Data and subjectification
Self-Tracking, Big Data, and the questions of Subjectification and Primitive Accumulation | Gordon @Hull , February 2017
@capitalism @accumulation
Blog by Gordon Hull .
Source: https://www.newappsblog.com/2017/02/self-tracking-big-data-and-the-questions-of-subjectification-and-primitive-accumulation.html
On "The diverse domains of quantified selves: self-tracking modes and dataveillance" by Deborah Lupton's, https://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03085147.2016.1143726 .
Next to concerns about privacy and discrimination, there is emerging research into big data as a form of capitalist accumulation.
One discussion concerns "whether the value that individuals freely contribute to the Internet can be described in Marxian terms as surplus labor."
Hull's own contribution: think about the level of primitive accumulation, cf. David Harvey's "accumulation by possesion". See below for notes! That post concerns the dispossession of preferences.
This post concerns another mechanism, coercive self-tracking. See Deborah Lupton's paper https://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03085147.2016.1143726 .
As Lupton emphasizes with a useful typology, self-tracking can take a number of forms, which she aligns more-or-less in terms of their voluntariness.
- Quantified-self movement, goal is self-improvement of self-discovery
- Pushed self-tracking e.g. in patient care
- Hull calls this a "confessional practice"
- Earlier he remarked that the preceding element is not yet present in the self-improvement idea. The confessional aspect: "What is not present is the later Christian examination of conscience or the exploration of “the secrets of the heart, the mysteries of the heart in which the roots of sin are to be found” (246)."
- See Hull-Confessing preferences, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2887480
W.r.t. the quantified-self movement:
Interesting passage w.r.t. predigital self-tracking, the diary, and Foucault's remarks on Stoic self-examination.
Lupton notes briefly that such practices as diary-keeping can be viewed as pre-digital methods of self tracking. She does not draw the connection here, but this description of self-tracking actually hews very closely to what Foucault says about Stoic self-examination in On the Government of the Living. There, citing Seneca, he suggests that stoic practices are “in the world of administration” (242), that is, “the scene of the functionary inspector who, as it were, looks over the shoulder of the daily functionary to see whether he has done what he had to do” (242). Indeed, even Seneca’s language – “I take the measure again of my faults and actions” suggests this sort of dispassionate outcomes assessment, where “once the mistake has been discovered, there is the formulation of a rule of conduct for the future” (243). (I am emphasizing the language of bureaucracy and administration deliberately: Lupton notes that self-tracking fits the imperatives of audit culture).
This data is likely not transferable in a way that is interesting to others (cf. Lupton 106).
When self-tracking ceases to be voluntary:
For example, she notes that “pushed self-tracking” (where the impetus comes from outside the subject) is especially prominent in “the patient self-care, health promotion and preventative medicine literature” (107). The goal isn’t just improvement, it’s confessional:
"In this context, the personal data generated from self-tracking are represented as pedagogical and motivational, a means of encouraging self-reflection or emotional responses such as fear, guilt or shame that will then lead to the advocated behavior changes" (Lupton 107)
These nudges and pushed can be increasingly coercive and even exploitative; examples include intensive, compulsory workplace monitoring, as evidenced by the general trend toward what Ifeoma Ajunwa, Kate Crawford and Jason Schultz aptly call “Limitless Worker Surveillance.”
See Limitless Worker Surveillance: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2746211
Ref. to PatientsLikeMe, the abuse of "voluntary" provided patient data:
It is when self-tracking shades into exploitation that we face a regime of primitive accumulation. Lupton cites the experience of those in sites like PatientsLikeMe, who freely volunteer and share their health information – and who almost never see any of the returns developed from that information. What happens instead is that Pharma harvests the data and patents whatever it produces as a result. As Lupton suggests, “this is a form of exploited self-tracking, in which the ‘little analytics’ of people’s volunteered personal information turns into commodified big data” (113; internal citation omitted).
There is a tendency here, which she underscores, that “once they are digitized, the array of practices that began as personal and private tend to become inextricably imbricated within these networks and economies” (115)
Three suggestions (one about big data, two about theory)
-
Big data
-
"self-tracking can be used as a technique to generate value from data."
- "To the extent that this data becomes walled-off from use by those who provide it (as for example, when it generates patented treatments that the providers have to pay for access to), they are left with less than they had before."
-
@self-improvement "Workplace programs show the same pattern: Marx describes primitive accumulation as fundamentally a process of depriving people of anything other than the need to be a worker (see below for some quotes); in that sense, both intensive surveillance within the workplace, but even more importantly, endless surveillance outside it in the form of employee wellness programs and other kinds of tracking, function analogously. The worker becomes “free” of any encumbrance that might distance her from her workplace." (my emphasis)
- This is what I call the cynical view on self-improvement, especially when it is offered by workplaces and/or pushed. For who is the improvement? Are we not just improving
-
Theory: Marx meets Foucault
Second, as a matter of theory, it seems increasingly important to align Foucauldian concerns about subjectification (which is indeed Lupton’s framing) with Marxian concerns about primitive accumulation. This is something I struggled with on the question of dispossession of preferences, as the taking of preferences is at the same time an attempt to replace them with those of homo economicus.
See Hull's 2016 post (notes below).
Very interesting hypothesis:
here, I just want to make the point that many of the techniques that can be described as encouraging modes of subjection can also be described as aspects of capitalist accumulation. This overlap suggests a hypothesis: we need to understand that primitive accumulation is itself a mode of subjection, and vice versa.
- I do not understand this point
Third, and finally, the overlap between concepts of subjectification and accumulation is further muddied by the usage of alienation vocabulary by current autonomist theorists to describe the effects of cognitive capital.