E4AI Questions
Cirrus
Changeable dynamically in Cirrus:
- Multiple choice
- Multiple response
- Either / or
Other types have to be completely removed if they are no good.
Nice to sometimes have but not too much:
- Drag and drop
- Essay is OK, but you need to provide an answer key
Do not use "fill in the blanks". This just doesn't work for philosophy.
Ethical skills
Q: Why are ethical skills important for people working in AI?
- AI is prominent in daily life so we need to consider its implications
- Society demands ethical reflection on the consequences of technology
- Funding agencies require ethical "pillars"
Could add a fourth and ask which one is not important
Questions about the ethical cycle
- Pose a question and ask in which part of the ethical cycle it is relevant
- In which phase in the ethical cycle are ethical frameworks not relevant?
- What role do ethical frameworks play?
- Justification vs. prescribing action
- Does an ethical framework help you distinguish the morally relevant facts?
- Engage in criticism of the ethical theories rather than taking them for granted
- Desired result: wide reflective equilibrium between these considerations. See below.
- Does not imply knowing what is right or wrong
- Helps understand moral intuitions
- And elucidate the principles underlying them
- Identify limits to our views
- Important for becoming a responsible professional
Descriptive vs. normative
Have two statements/claims. Four possible answers: Both are descriptive, both are normative, A is descr. B is norm. etc.
Ethics vs morality
- Ethics: the systematic reflection on what is moral
- Morality: totality of opinions, decisions, actions with which people express, individually or collectively, what they think is good or right.
Values vs. norms vs. virtues
Distinction value and norm
- Values are aspirational, norms prescriptive
- Values are ends, norms are means for achieving values
- Norms relate values to specific contexts
Values are aspirational and to be strived for, but are not directly connected with specific rules that specify how to achieve a particular value. In practice, values and norms should go hand in hand. Norms are only meaningful in light of the aspirational values they support, whereas these values are ineffective without any way I do think that in practice people immediately do think of connected norms when thinking about a value.
"In our company integrity is important and we expect honesty from our employees. When remote working, don't lie about your working hours."
What here is a value, a virtue and a norm?
- Value: integrity.
- Virtue: honesty
- Norm: don't lie.
Relativism, universalism, absolutisim
Universalism: there is a universally applicable system of norms and values.
Absolutism: all actions are intrinsically right or wrong. An absolutist would for example state that stealing is inherently wrong, even if this is done with morally good intentions (e.g. stealing to feed your dying child in a situation of immense duress).
N.B. so universalism is not necessarily absolutist.
Q: What is an example of a universally applicable ethical theory that is not absolutist?
Well, utilitarianism is a great example here. It is a system that is applicable to all moral considerations, but it does not commit to one particular set of values or norms. It merely requires you to weigh them against each other by the maxim that the utility after the moral decision should be maximized, given the situation.
N.B. so universalism is not necessarily absolutist.
Q: Can you name an example of an ethical theory that does make recommendations?
I would say this is deontological ethics: it is heavily prescriptive and also disregards the consequences of actions and the uncertainty that they introduce.
Ethical theories
Consequentalist vs utilitarian vs. deontological vs. virtue ethics
Virtues of AI professionals
Minimal:
- Reliability
- Honesty
- Responsibility
- Solidarity
Specifically for engineers, by Pritchard (2001), ETE 113:
Pritchard 2001:
- Expertise/professionalism
- Informative communication
- Cooperation
- Willingness to make compromises
- Objectivity
- Being open to criticism
- Stamina
- Creativity
- Striving for quality
- Having an eye for detail
- Habit of reporting work carefully
Neutrality thesis
- Alice: Technology has a use plan
- Bob: But technologists cannot determine and foresee its use
- Alice: Inventions bring about new possible and morally relevant actions
-
Bob: But users still decide what to do with these possibilities
-
Charlie: No use in discussion for too long, someone else would have invented the technology anyways at some point.
Which statement is correct?
- Bob is a instrumentalist and Alice is a fan of mediation theory, Charlie is determinist
- etc.
What is a dual use argument?
See neutrality thesis artefacts
Responsibility
What is the difference between passive and active responsibility?
Passive responsibility
Passive: after the fact, backward looking
- Accountability: provide an account of what has happened and why if you were responsible
- Blameworthiness: this could make you the object of moral blame, in case of:
- Wrongdoing; breaking a moral norm or code of conduct
- Causal contribution; either by doing or refraining from doing
- Foreseeability; you can't be held accountable for consequences that were impossible to foresee
- Freedom of action; no coercion of extreme duress
Active responsibility
Active: forward looking, taking into account both moral and professional duties
Active responsibility is therefore never really fulfilled. It is primarily about aspiring to reach an ideal.
Ideals can differ of course.
- Technological enthusiasm: go ahead and do it for the sake of technological innovation itself . E.g. Oppenheimer.
- Worry about consequences later?
- Effectiveness and efficiency, e.g. Frederick Winslow Taylor.
