Bertrand's Paradox on the Principle of Indifference

Bertrand's Paradox, and variants thereof, show that the principle of indifference does not yield a unique set of probabilities. This is often used as an argument against objective Bayesians that use constraints on the assignments of priors and argue that there is a rationally correct way to assign prior credences (strong variant).

This is a version of Bertrand's Paradox from Van Fraassen, as quoted in Easwaran - Bayesianism II .

  • We have a cubical box width a side length between 1 and 3 meters
  • so we assign 1/2 credence to it being 1-2 meters, and 1/2 credence to it being 2-3 meters (that is a uniform distribution)
  • we can translate this problem into an equivalent estimate, namely that the side surface will be between 1 and 9 square meters.
  • then if we maintain a uniform distribution, we end up with 3/8 credence for 1-4 and 5/8 credence for 4-9.

So we have in fact assigned two different credences to equivalent statements.

Bird, p.101-102 discusses two approaches to the case where we have a coin that we know if biased, but we do not know if it's biased towards heads or tails. Here we also assume different credences towards some identical observed outcome sequence.

Assume we throw the coin 10 times.

  1. If our hypothesis space consists of each possible outcome, we assign each hypothesis 1/1024 credence. Probability of various proportions of heads and tails can be computed.
    • P(10 heads)=0.001
  2. If instead, we make hypothesis about the fairness of the coin (0, 0.1, 0.2, 0.3 ... 1), each hypothesis has prior credence 1/11.
    • P(10 heads)=0.09

N.B. Bird points out that the first case is sceptical because it does not allow let's say finding heads nine times to increase your belief in the coin being more biased towards heads. This is not how we desire Bayesian updating to proceed, so in contrast to Van Fraassen's version in this case the choice would be clear. The criticism stays the same though: depending on which hypothesis space you distribute your credences over, the principle of indifference yields to different results. It is then arguably not entirely indifferent.