Notes proposal on digital hermeneutics
The basis idea of hermeneutics is that of mediated experience within a broader context.
Progression of hermeneutics:
- Broader context of a whole text.
- Understanding of beings within a lifeworld (~ Heidegger)
- Dialogue within tradition
- Now: our lifeworld is increasingly digital. Hermeneutics needs to be updated in light of this major technology-induced change. Concepts such as "infosphere" or "cyberspace" indicate that the emergence of digital technologies is not just another "tool" but fundamentally changes human reality.
This project extends this mediation to digital technology.
Goal / research question: Brand new form of hermeneutics. There is no single new common framework (hmm... infosphere is pretty clear) Goal is to develop such a framework.
Investigate the various ways in which the things in our lifeworld are mediated by technological technology (broader than just the internet).
Various new forms of mediation are introduced by digital technology specifically!
- Mediation of human action (e.g. mediation of human labour through automation and the need for tracking cf. Pierson)
- Eldred 2016, 78: Humans are captured and controlled by the cyberweb
- Danger of being "engulfed". This needs to be counteracted by realizing the ontological/hermeneutic influence of the digital.
- We should realize the influence of the digital on our lifes in order to not be enslaved by it.
- Main fundamental point: We should "learn to see the historical origins of the simple ontological hermeneutic cast of our present age" (80)
- Mediation of perception (post-phenomenology / mediation theory )
- Algorithmic mediation ( @Mittelstadt @Kaplan )
- Re-evaluation of our understanding of the "real" through deep fake technologies.
- Mediation of our way of thinking and remembering (Stiegler, digital grammatization)
- TODO Splintering of mind: Eldred M. (2015c). Out of your mind? Parmenides’ message. A question of time. North Charleston. SC: CreateSpace.
- The digital/internet ourselves changes our way of being/understanding of reality(?)
- Reinterpretation of the real (both the world and the body) as information (Floridi: infosphere) (goes back to the Greeks, but now this idea has become concrete,practical, material with the onset of the "digital world", rather than a mathematical-ontological insight)
- Eldred: Information is itself mediated by technical human understanding.
- Alternatively: in order for "data" to convey information this data must itself stand in a tradition with technical pre-understanding; without this, the "data" does not speak and say anything. (This is not a point of Eldred)
- A tradition in the hermeneutic sense is a sense tradition i.e. the transmission of particular horizon in which things are meaningful.
- Databases also have an hermeneutical basis (cf. Kelly 2016, p.92)
- Databases are designed and structured with a future recovery in mind, i.e. based on a pre-understanding of this purpose.
- Information retrieval is a "fusion of horizons" with these objectified preconceptions and the preconceptions of those with an information need.
- This is super interesting! An example I think of: when you are Googling something you need to already kind of know what you are looking for. Without this pre-understanding you won't find what you are looking for. On the side of the database, the need of the user need to match the objectified pre-understanding that determines what is retrievable and in what manner.
- See Capurro "Hermeneutical questions concerning the construction of databases", Chapter 3.1, paragraph 1-6.
- Zettelkasten/hermeneutics_of_databases.md
- This technological world-interpretation as a historical epoch with its own understanding of being.
- Various authors point out relations between digitalization and capitalism, and how both reshape society. Cf. Stiegler, or maybe have a look at Eldred's "The Digital Cast of Being" or "Eldred M. (2015b). Capital and technology: Marx and Heidegger. North Charleston. SC: CreateSpace."
A form of material hermeneutics (cf. Ihde): focuses less on how meanings are sedimented in texts and tradition, but more on how technological artefacts open particular possibilities for perception and action (two sides of mediation). This approach still has the same basic hermeneutic principle: it's not the designer's intention that matters (cf. Ihde's designer fallacy).
See notes on Eldred: When we speak about the cyberworld it is very easy to forget its materiality. But for example the "infiltration" or "implantation" of foreign bits of program code is something very real in a material sense: it can shut down a power plant. The cyberworld is a new domain for power struggles.
