On diversity and quota
In discussions with others I've noticed that 1) I agree that diversity is a very important topic and 2) I'm against quota that reduce this issue to a numerical problem, in the sense of "we need 50-50 male/female" or we need "10% people with this particular ethnicity".
Quite a difficult and sensitive topic that never fails to produce heated debate. And things tend to get personal quite quickly, especially when participants themselves belong to a minority.
One argument pro quota is that systemic bias requires a concentrated effort to be countered. An argument could go something like this: history has shown that the problem that minorities do not enjoy equal opportunities does not balance itself out over time, and therefore requires pro-active counter-balancing, for example in the form of quota.
My thoughts:
You can only set those quantitative measures by first dividing people up in classes and (at least partially) determining how people will be treated based on a particular group identity.
The goal of for example the effort against discrimination should instead be to not identify, group, and treat people according to a "class label". So to me a measure like a diversity quotum is a self-defeating measure, because it relies on the very thing it tries to get rid off. It's a bit like an auto-immune disease: you try to defend against people being treated differently based on a group identity, e.g. gender, religion, ethnicity, but this defensive move ends up biting you in the ass.
However, I think there's some interesting parallels to be made with Derrida's practice of deconstruction. In his early works, Derrida tends to identify a particular conceptual hierarchy which he then counters by reversing the hierarchy. However, in his works this reversal always ends up de-stabilizing the conceptual distinction that made it possible.
- B > C.
- Wait, B is a particular form of C? So C > B?
- Actually, B ~?=! C
I'm concerned that the "business-like" mindset that tries to do the counter-balancing in terms of quota is not sensitive enough to the ultimate goal: dissolving the unjustice of identifying and treating people by one of their group identities in the first place.
To me the goal seems to promote diversity in perspectives and ideas. A difference in someone's background (be it religion, ethnicity, gender) very likely will lead to additional perspectives i.e. more diversity. But diversity in background should not in itself be the goal. The goal is, again, diversity in ideas and there are several ways of working towards that.
Of course a problem is how you can promote or enforce openness to diversity within organizations. Whereas things like gender quota are very nice for managers writing policy (in my opinion ultimately self-defeating), you could also take a more qualitative bottom-up approach by ensuring that for example people in charge of hiring receive some ethical training.
I also believe that a company that fosters diversity (in terms of ideas) will be a better company.
The following section from EU_ethics_guidelines_thrustworthy_ai.md may be relevant:
It is critical that, as AI systems perform more tasks on their own, the teams that design, develop, test and maintain, deploy and procure these systems reflect the diversity of users and of society in general. This contributes to objectivity and consideration of different perspectives, needs and objectives. Ideally, teams are not only diverse in terms of gender, culture, age, but also in terms of professional backgrounds and skill sets. (23)
TODO: how does my argument above relate to this section?
I'm absolutely sure, however, that my own perspective on this is limited. Idea: invite others to criticize, complement, contribute to my initial thoughts.