Privacy as noise

@privacy @signal @noise

On a particular interpretation of privacy in terms of signal-noise ratio.

Comment from Gordon Hull on https://www.newappsblog.com/2013/12/big-data-why-privacy-is-no-help-at-all.html:

As far back as 1978, Richard Posner basically provided a plausible neoliberal reading of privacy, and the core of his argument was that privacy usually functions to hide relevant information in an exchange, and in that sense the state shouldn't be protecting it very often. On the other hand, he also thought that the state shouldn't do much to try to force disclosure of information, since that would probably be inefficient - the party for whom information is valuable should bear the cost of getting it. So privacy is basically the insertion of noise into the system (and for that reason is probably of vital importance for any theory of resistance). On the other hand, I don't see how Posner's concept survives in an age of big data, since one effect of big data is to make information a lot cheaper, and to make the sorting of signal and noise sufficiently robust that it's very hard to make enough noise to slow it down. (Nothing I'm saying here, btw, is (I think) in any way incompatible with the way you talk about listening).

This comment was also more or less in response to a question concerning the relevance of Foucault's biopolitics in relation to big data (data at a "population" level).

See Posner: https://digitalcommons.law.uga.edu/lectures_pre_arch_lectures_sibley/22/

I'm also thinking about the current practice of privacy as @obfusciation , for example in "The Fantasy of Opting Out" by Finn Bunton and Helen Nissenbaum, who state that "Obfusciation may be our best digital weapon".

See https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/the-fantasy-of-opting-out/

Obfusciation is basically an act of resistance by artificially increasing noise to cover up a "signal" i.e. digital traces corresponding to behavioral patterns.