Big Data, Commodification and Original Accumulation | By Gordon @Hull , April 2016

@data @commodification @accumulation @Marx

Blog by Gordon Hull .

Source: https://www.newappsblog.com/2016/04/big-data-commodification-and-original-accumulation.html

Refers to: Thatcher et al., Data Colonialism Through Accumulation by Dispossession: New Metaphors for Daily Data, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2709498

To read later, related: https://www.newappsblog.com/2016/07/regimes-of-accumulation.html

Thatcher et al. argue that "big data functions in the context of capital as 'accumulation by dispossession,' which is David Harvey's term for what Marx called 'primitive accumulation,' the process by which capital adds to its wealth by taking goods from others and adding them to the system."

Hull cites Marx, Capital I, 875, Penguin edition:

so-called primitive accumulation, therefore, is nothing else than the historical process of divorcing the producer from the means of production

Another Marx citation:

“The spoliation of the Church’s property, the fraudulent alienation of the state domains, the theft of the common lands, the usurpation of feudal and clan property and its transformation into modern private property under circumstances of ruthless terrorism, all these things were just so many idyllic methods of primitive accumulation. They conquered the field for capitalist agriculture, incorporated the soil into capital, and created for the urban industries the necessary supplies of free and rightless proletarians” (895)

This is the main new @metaphor concerning Big Data: just like in capitalism's primitive accumulation the producer is divorced from the means of production (instead forced to sell labour to factories etc.), just so is there a "separation of the valued information from the person who produces it."

Critical note from Hull:

the data trail that a person leaves is generally itself without value, and only becomes valuable when aggregated with a lot of other data. In other words, as I tried to argue a while ago, data is itself without value; it is only when it becomes information that it realizes that value.

(See for reference: https://www.newappsblog.com/2013/12/big-data-why-privacy-is-no-help-at-all.html)

Intermezzo from December 2013 post

But the pairing of ‘voluntary’ and ‘information’ also suggests that I have some cognizance of the semantic content of what I am sharing. I may not know why information is valuable to someone else, but I at least know what that information is.

In the case of big data, e.g. NSA analysis of massive amounts of phone call meta-data, the data only becomes information in light of a larger scale data analysis. As a result, consumers do not realize the significance of this data:

Big data challenges that. We have no idea of the meaning of this material we are providing as we go about our daily lives, or even that it is meaningful: we are providing data, not information. The NSA case is exemplary: it’s true that we know what our phone number is, and presumably the number we are calling, but the significance of those two numbers emerges only when they’re part of a much larger analysis. In that sense, the status of my phone number and the connections it makes as “information” is (for lack of a better term) an emergent property of the data analysis, in the sense that it has no significance and no relevant meaning until after it’s analyzed with other data.

Nice formulation from comments, by Robin James: "A datum cannot be information; only data can be, and only, it seems, vast amounts of data, really. So information emerges from analyzing a "population" of data."

Example:

Consider the case where I frequently dial Mr. X, and Mr. X is closely tied to a terrorist group. That would get me on a watch list, and probably even the attention of some human agents - but only if the NSA’s computer also had knowledge of X’s ties to the terrorist group. If the computer lacked that knowledge, my connection to X wouldn’t be represented to anyone, and the system would proceed without ever flagging me. The information that I have suspicious ties to a terrorist group simply would not exist.

The fundamental issue is that as consumers, we do not necessarily know what we are disclosing, which weakens the argument that you freely gave away that information, e.g. metadata of which you do not understand the importance. In particular *data @mining * limits the extent to which consumers know the value of their data, because you cannot foresee all contexts in which your data displays information about you:

But there’s a lot of examples where it’s not clear that I voluntarily release information, as a good deal of what big data does is mining: it generates new, emergent information from large data streams. If nothing else, there's a lot of material that is going to be 'data' when viewed at one moment or from one point of view, and 'information' when viewed from another.

In other words, in big data, information is emergent.

Conclusion:

In short, a meaningful notion of information needs to include some sort of semantic content, and probably some de minimis level of significance. Most of what makes big data so powerful is its ability to generate new information from vast data flows.

