The End of Tradition? | Edited by Nezar AlSayyad

@tradition @detraditionalization

The end of tradition, or the tradition of ends?

"All this emphasis on the re-evaluation of tradition, its role in the production of environments, its relative efficacy of transmission, its demise in the face of globalization, etc., certainly does suggest its possible 'end'. Indeed, if tradition is merely the dialectical fabrication of modernity, then its objective reality is seriously in peril. Does not the end of tradition as an object of inquiry suggest the end of tradition as an objective reality?" (11)

"Fortunately, as stated above, the end of tradition does not entail the death of tradition itself, only an end to our conception of it -- and the emergence of a need to re-evaluate its utility as a repository of authentic (and hence valuable) ideas to be handed down or preserved." (12)

Overview of potentially interesting authors:

Jacobs: "tradition has indeed been brought into being by modernity's own imaginary. But she notes that rather than doing away with tradition, under globalization, tradition has been reshaped and enlivened in a range of unexpected ways. Globalization has thus delivered new conditions for the re-emergence of tradition, installed new mechanism for its transference, and brought into being new political imperatives for its performance."

** FIND QUOTE in Jacobs: Globalization --> new conditions of transmission**

Roy: "presenting the end of tradition s the end of traditional ways of thinking about tradition. Arguing that tradition cannot be understood as having authentic or intrinsic value, she states that the practices of valuation associated with consumption give value to tradition. In other words, the consumption of tradition is the production of tradition."

Two forms of consumption: 1) narratives of nostalgia, heritage, authenticity 2) performance, borrowing, mimicking

Todeschini & Japha: article on Bo-Kaap in South-Africa.

Lu: in 'The Latency of Tradition' she discusses a history of walls in China. Perhaps interesting to write a blog about, but now in relation to Trump's "wall".

General note: "two opposite concepts of tradition appear salient in the general debates. The first privileges national culture and continuity; the second stresses the absence of choice." (23)

"Tradition, like culture, has now, at least for some, become a matter of choice, because both information and alternative identities are now available in this global supermarket." (23)

"So it would seem that what has ended, in the end, is not tradition itself, but the idea of tradition as a harbinger of authenticity, and as a container of specific cultural meaning. What has ended is not tradition, but tradition as a place-based, temporally situated concept; as a static authoritative legacy; and as a heritage owned by certain groups of people. We must recognize that what lasts in tradition today is the 'transient, the fleeting, the contingent', because that is the new way to find 'the eternal and the immutable'. " (23, referentie van Gaonkar, 'On Alternative Modernities')

"Tradition is not dead either. What is dying is tradition revered as authenticity." (23)

Tradition is (not) modern: deterritorializing globalization | Jane M. Jacobs

Classic picture of modern vs tradition (by Anthony Giddens): "This structure of authority is stably confirmed by the locale in which one is embedded. Modernity, it is argued, delivers us away from this embedded mode of dwelling, and injects us into a more disembedded and rationalized, and individual being in the world. For example, Giddens suggests that modernity is marked by a radical turn from tradition, and a demise in 'the local' as a meaningful life-world constituted through face-to-face interactions. (ref Gid.) No longer subjects of fate, we are active agents of choice. Authority lies no longer outside of us, but within us." (30)

"In the first instance we need to move away from seeing 'tradition' as fixity and stasis. The root origin of the word tradition is of course the Latin verb tradere, meaning 'to transmit' or 'to give something over to another'." (31, Luke from "Detraditionalization" is cited here). "The verb root alerts us to the fact that tradition is not a 'thing-like vessel'. Rather, it is something that is handled and which is embedded in action in specific contexts." (31).

"In short, so-called traditional societies only came to see themselves as such once subjected by Europeans and their modes of thought." (31)

"As Tomlinson notes, a homogenization of culture -- the doing away with tradition -- is the most obvious, but least plausible, outcome of globalization. Rather than doing away with tradition, globalization has delivered new conditions for its emergence; installed new mechanisms for its transference; and brought int o being new political imperatives for its performance." (32)

The use of tradition for "traditional" artwork and shows for tourist consumption, and defensive stances in relation to the modern ("nostalgias, religious fundamentalisms, and essentialized identity categories") seem inauthentic and can be called invented traditions, as Hobsbawm and Ranger do (32).

Tradition is (not) modern

Skipped a bunch.

