Why is Data so Easily Commodified (with a detour into fish)? | By Gordon @Hull , May 2019
@data @big_data @commodity @capitalism @commodification
Blog by Gordon Hull .
Source: https://www.newappsblog.com/2019/04/why-is-data-so-easily-commodified-with-a-detour-into-fish.html
Main point:
Surely one of the more striking features of the rise of data science is how readily it can be incorporated into processes of capitalist valuation, to the point that data may not just be a commodity - it may also be capital. At one level, this sounds intuitive enough: one might suggest that data presents information about the world, and that knowledge is valuable. But this view encounters an immediate limitation in that firms seem to want to accumulate data far beyond their ability to value it. According to this “data imperative,” data is something to be accumulated, even if one has no clear use for it. An additional problem is that the companies that accumulate all of this data are generally not so interested in whether it represents the world accurately. They want it because they want to influence behaviors.
On Leonelli: What counts as Scientific Data?
Source: https://philpapers.org/rec/LEOWCA
Leonelli is writing from the perspective of the philosophy of science, and her paper is especially useful in that regard because she is able to embed the definition in recent work in the sociology of science and STS, such as Latour. The key takeaway is that data needs to be defined pragmatically – not what it is, but what it does. And the key implication of that is that we need to stop thinking of data as representative. Data is generated for a purpose, and in science, a central purpose is portability:
“Scientists engage in data generation in full awareness that the outputs of that activity need to travel beyond the boundaries of their own investigation. That awareness is built into the choice of instruments used, the recording of procedures and protocols carried out in lab books, and the decisions about how outputs may be stored, shared with peers, fed into models, and integrated with other data sources” (816)
In this sense, data are material artifacts that are designed to circulate. In order to circulate, they have to be standardized in such a way that they can be commensurable with (or at least relate in a predictable way to) other data, and that need for standardization fundamentally drives their production process. In other words, data is always already packaged to the extent that its meaning as data is inseparable from its packaging.
The fish detour concerns descriptions of the commensuration of salmon.
Notable sentence with respect to the idea that a "brand" occults the production process; the origin of a product becomes itself a product of marketing:
The attribution of origin is mythological in the sense that it presents whatever narrative about the origin of the product the producer wants to communicate.
Conclusions:
When used to illuminate the context of data as something already-packaged, this literature helps to underscore two things: first, data is produced with an eye towards its circulation; and second, commodities are also produced with an eye toward their circulation. The fundamental congruence here suggests part of why data is so easily subject to capitalization and commodification: it’s already a lot of the way there. This basic point can be obscured by the fact that data is often taken to be representative of some underlying substrate. But that’s not what data does. It is a truism by now in the data literature that data is action-oriented – and here we see a specific consequence of that. As Mary Beth Mader notes of the difference between individuals and the members of a population, the difference is ontological. The process of generating data is, like the process of generating quality salmon, one of producing an item into a classificatory schema. This classificatory process, as Marion Fourcade and Kieran Healy argue, is constitutive of the process of big data as it is used in markets under capitalism.
As Leonelli notes, this means that the potential reach of data is nearly infinite; or, rather, its reach extends precisely insofar as it can circulate.
“This does not mean that whoever gathers data already knows how they might be used. Rather, what matters is that observations or measurements are collected with the expectation that they may be used as evidence for claims about the world in the future. Hence, any object can be considered as a datum as long as (1) it is treated as potential evidence for one or more claims about phenomena and (2) it is possible to circulate it among individuals.” (817)
In short, part of why it is so easy to commodify data is that data is already a long ways towards being a commodity.