Abandoned Being by Jean-Luc Nancy
@abandonment @ontology
Authors:
43
‘These are words to qualify, or rather to camouflage—quite poorly—the abandonment through which being reaches us, and through which we reach being. All our Ideas, on the contrary, rest on a belief in the virtue of the question "Why is there something, and not nothing?" An antecedence of being could be the answer. But now we know that this question already answers itself in secret: "Since there is something, and not everything, it is because this thing is in abandonment, it is because everything is abandoned." And it is not permitted us to ask by whom.’ (Nancy 1993, 43)
LATER INVOEGEN M.B.T STUK OVER LEIBNIZ ETC.
Hier ligt dus misschien ook het verschil tussen Agamben en Nancy. Nancy is écht een denker van de verlatenheid. De wet wordt bij hem niet opgeheven. De ‘relatie’ blijft in diens paradox als paradoxale relatie gehandhaafd. Nancy: DELEN! Participatie, theia moira.
44:
‘an absolute, solemn order, which prescribes nothing but abandonment. Being is not entrusted to a cause, to a motor, to a principle; it is not left to its own substance, or even to its own subsistence. It is—in abandonment.’ (Nancy 1993, 44)
44:
‘Abandonment respects the law; it cannot do otherwise.’
45:
‘By respecting the law, abandonment respects itself, so to speak (and the law respects it). It turns back—not to perceive itself, but to receive itself.’
Abandonment & Gift:
45:
‘Being is not given with abandonment, if the gift supposes a reserve and the provision of riches, an initial accumulation as well as the generosity of a donor. The law gives nothing; it orders. Being is not given—or a gift is not given to it—unless a gift, well short of what we imagine and what we practice in its name, is or should be always abandoned. One thinks one hears, one would like to hear, donner [to give] in abandonner, but the opposite is true. ("Don't give with one hand and withhold with the other," says the law; but it is the giving itself as such that must not be withheld.)’
46:
‘Being is thus abandoned to the being-there of man, as to an order.’
47:
‘Ontology will be, from now on, an anthropology that has no other "object" but the dereliction of being—and thus, once again, its pollakos, for there are cruel abandons and gracious abandonments, some sweet, some pitiless, some voluptuous, frenetic, happy, or disastrous, some serene. Abandonment’s only law, like that of love, is to be without return and without recourse.’