The notion of pre-understanding is still very relevant but needs to be updated. Not only sedimented meanings in tradition, but also
A digital ontology implies a digital hermeneutics, because "information" is only information for humans. The hermeneutic "as" even already applies to brute physical signals because they and the devices that handle them are predesigned from technical human understanding. See Eldred-Turings_Cyberworld.md
Why is hermeneutical philosophy relevant for studying digital technology? Because digital technologies are an essential part of processes that are transforming/uprooting our society. Capitalist consumerism (cf. Morozov 2013, Stiegler 2015), the uprooting of traditions (references), predictions of mass unemployment due to automation transforming old conceptions of work, pressure on democracy from AI techniques being able to produce human-like texts or deepfake images and videos, (various "smart" technologies mainly contributing to mass surveillance?) are all components of an overall trend that can be construed as a crisis of meaning. (even changes the way we think, cf. digital tertiary retention)
How can I strengthen the connection to meaning?
Ihde: material hermeneutics.
Post-phenomenology / later philosophers of technology: focuses on technology "how new meanings and functions are made with technologies (Ihde, 2009)" (Tripathi 2016, 146)
Meaningful: technologies mediate the ways in which the word appears to us as meaningful. But can also help create new meanings?
Verbeek, Fatum interview: "I believe postphenomenology sees it completely differently: science and technology are a way of interpreting the world, one of the ways in which the world can become meaningful for us."
Verbeek-Fatum_Interview_Mediation_Theory.md
Focus on hermeneutical ontology: Digital technologies have moved well beyond being mere handy "instruments" towards fundamentally shaping and mediating how contemporary humans perceive reality.
See Don Ihde 2004, p. 94 for reference to how Kapp theorized technology as an extension to the human body.
See Tripathi_2016-Significance_Digital_Hermeneutics_for_Phil_of_Technology.md
Tripathi 2016, 145: "Likewise, all technical artifacts such as laptop and pen can be explained, similarly, to be extensions of the human body (Vries, 2005, p. 68)."
But is this extension theory still feasible/realistic when technologies become increasingly complex and pervasive? Like the emergence of an "infosphere?" The "extension" theory relies on analogies to the human body; doesn't seem appropriate here anymore. This is where Don Ihde's post-phenomenology comes in.
Hermeneutic mediation of perception in Materializing Morality : "The hermeneutic or experience-oriented perspective starts from the side of world and directs itself at the ways reality can be interpreted and present for people." (464)
See ICTS-Verbeek-Materializing_Morality.md .
Also, Verbeek 2008 as quoted by Tripathi 2016:
Technologies are not neutral instruments or intermediaries, but active mediators that help shape the relation between people and reality. This mediation has two directions: one pragmatic, concerning action, and the other hermeneutic, concerning interpretation.
See: Verbeek, P. P. (2008). Morality in design: Design ethics and the morality of technological artifacts. In P. E. Vermaas, P. Kroes, A. Light, S. A. Moore (Eds.), Philosophy and design: From engineering to architecture (pp. 91-103). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
By Tripathi 2016: material hermeneutics is more focused on perception than language (cf. that in Materializing Morality Verbeek mentions hermeneutics indeed in relation to perception)
In fact, Ihde’s aim in Expanding Hermeneutics is to show that science is a profoundly hermeneutic activity, and that hermeneutics, therefore, is not limited to the humanities (Verbeek, 2003). Material hermeneutics retains the imperative for critical, interpretive work, which all hermeneutics requires, but it is more a perceptual than a linguistic interpretation. After all, much of natural science solely investigates the non-speaking, non-writing, non-linguistic phenomena that is quite removed from the social scientific interests that underpin this other realm (Ihde, 2009).
Digital reinterpretation of the world (or our body): When someone asks what technology X means you expect an answer in terms of information. (Find examples in Floridi 2014) Floridi thus argues that we are living in an infosphere. This ontological effect is
Verbeek's mediation theory does something similar. Expresses how technologies (but does not necessarily focus on digital technologies)
Deepfakes and AI: the inability to ascertain whether images and videos are "real" or not, infects the value of common facts important to well-functioning democratic discourse (deepfake reference from paper). Spreading of fake news.
