Going Postcard: The Letter(s) of Jacques Derrida | edited by Vincent W.J. van Gerven Oei.

Derrida_Jacques.md

After a quick scan, what might be interesting to read?

Troubling Lines: The Process of Address in Derrida's The Post Card

When I read this, I realized how annoying literature about Derrida can be. The association with the Holocaust is unnecessary and borderline offensive. The emphasis on violence is terribly exaggerated.

The selecting of one addressee over another, the encoding of a message to a specific audience, effectively excludes an entire world of other readers, an act that Derrida associates with the holocaust. When one addresses a letter, one engages in a process of exclusion and violence, which, in principle, has no limit to its destructive force. Hence, addressing necessarily involving the risks of violence, exclusion, death, and annihilation. Yet, while these risks remain necessarily immense and irreducible, they also remain, at root, indecipherable. (61)

I get the inclusion and exclusion part, but how on earth does it necessarily imply a life-death distinction. There's probably a clear connection with Derrida's writing somewhere, but it's assumed rather than explained.

The addressing of a letter is not, for Derrida, merely an act of inclusion or exclusion. It is an action that encodes the very determinations of inclusion and exclusion, violence and nonviolence, and, most radically, life and death. Insofar as every act of addressing involves both the denial and extension of life, this process also clandestinely demarcates the border separating life from death, living from non-living. (62)

Drawing Blanks - Michael Naas

  • On the various blanks that appear throughout the envois
  • Does not seem directly relevant

Postcard Telepathy

Very short, very unsystematic, just some loose associations.

Post by a thousand cuts

Brutal images of lingchi (Chinese torture), on Bataille as well, but nothing relevant for me right now.

Ateleia/Autoimmunity | Eszter Timár

Such a clear statement in the first sentence is very rare in literature on Derrida!

"I would like to highlight an important connection between Derrida’s use of the term “autoimmunity” in his later work and the postal principle of The Post Card." (83)

"The connection is articulated in the historical construction of the name of stamp collection, or love of the stamp as “philately,” which is constructed with the help of the Greek ateleia. Both terms, ateleia and immunis, refer to tax exemption." (83)

From Wikipedia, which indeed immediately mentions this connection:

"Ateleia (Attic Greek: ἀτέλεια; privative a + τέλος telos (tax); see also philately) in ancient Greece was a general immunity (ἄδεια adeia) or exemption from some or all the duties which a person has to perform towards the state."

This connection is important because autoimmunity, as it appears in Derrida's later works, can perhaps be seen a better name for deconstruction than deconstruction itself (cf. 83)

The point of highlighting the connection between ateleia and autoimmunity:

1) Shows continuity between early/mid "apolitical" deconstruction and Derrida's later "ethical" phase. 2) This link can elucidate the significance of "life in general", a "concept of life" that "cannot be securely placed as originating in the "biological" or the "organic." " (84)

The connection

See PC 55 for a quite clear mention of ateleia.

For an explanation of immunity and auto-immunity, see the quotes passage from "Faith and Knowledge":

We can see that tax exemption is the shared feature of both ateleia and the immunis. Ateleia, whose significance in “Envois” exceeds the mere choice for naming philately in the nineteenth century by connecting exemption with laws, paralysis, and love, reminds us of the political link. (86)

In later texts explicitly thematizing the immune, autoimmunity becomes such an important term due to the tension between the auto and the embedded immunis, a tension destabilizing the privilege of ipseity within the concept of the immune. (86-87)

TO BE CONTINUED

Some loose thoughts while reading

Hermeneutics. Hermes: he who delivers the post. Hermeneia. The extreme possibility of hermeneutics is firstly to address.

A postcard is a courier of history.