AI and Law

(Legal) argument mining

Ontologies and topic modelling

Text similarity, recommendation, information retrieval

Case factors, classifying cases, predicting case outcomes

Argument mining

See index argumentation mining .

Since I'm currently interested in modelling attack relations between arguments/conclusions, it may be interesting for me to check out Dung's abstract argumentation framework because 1) it does not consider internal structure of arguments, 2) it is apparently very good at modelling attack relations.

There is also argument mining work that targets a specific argument component, e.g. the claim. Have a look at that as well, this may be sufficient for me! See Lippi & Torrini (2015). This would also make constructing the training data easier, since it would only require positive labels for claims.

Use cases

  • Prediction case outcomes
  • Finding similar cases (e.g. in common law)
    • E.g. cases on similar topics
    • Discussing similar laws
    • same or similar case factors
  • Finding relevant case factors
  • Argument extraction
  • Distinguish legal from non-legal sentences or arguments
  • Given a directive (e.g. EU directive), automatically find laws that implement the directive
  • Given a particular case, find related legislative documents.

TODO

Case-based reasoning:

  • J. L. Kolodner. An Introduction to Case-Based Reasoning. Artificial Intelligence Review, 6:3–34, 1992

Argument mining

  • Statistical + rule-based [A] Robaldo L, Caselli T, Russo I, Grella M (2011) From Italian text to timeml document via dependency parsing. In: Computational linguistics and intelligent text processing—12th international conference, CICLing 2011, Tokyo, Japan, 2011, pp 177–187
  • Medvedeva 2020 - Using machine learning to predict decisions of the European Court of Human Rights
  • Savelkla 2021 - Transfer of predictive models across legal domains
  • [C] Craandijk 2020 - Deep Learning for Abstract Argumentation Semantics

These systems "model how lawyers in common-law jurisdictions make use of past decisions when arguing a case" (29):

  • HYPO by Kevin Ashley
  • CATO by Vincent Aleven

Maybe relevant for figuring out how argument mining helps in finding relevant cases:

  • Daniels, J.J., Rissland, E.L.: Finding legally relevant passages in case opinions. In: ICAIL 1997: Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Artificial intelligence and Law, pp. 39–46. ACM, New York (1997)
  • Brüninghaus, S., Ashley, K.D.: Generating legal arguments and predictions from case texts. In: ICAIL 2005, pp. 65–74. ACM Press, New York (2005)

Word embeddings used by Panagin 2016 en Landthaler 2016

Explainable word embeddings; connecting vectors and concepts

  • Qureshi, EVE: Explainable Vector Based Embedding Technique Using Wikipedia, https://arxiv.org/abs/1702.06891; https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10844-018-0511-x
  • Jang 2019 - Selection and Interpretation of Embedding Subspace for Query Classification;

    • Uses SHAP to identify embedding subspaces that are strongly connected to particular queries
    • Similar strategy for recommending relevant documents would be: which "concepts" in this document make it relevant to the query (which in this case is the reference document)
  • Stephen Mcgregor, Kat Agres, Matthew Purver, and Geraint Wiggins@qmul Ac Uk. 2015. From Distributional Semantics to Conceptual Spaces: A Novel Compu- tational Method for Concept Creation Geraint A. Wiggins. Journal of Artificial General Intelligence 6, 1 (2015), 55–86. https://doi.org/10.1515/jagi-2015-0004

    • Jang 2019 about this paper: "For instance, the authors of [33] proposed a model to bridge the gap between distributional semantics (vector space) and conceptual space. The model dynamically selects specific dimensions associated with seed terms, which form a sub-space of terms defining the related concept."

3, 37, 51: finding more conceptually coherent dimensions in embeddings by using sparse coding

Enforcing sparse embeddings

Data

Links

Brainstorming