Aesthetics of difficulty
@aesthetics
When investigating the "aesthetics of difficulty", one inquires into art that withholds and resists comprehension. In which way is this not just e.g. due to bad writing, but a deliberate strategy that allows for a particular aesthetic (or even philosophic or existential) experience?
From "Doing Philosophy in Style: A New Look at the Analytic/Continental Divide" in Philosophy Compass 7/12 (2012): 919-942, by N.N. Trakakis:
In literary studies there is a well-developed field of the aesthetics of difficulty which philosophers have barely broached. The aim of research in this area is to study literary works (and other art works) that appear tobe intentionally difficult to understand or interpret, and to investigate the rationale behind such an approach to the creation of art. A genre of difficult and inaccessible literature was promulgated by the early German Romantics such as Friedrich Schlegel and Novalis, in opposition to the fashionable (then and now) equation of art and entertainment. In more recent times, the genre has excelled in a number of writers experimenting at the edges of language with unorthodox forms and methods. One could point, for example, to the hermetic poetry of Paul Celan and Giuseppe Ungaretti, the ‘alienation effects’ of Bertolt Brecht’s plays and the absurdist theatre of Samuel Beckett, the cryptic and perplexing stories of Franz Kafka and the innovative but forbidding language of James Joyce’s last novels. (A similar degree of impenetrability is present in much twentiethcentury painting and sculpture, particularly in movements such as minimalism, abstract expressionism and conceptual art.) In each case an unambiguous interpretation is refused, and instead the work only frustrates and alienates its audience or readership, thwarting their expectation of a unified narrative and their desire for resolution and closure. But this is not a case of being difficult for its own sake. Rather, the difficulty is intended to overturn settled ways of thinking and motivate the reader to question and to embark on their own quest for answers. (930)