From Ethics Washing to Ethics Bashing: A View on Tech Ethics from Within Moral Philosophy" | Elettra Bietti, 2019

@AI_ethics

I could only find the draft version of this paper without page numbering... so when citing I need to revisit this.

Premise: the word "ethics" is suffering from inflation because it is increasingly seen as "technology companies’ self-regulatory efforts and with shallow appearances of ethical behavior."

This lead to accusations of "ethics washing". On the other hand, when ethics is reduced to this particularly shallow role, it is criticized from a particular perspective that Bietti summarizes as "ethics bashing".

Ethics washing: the "instrumentalization of ethical language by tech companies" thereby "simplifying the value of ethical work" (be wary: I put this sentence together from two different sections ):

Some examples of how that may look like:

  • AI ethics councils
  • hiring "in-house moral philosophers who have little power to shape internal company policies"
  • "focus on humane design – e.g. nudging users to reduce time spent on apps – instead of tackling the risks inherent in the existence of the products themselves"
  • funding work on ' "fair" machine learning systems which positively obscures deeper questioning around the broader impacts of those systems on society'

First thoughts: so far I'm not sure yet if this paper is critical or a form of activism. The above mentioned points are interesting, but it's quite cynical to assess attempt to introduce fairer machine learning techniques as a positive (does that mean: actively contributes to?) obscuration of the broader impact of those systems. Also, she raises suspicion with the use of quotes ("fair" machine learning) that as of now is not supported yet.

The language is quite loaded. The second page for example refers to the "weaponization" of ethics.

I'd counter that in order to apply those fairer machine learning techniques you need to be aware of broader context in order to correctly use them. Treating them as plug-and-play tools is arguably a wrong approach.

Ethics bashing is the opposite approach where ethics is reduced to the shallow form above and criticized as such.

Whole block is a citation, I just leveraged the list structure:

"The misunderstandings underlying ethics bashing are at least three-fold:

(a) philosophy and “ethics” are seen as a communications strategy and as a form of cover-up or façade for unethical behavior, (b) the role and importance of moral philosophy is downplayed and portrayed as mere "ivory tower" intellectualization of complex problems that need to be dealt with in practice; and (c) philosophy is understood in opposition and as alternative to political representation and social organizing."

Intrinsic vs. instrumental value of ethics

Intrinsic:

the value of ethics as a mode of inquiry which it is independently valuable when engaged in as an aspirational process and which takes moral principles seriously in achieving better knowledge and understanding of a state of affairs or phenomenon

Instrumental:

As employed in ethical codes of conduct, professional ethics, or 'ethics boards', ethics is a means to an end, it is instrumental to the achievement of certain more interesting or valuable outcomes such as reputation, innovation, profit, the integrity of a profession

Sure, but as for example the EU Ethics guidelines for Thrustworthy AI mention, this type of "instrumentalization" of ethics can never replace ethical reflection. Each and every ethical board that is worth it's money should realize this, I reckon, and not treat ethics as a checklist to complete.

Bietti acknowledges both conceptions of ethics can exist side-by-side, but that the value of ethics becomes suspicious the more it is measured by outcomes and thus is a means to an end.

Limits of moral philosophy

Bietti discusses some common criticisms of moral philosophy.

  1. Too abstract and inaccessible for larger audiences; not suitable for quickly responding to current issues
    • Counter: slowness in thinking is actually what makes philosophy valuable
  2. Moral philosophy remains too general and abstract and does not sufficiently prescribe concrete courses of action (low functional value); e.g. how does all work on the trolley-problem really help?
    • Counter (bit weak): "Greater emphasis on the special epistemic value philosophical work can add in given technological contexts could possibly address this limitation"
  3. Philosophy can be employed for certain ends that "contradict the principles that motivated the work in the first place."
    • E.g. the work of an in-house philosopher becomes suspicious and runs the risk of becoming "reputational propaganda"
    • Counter: scrutiny of work; transparency about funding
  4. Moral philosophy is not objective and instead just posits the subjective beliefs of some author
    • Counter: "Far from presenting ultimate and final words on a subject, good philosophical work is rigorous yet porous and open to scrutiny, its aim is to broaden perspectives, allowing us to see the limits of the existing and to constantly revise our beliefs."
    • This includes acknowledgment of the assumptions of one's work and openness to an iterative process of revising them, e.g. through trying to reach reflective equilibrium.

What can moral philosophy add to technology policy debates?

  1. Meta-level perspective for approaching disagreements and value conflicts

philosophy is a good antidote to knee-jerk reactions and ideological incompatibility, a method that can help us reduce unbridgeable value conflicts and make agreement possible by moving discussions to a different level of abstraction.

  1. Add principled thinking to value-laden discussions

Moral philosophy should be understood as an explanatory mode of inquiry which operates by requiring us to set out the justifications and reasons for advancing one view and not a different one.

Like this point: it's not about prescribing what to do (neither is it law) but about reflecting on courses of action, thereby informing decisions and adding a basis of support for some of them.

  1. "a normative philosophical lens allows us to move beyond a narrow focus on procedural fairness, diversity and representation in technology governance."

  2. nice if an ethics board is diverse, but what matters is that they can actually constrain the actions of a tech giant like let's say Google

  3. it's not sufficient if an ethics board follows a self-regulation scheme made by a company, if this in practice leads to decisions that tend to follow corporate interests

  4. philosophy can help finding common ground in a polarized landscape

What's wrong with ethics washing

Case study of Facebook Oversight Board (FOB) in particular how it focuses on a particular issue and in doing so, effectively diverts attention away from other pressing issues, while giving Facebook the appearance of tackling issues appropriately.

  1. Self-regulatory bodies likely have poor instrumental value for the more general population

The decisions of internal AI ethics committees are subjected to internal limits, subordinated to the endorsement of high management and dependent on company funding. This dependency on the company’s benevolence makes such efforts inadequate for addressing serious cases of company misconduct and also importantly unfit for achieving desirable policy outcomes.

Example: Apple's in-house philosopher Joshua Cohen is forbidden from speaking to the press.

Decisions of such in-house bodies are unlikely to be allowed to hurt the bottom line of a company.

strong data protection guarantees, data minimization mandates, redlines on the use of AI in credit scoring, criminal procedure or content moderation could hardly be started from within a company’s ethics board.

Counter: there could be cases where procedural fairness is somehow guaranteed.

  1. Examine the intrinsic/independent value of the activity e.g. of in-house philosophers or ethical boards.

It's not clear to me if here Bietti is arguing against ethics washing (like announced), or making recommendations for countering ethics washing?

  1. Ethics washing "denotes a particular performative and epistemic function of the activities in question which requires distinct analysis."

E.g. does ethics washing mislead people into thinking that a contested policy is now acceptable? I.e. do "ethics washing" practices reinforce apathy, weaken activism, and shield companies from public scrutiny?

What's wrong with ethics bashing?

Why is there much ethics bashing in technology policy circles?

  • Misunderstanding of ethics as the instrumentalized version summarized under the name "ethics washing"
  • Ignorance of or resistance to the possibilities of moral philosophy

I.e. the "ethics" that is attacked becomes a red herring.

Main tenet of this last section is that we should learn to distinguish ethical reflection (an "aspirational" process, Bietti calls it) from its instrumentalized forms.

What the technology ecosystem is in greatest need of today, in fact, seems to be a slower, richer, more comprehensive investigation of what various technology companies and stakeholders owe to humans, to animals and to the planet. New technologies are also making us reinvestigate and question the commitments we humans owe to each other, as well as to other beings and to the global planet ecosystem. This is precisely what moral philosophy is for. We may want to stop bashing it.