Cnt'd

Main points:

  • Data is not yet information
    • To do, look up Nate Silver's "Signal & Noise"
  • Data is itself without value (this is a complicated issue, I suspect)
  • Data requires manipulation, e.g. aggregration, to become information and gain value.

The commodification of data into information includes:

  1. "the elevation of exchange value over use value"
  2. "the conversion of qualitatively different items of data into commensurable units of information"

These parallel processes imply a "reduction of quality into quantity". "In Marx, this is the conversion of labor into labor power; without this conversion of qualitatively different objects and processes of labor into something that could be measured by a consistent standard, capitalism could not function."

Hull quoting Marx:

Or, as he puts it more summatively, “what exclusively determines the magnitude of the value of any article is therefore the amount of labor socially necessary, or the labor-time socially necessary for its production” (129).

Hull emphasizes that this conversion is an ontological process:

it is no accident that Marx says that the analysis of commodities shows them to be “very strange thing[s], abounding in metaphysical subtleties and theological niceties” (163). That is, there is a fundamental difference between human labor, in the sense of making a nail, or planting a seed, and the same thing expressed as the expenditure of socially averaged time.

Back to data! We may discern a similar process in how data becomes commodified i.e. becomes information with value:

So one of the things that capital does in converting data into information is to convert it into a 21c equivalent of labor-power: information, which can be priced. When data becomes information, i.e., “as soon as it emerges as a commodity, it changes into a thing which transcends sensuousness” (163).

Hull plays a very nice trick when he substitutes "commodity" with "data" in a Marx quote from Capital 163, resulting in the following quote:

“The mysterious character of data commodified as information consists therefore simply in the fact that the information reflects the social characteristics of men’s own data as objective characteristics of the data itself, as the socio-natural properties of that data. Hence it also reflects the social relation of the producers of data to the sum total of data as a social relation between information, a relation which exists apart from and outside the data."

In other words, data as recorded in some social context, itself has no capitalist value unless it is commodified into information. This process of commodification in turn standardizes and objectifies this value, as if the information itself objectively represents something about that person.

Whatever value the data had to the person is converted becomes inexpressible except in market terms of monetary value.

Example:

As I argue elsewhere, the data industry approach to privacy is one that encourages users to treat their private information in commodified terms, as something they might exchange for some other consumer product.

And: "Even more significantly, this process makes the social value of privacy completely invisible."

This conversion of use to exchange value does, therefore, seem like a place to talk about primitive accumulation, because individuals may very well lose things of importance to them in the process of data collection. For example, the mysterious processes of credit (and other) scoring systems, which aggregate vast amounts of data about people, might make it impossible to obtain financing to buy a house, when previously one could have done so. Absent the protections of the GINA, information that one has the BRCA1/2 genetic mutation that increases the risk of breast cancer might make the individual in question uninsurable, when previously she could have obtained coverage. Even the credit ratings of one’s friends have predictive value.

Second main point:

The other thing that commodification does, strongly suggested in the Marx passage on commodity fetishism, is to deracinate the data, separating it from whatever context it originally occurs.

Cf. Helen Nissenbaum in the context of privacy.

Processes of "branding" do something similar: "In this way, politics becomes invisible, and the entire social field becomes legible only in economic terms (I take it this is the core of any successful definition of neoliberalism)."

Big Data as a continuation of the idea that market purchases show prefernces:

I might prefer to buy a Porsche but end up buying a Kia instead, because I can’t afford the former. Thus my “preference” will be coded as Kia over Porsche. But that’s clearly not the case – it’s that I had to fit my preferences into my budget; that information isn’t visible in the purchase decision. On a first glance, big data seems to be designed to solve this problem: if we aggregate enough data about me, then my real preferences will become clear.

So commodification of data raises this representation of a person's information, used as if it was objective and representative. But in light of what Hull has written, the process of commodification itself shows the underlying ontological and epistemic assumptions:

What we definitely know is that it will have to exclude any number of important characteristics of me the concrete individual – this is Marx’s point about the conversion of labor to labor-power, and Mader’s point about the ontological difference of norms. In that sense, the deracination of relevant information makes my preferences inscrutable, because they are no longer about me. They are about a profile, and profiles and representations always are incomplete. All of this undermines the putative epistemic value of markets.