a) playing tennis b) navigating home + fMRI and machine learning.
- BCI with locked-in patients
- Recognize suicidal ideation (fMRI + machine learning)
- Recognize auditory hallucinations
Because psychiatric diagnoses heavily relies on first person accounts of patients themselves, and because these accounts can have severe limitations, it is of interest in psychiatry to be able to "look in someone's head", so to speak.
Also relevant legally: When someone pleas "ontoerekeningsvatbaar" for example by claiming he thought he was abducted by aliens, does that person really believe that?
Ethical concerns
Confidentiality
Confidentiality between patient and psychiatrist can be broken in case of extreme conditions where serious harm to an intended victim can be prevented, and there are no other means available anymore.
Can NTA provoke confidentiality breaches? And if so, do NTAs not give away too much information about mental states in such a case? Normally you would only disclose the necessary information. What is absolutely necessary in the case of NTA?
This risk is especially clear in forensic psychiatry, because the results of the examination of e.g. a legal defendee might have to be shared in a legal testimony.
A normal examination is Q&A. But irregardless of the question, NTA would apprehend all thoughts. But what information is relevant to the question?
Measurements can also always be incorrect, which is especially troubling in legal cases.
Trust and distrust
Trust between patient and doctor is very important in order to adequately help patients.
The type of information you would apprehand with NTA is often information the patient can give herself as well. Double checking everything with NTA conveys distrust and can harm a healthy relationship with the patient.
That can of course also be an advantage to catch fraudulent claims.
Consent and judgmental ability
Consent for NTA is tricky because the implications of NTA are largely unknown. What is the patient consenting to?
Many psychiatric patients suffer from impaired decision making. How can you obtain valid consent in these cases?
This is especially troublesome for treatment decisions. Imagine a vegetative person communicating through NTA about euthanasia.
1) Does this person have the capacity to make such a decision? 2) Can such capacity be estimated using NTA?
What about forced consent? E.g. you have to consent to NTA if we really want to know what you are thinking. If the result is positive we can release you early, otherwise not.
To solve such pressure, should you prohibit NTA as a basis for e.g. getting on parole early?
Responsibility
NTA can be translated into action, e.g. in the case of a locked-in patient guiding a robot arm with thought.
With actions come responsibilities. If an NTA-based action injures someone, where do you allocate blame then? In the "brain" (that might be injured), or in the BCI, that did not deal with the situation correctly? Did the BCI/NTA perhaps translate a spontaneous bad thought in action that would have never been executed with a healthy body?
Ecological validity
What is the "fit" of NTA with forensic psychiatrics?
NTA works in research settings where the participants are trained and cooperate. Can it possible work in a legal setting where a defendant might have no interest to cooperate? Unless manipulation itself can be measured, NTA will be extremely problematic for use in the court room.
Standpoint of the author: the added value of NTA must be clear w.r.t. other techniques, or if other techniques are completely unavailable.