The space shuttle tragedy and the ethics of engineering | Steven Goldberg
@ethics @NASA
The engineers were not the villains in the Challenger tragedy, but most were no heroes either. Most were doing their engineering job and stayed within the confounds of that job, and not much more. This paper also point out that who many claim to be the main hero of the story, Roger Boisjoly, was in fact displaying separatism: he tried everything within the confines of the existing management structures, and accepted his defeat, having tried everything through the existing channels of communication.
Against separatism, where engineers sharing their opinion do so in principle as civilians (decisions not being their responsibility, but those of management of politicians)) :
Yet surely there are also cases where even a devout separatist would agree that an individual scientist or engineer should speak, as an expert, outside of the usual chain of command. If, for example, an engineer believes his or her tech nical judgments are being suppressed or distorted, and lives are at risk, few would doubt that a dramatic public statement was justified. Indeed, such a statement would serve the separatist goal of informed public opinion. (157)
Would whistle-blowing have been appropriate for Boisjoly? Very hard to say.
Hurdles for whistle-blowing:
- Unclear ethical and professional standards (remind: written in 1987) and no real enforcement
- Unclear what audience the engineer should target with whistle-blowing. Media, higher-ups? Or those who will suffer the consequences?
- Whistleblowers get fired (inadequate protection)