@consumerism

"Another kind of relational process is worth considering when seeking to compare our sense of the tradition/modernity binary. This is the way in which, under the logic of consumption, traditions routinely pass out of the very group they were assumed to belong to. We might think of the seemingly insatiable appetite that the global subculture of the 'New Age' seems to have for indigenous ways of being in the world. These New Age romantics scan the web and scour globally-supplied New Age stores for the traditions they imagine they no longer have "

After this, case studies that I skip here.

The Tradition of the End: Global Capitalism and the Contemporary Spaces of Apocalypse | Katharyne Mitchell

@apocalypse @capitalism @globalization

"What are the shifting conceptions of the apocalypse in the era of capitalist globalization, and how do modern understandings and experiences of space contribute to these conceptions?" (46)

"In the Book of Revelation, as in most apocalyptic narratives, the movement from descriptive to normative time is a profoundly conflictory and catastrophic moment. The traditional world of Babylon must be destroyed in order that the perfect world may be born (again)." (47-48)

Spatial aspects of apocalypse:

"If the idea of the apocalypse is concerned with the ravages of alienation and distance (from God) and of thus restoring the lost perfection of the oneness with God found in Genesis, 'then the pursuit of apocalypse is itself a quest for direct apprehension of the transcendent - a quest for the end of metaphor, escape from the net of words, freedom from entrapment in the hermeneutical circle'. (Hendrix 1990, 2) This 'escape' - from the distance of metaphor, from the alienations of language, from the fissure between subject and object - is fundamentally an escape from all of the paradoxes of time and space." (48-49)

"Apocalyptic thinking represents the quest for a world without metaphor, and hence a world without time or space as it actually exists. It is thus a vision inherently connected with the end of tradition, and ultimately the end of the world." (49)

The spaces of apocalypse now

"According to apocalypse historian Daniel Wojcik, since the nineteenth century a belief in the inevitable end of the world is no longer necessarily tied to the promise of transformation and redemption." (50)

"For religious apocalyptic thinkers, the belief that the cosmos was ordered and that events were inevitable - guided by a stronger or larger force - was central to the regenerative quality of the belief. Faith and fatalism were woven together. For contemporary secular thinkers, however, there seem to be few redemptive qualities in the end of the world narrative. And it is thus a vision characterized largely by pessimism and despair." (51)

Derrida's writing on apocalypse focuses on the fact that the apocalypse signals an end that is a beginning. But it seems now apocalypse becomes empty, merely an ending.

Global capitalism as the apocalypse

"What is most astonishing about these two visions is not the similar depiction of global processes, but the realization that for the former this vision represents apocalypse, while for the latter, utopia. For one group, it is about endings without redemption; and for the other, it is about endings and attendant salvation." (52)

Spaces of identity: towards the global self

"The dislocations occasioned by economic globalization have accelerated the modernist angst of loss of community - community here operating as a metonym for the shared personal spaces of social relationships anchored in a particular place. This has been heightened by the loss of the nation as the default repository of these narratives of shared identities, memories, and histories." (55)

"The loss of these imaginings is widely experienced as unacceptable and viciously struggled over, as it leaves in its wake nothing but a secular image of economic globalization, or, in other words, apocalypse without redemption." (55)

(Rest niet gelezen)

Nostalgias of the modern | Ananya Roy

@nostalgia @authenticity

"It can be argued then that the consumption of tradition is the end of tradition (...) I do not mean this proposition as a lament, a mourning for the commodification of allegedly authentic traditions. Rather, my intention is to point out the inauthenticity of tradition and, further, to note that tradition becomes authentic only in the act of consumption. Put simply, the valuation implicit in consumption gives value to tradition. There is no inherent or intrinsic value to tradition outside these processes of valuation. It can also be argued then that the consumption of tradition is tradition" (63-64)

"The consumption of tradition is the production of tradition. This proposition can in turn be articulated in at least two different ways, in two different systems of meaning." (64)

1) Dwelling (authenticity) 2) Performing (inauthenticity)

"Both involve frameworks of valuation but dwelling, concerned as it is with authenticity, masks the act of valuation in a narrative of nostalgia." (64)

"When formalized as heritage, nostalgia goes a step further: it produces legitimacy through aestheticization." (65)

"Nostalgia as heritage serves a double function -- on the one hand, it generates aesthetic icons of value, icons that add value, icons that revalorize and revitalize; on the other hand, through this aestheticization, it renders invisible the brutal mechanics of capitalist valuation." (65)

"I investigate the modern as a simultaneous transcendence and valuation of tradition. As tradition is superseded by modernist progress, so a pure and distilled tradition is put on display, such that it can be consumed within the circuits of modernization" (67)

(Rest van artikel niet gelezen)