Likewise digitalization furthers processes of automation, because it allows the efficient tracking (see existing notes). Again: reinterpretation of the reality of human work. Human itself becomes a tool for entering data in a standardized process that is digitally tracked (Pierson e.a.). Beyond "inherent virtuousness of work" (Bertrand Russell), decoupling labour from work (Stiegler),
Ethics of algorithms: responsibility beyond intention of designers. Some effect of algorithms are not foreseen and are due to their ontological effects (Mittelstadt). This is not easy to think. But this is especially a way of thinking that is characteristic for hermeneutical philosophy: the world is always already disclosed to us in a particular way, such a meaning is not the result of someone's intention, but has to be seen against the background of a particular tradition and life-world. Basically, hermeneutical philosophy is a particular theory of how our access to the world, i.e. the fact that we experience the world in a meaningfulway, is mediated e.g. through tradition and our throwness in a context in which particular potentialities for understanding and action are disclosed.
Idea of algorithmic mediation:
Google paper that Stiegler refers to: Kaplan, “Linguistic Capitalism and Algorithmic Mediation”, Representations 27 (2014), pp. 57–63.
This article argues that linguistic capitalism implies not an economy of attention but an economy of expression. As several million users worldwide daily express themselves through one of Google's interfaces, the texts they produce are systematically mediated by algorithms. In this new context, natural languages could progressively evolve to seamlessly integrate the linguistic biases of algorithms and the economical constraints of the global linguistic economy From Kaplan's abstract:
This article argues that linguistic capitalism implies not an economy of attention but an economy of expression. As several million users worldwide daily express themselves through one of Google's interfaces, the texts they produce are systematically mediated by algorithms. In this new context, natural languages could progressively evolve to seamlessly integrate the linguistic biases of algorithms and the economical constraints of the global linguistic economy
Move towards tradition: mediation effect due to change in the transmission of meaning? (cf. tradition)
See Heelas,Lash,Morris_eds-Detraditionalization.md , specifically Thompson
See AlSayyad_editor-The_End_of_Tradition.md
Check our Morozov's claim that algorithmic regulation suppresses disagreement and conflict, https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jul/20/rise-of-data-death-of-politics-evgeny-morozov-algorithmic-regulation :
[A]lgorithmic regulation offers us a good-old technocratic utopia of politics without politics. Disagreement and conflict, under this model, are seen as unfortunate byproducts of the analog era – to be solved through data collection – and not as inevitable results of economic or ideological conflicts.
This is particularly interesting because the possibility of disagreement is absolutely for any real dialogue. A digital hermeneutics should thus absolutely counteract that movement:
where this is also a matter of redesigning the digital architecture and in particular the digital architecture of the web, with the goal of creating a digital hermeneutics that gives to controversies and conflicts of interpretation their negentropic value, and constitutes on this basis an economy of work and knowledge founded on intermittence, for which the model must be the French system designed to support the so-called “intermittents du spectacle”
Pöggeler: Poggeler-Hermeneutics_of_Technical_World.md
Apparently there is also danger in new worlds being opened up by new instruments.
Similarly Becker considers the criterion for the danger of the challenge to be the fact that 'entirely new worlds are opened up' by new instruments. (39)
For Heidegger the peasant that cleared the woodlands was the prototype of dwelling on earth. But Pöggeler makes a skeptical remark here: those technologies that express the fundamental of reality change curiously often. Does the whole of reality change?
Those technologies which ought to reveal the basic tendencies of our times change rapidly, and so the talk of the nuclear age is soon replaced by talk of the age of information.
Links to check
Check ook mijn oude notities over traditie.
- http://www.digitalhumanities.org/dhq/vol/11/3/000337/000337.html
- https://www.crcpress.com/Digital-Hermeneutics-Philosophical-Investigations-in-New-Media-and-Technologies/Romele/p/book/9780367353667
- https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01824173/document
- https://www.cs.vu.nl/~guus/papers/Akker11a.pdf
- http://www.capurro.de/digitalhermeneutics.html
- https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2F978-3-658-14681-8_8