On the concepts of work and labour
@work @automation @labour @Stiegler @Russell \ Have a look at Stiegler's work: Automatic Society. Fragment from publisher's summary:
Stiegler advocates a radical solution to the crisis posed by automation and consumer capitalism more generally. He calls for a decoupling of the concept of labour (meaningful, intellectual participation) from employment (dehumanizing, banal work), with the ultimate aim of eradicating employment altogether. By doing so, new and alternative economic models will arise, where individuals are no longer simply mined for labour, but also actively produce what they consume.
Work may be automated, whereas labour may not.
Compare this with this remark from Bertrand Russell in In Praise of Idleness:
I want to say, in all seriousness, that a great deal of harm is being done in the modern world by the belief in the virtuousness of work, and that the road to happiness and prosperity lies in an organized diminution of work.
The promise of automation is that we have to work less to get the same result. Nevertheless, some people end up working more and others are automatized out of a job. Those without a job are treated as parias for not working, whereas we applaud those working themselves into burn-outs.
This is related to the question of self-automation: if you automate your own job and produce the result you are being paid for more efficiently, even though you for example play games in working time, that might not be appreciated by your employer. In other words, such a situation would likely be considered unethical because you did not "put the work in", despite delivering exactly all results expected from you. This points towards the belief in the inherent "virtuousness of work," as Russell said.
Coming back to Stiegler's decoupling of work and labour Stiegler-Automatic_Society_1_introduction.md:209 :
We have seen before that Stiegler argues that the nihilistic and capitalist elements related to automation must themselves be overcome by forms of automation (albeit, different ones)? In this section, Stiegler really takes an accelerationist position by arguing that automation must be completed and that the completion of automation will show the necessity of a social reorganization.
To be honest, apart from the abstract terms, this story makes sense to me: general automation will show decisively that work can no longer be the measure of value, or have inherent value, as it has been completely automatized.
To hold on, that is, to hold good to this promise, is to hold on, precisely, starting from those neganthropic possibilities opened up by automation itself: it is to think this industry of reticulation as a new epoch of work, as the end of the epoch of “employment”, given that the latter is ultimately and permanently compromised by complete and general automation. And it is to think this industry as the ‘transvaluation’ of value, whereby «labour time ceases and must cease to be its measure, and hence exchange value [must cease to be the measure] of use value» [48], and where the value of value become neganthropy. Only in this way can and must the passage from the Anthropocene to the Neganthropocene be accomplished. (136)
Cf. [48]: Karl Marx, Grundrisse: Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy (Rough Draft) (London: Pelican, 1973), p. 705.