- Worker exploitation?
- Human welfare, e.g. "Engineers against poverty"
Fallacies of technological risk
- Ostrich fallacy
- There is no scientific proof that X is dangerous
- So X does not give an unacceptable risk
- (The correct conclusion would be: we do not know and perhaps: better safe than sorry)
- Delay fallacy
- We take no decision about X now because we first need more data to understand the problem
- This fallacy is interesting to counter with the paradigm of value-sensitive design
- Price fallacy
- We must weight benefits and risk of X
- So X is something we have to put a price on
- E.g. it is most likely not ethical to put a price on a life
- "Eventual" fallacy
- From Koepsell 2010
- Someone will discover this dangerous technology at some point anyway, so we should do it first, since we have good intentions.
- Can justify any type of research, however dangerous.
- But why does this research need to be done now?
Exam Questions from last year
Discuss Roger Boisjoly’s role in the Challenger 9 accident. Evaluate his actions using the terminology of the textbook (mainly chapter 1):
A
-
Explain what his active responsibility was: what he was and could be expected to do, what he should have done (75 words).
-
Try to make sense of his actions in the light of his role. Also remembering the two papers you have read about his case, do you think he was morally justified in acting the way he did? Briefly explain your reasons why (not). (125 words)
B
Do you consider the company Morton Thiokol responsible for the Challenger disaster? Explain why (not). In answering this question, refer to the criteria for moral responsibility and use the information available. (200 words)
C
1) What are the facts you take to be central for your analysis of this case (50 words) 2) The moral nature of the problem that is most important according to you (50 words) 3) The options for action you think most important to consider (50 words) 4) Your ethical evaluation of these actions (indicate briefly the main ethical perspective you’re taking) (50 words) 5) Skip the reflection, instead, provide your main recommendation (50 words)
D
What, in your view, is currently an important societal application of AI that is urgently in need for further ethical analysis? In order to answer this question, specify the following elements:
1) What is the application? (50 words) 2) Why is it societally important? (50 words) 3) Why is it urgent to analyse the application ethically? (50 words) 4) Which aspects of the ethical cycle seem most relevant to you for the analysis of the application? (50 words) 5) Without giving your reasons, which recommendation would you want to give and to whom (which participants or stakeholders) specifically? (50 words)
Brainstorm
- Hotspot question: working hours value, virtue, norm (3 variants in total)
A self-driving car hits a pedestrian
The vast majority of accounts that the AI predicts to be fraudulent are from male account holders.
- "First, not only an action, but also a failure to act may often be considered a causal contribution, like in the case of the Challenger the failure to stop the launch. Second, a causal contribution is usually not a sufficient condition for the occurrence of the consequence under consideration. Often, a range of causal contributions will have to be present for the consequence to occur. A causal contribution will often be a necessary ingredient in the actual chain of events that led to the consequence, that is, without the causal contribution the consequence would not have occurred." --- 0.059, 2020-02-20
Van der Poel et al. list causal contribution as one of the requirements for moral bla bla. Can a failure to act also be considered a causal contribution?
If you can show that someone caused an accident, is that enough to show that someone is morally responsible?
-
"Usually, four conditions need to apply: wrong-doing, causal contribution, foreseeability, and freedom." --- 0.059, 2020-02-20
-
Accountability: provide an account of what has happened and why if you were responsible
- Blameworthiness: this could make you the object of moral blame, in case of:
- Wrongdoing; breaking a moral norm or code of conduct
- Causal contribution; either by doing or refraining from doing
- Foreseeability; you can't be held accountable for consequences that were impossible to foresee
- Freedom of action; no coercion of extreme duress
Imagine
Professional responsbility of engineers; zie list in notes. Geef voorbeeld;welke is geen professional responsibility?
Which of the following statements is false?
- Active responsibility is not primarily about blame
- A failure to act can also be seen as a causal contribution and incite moral blame
- It is not possible to hold
Which of the following remarks does not hold:
- Ethics is about prescribing actions
-
Causal contribution --> component of blame worthiness.
Which of the following statements is true?
Reflective equilibrium:
TODO: Consequentialism & utilism
the measurement of the effectiveness and efficiency of a technology is value-laden.
Moeilijke...!
- One can be responsible for something one did not cause
DONE
Imagine that the Dutch railways want to increase the overall safety of passengers by using facial recognition to spot aggression in the train and on stations. Let's say you work at the Dutch railways and you have to explain to passengers why this is the ethical thing to do.
Which ethical theory is most likely to be used for justifying this decision?
Which ethical theory is most likely to be used to argue against this decision?
- Consequentialism
- Deontology
- Virtue ethics
- Care ethics
Ethical theories offer ways to reflect on the question why a certain course of action would be just or unjust. As such they can be used for justifying a course of action. Ethical theories do not however necessarily prescribe actions. Which one of the following ethical theories nevertheless most clearly prescribes what to do?