Meditation log

@meditation @Harris

Notes while following the "Waking Up" meditation course from Sam Harris, together with four friends.

1: Mon 09 Sep 2019 07:15:00 AM CEST

The point of meditating is not something that will be proven theoretically; you have to practice it yourself to see its benefits and the changes it will make in your life. Otherwise it is like doing astronomy without ever having seen the clear sky without light pollution.

Attention to breathing; all types of breathing are fine, shallow or deep. Simply observe your breathing without trying to control it. Either focus on the movement in your chest, or on the tip of your nose, or both; whatever suits you.

If thoughts come up, observe them without judgement, and then return to concentrating on your breathing.

When you got somewhat used to that, focus instead on other locations of your body. I noticed particularly pain and tension in my shoulders and my neck, because I meditated immediately after waking up.

I experienced the commentary on my phone as distracting. I was worried whether I put the volume too loud (I was at Francesca's place where everyone else was still asleep), but after adjusting the volume I had to focus a lot on understanding the commentary. Interestingly, Sam Harris remarked that if the commentary felt like an interruption, also simply observe your own thoughts (and perhaps annoyance) about that, without judgment.

Always return to simply focusing on breathing once you have realized a distraction and have drifted away.

2: Tue 10 Sept 2019

I slightly misunderstood the advice from yesterday on where to pay attention to your breathing. It can be any place, but it is advised to pick one during the meditation and stick to it.

This lesson focused on how hard it is to focus on breathing without being interrupted by thoughts. While counting breathing cycles until 10 I indeed noticed how at count 9 I completely forgot I was counting and caught myself thinking about something else.

The value of observing whatever arises in consciousness without immediately identifying with it. I.e. seeing it as your own, quickly connected with emotional responses and judgments. The exercise is to simply observe these thoughts as they come up, nothing more.

Practicing meditation in this manner is slightly paradoxical. After getting better at paying attention, you do not do more, but instead you do less.

3: Wedn 11 Sept 2019

Similar basics as the previous days. Try to also pay attention to the breathing as it starts, not only while it is already in motion. Also pay attention to the breaks between breathing.

Be aware of the space that your body is in. Feel how your hand weigh down on a surface, how you back feels against the chair. Move past different body parts, and try not to think of the shape of your body. Instead, try to conceive of each body part as a cloud of sensations.

I thought this was particularly hard, because when I feel for example my hand weighing down, I am immediately aware of its position.

Final assignment: let your mind be a space in which all these sensations can come up as a cloud of sensations, that you merely observe.

Exercises like these can be performed in an ultra-short manner. E.g. if you are stressed, take as little as a second to become aware of your breath and observe sensations, such as your mood or stress that you experience.

4: Thurs 12 Sept 2019

Same start as usual.

Today the exercise is about paying attention to sounds around you.

Notice them, and particularly observe how you do not produce these sounds yourself.

The longer I waited the more subtle sounds I started to hear. First: the chickens waking up, the low rumble of a boat in the river. Later: birds in the distance, small clicks and ticks here and there.

Let your mind be the space in which these experiences appear. Sam Harris even said it a bit more drastically: let sounds announce this place.

How much control do you have over the sound? Once you hear something, can you make it stay? Do you control it? My experience: only when you keep repeating it actively in your head, which is sort of an artificial echo that tries to keep present what is already gone.

Now do the same with thoughts. If a thought comes up and disrupts your attention, simply observe it, and then ask: did I produce this thought? Or did it, just like the sound, simply come up and go away again precisely as I observe it?
*

Sounds are a good phenomena to show this point due to their "ungovernability"; they are very ephemeral and fleeting.

The fact that you can incorporate experiences of sound into your mediation shows that there is no such thing as a distracting environment, if you are able to simply observe these sounds as they come.

* This point really resonates with a remark from the lecture of Markus Gabriel last week. He said that the reason you can "grasp" ideas or e.g. in Dutch "een idee valt je binnen" etc. is because ideas are entities of their own with their own type of existence. They are not locked inside my head or that of others, but also exists between people, and you can observe them.

* Cf. the voice in Derrida. In this meditation, the voice was again a model for the idea of presence, while at the same time underlining its fleetingness.

* Cf. phenomenology, the primitive of experiencing the phenomena as phenomena, simply observing them as such. Difference probably is that this mediation does pay as much relation to the fundamental relatedness between "subject" and "object" captured in the idea of intentionality. Does this mediation presuppose a distinction between "self" or "mind" and "the things out there that I do not produce?" Is there any notion of intentionality?