Heidegger, Derrida, and the Greek Limits of Philosophy | Timothy Clark, Philosophy and Literature
@Greek_philosophy
Authors:
Well written article. I only made notes of chapter 2 because I was reading the text with eye on general notes on Heidegger and Derrida, rather than the main theme of the limits of philosophy.
Chapter 1 skipped
Chapter 2
"When Paul Friedländer opposed Heidegger's reading of aletheia, insisting that the Greeks themselves almost invariably used the word in the sense of "correctness" rather than "unconcealment," Heidegger, in 1964, surprisingly endorsed this conclusion: "we must acknowledge the fact that aletheia, unconcealment in the sense of the opening of presence, was originally only experienced as orthotes, as the correctness of representations and statements."^(17)" (81).
Note 17 refers to: "The End of Philosophy and the Task of Thinking", in Time and Being, Harper and Row, 1972, p.70.
The debate of Heidegger and Friedländer has been summarized by Robert Bernasconi (The Question of Language in Heidegger's History of Being). This reference comes from page 23, I could perhaps read the first chapter to retrieve this distinction.
It might be a relevant quote in my thesis where I talk about Heidegger's nostalgia.
Bernasconi argues that Heidegger does not initiate a naive return to a pre-metaphysical Greek experience of being. Instead, and this is a difference, Heidegger tries to think what remained unthought in those experiences. In other words, when Heidegger reasons about aletheia, he can even admit that indeed the Greek did not think of aletheia as unconcealment, while nevertheless also maintaining that it was unthought yet the essential aspect of their very experience of being.
"One may reiterate this ambiguity in the participle in terms of the distinction between that which appears (the entity) and the appearing (being) whereby it becomes apparent. In this structure, the appearing is necessarily withdrawn, remaining invisible in the very unveiling of that which it renders present. One apprehends nowhere appearing itself, only apparent entities. Greece, as the site of the determination of being as presence, is consequently at the same time the site of this originary concealment. In order for aletheia to be what it is, unconcealment, it must efface itself to the very degree that some entity emerges from concealment. Hence the possibility of what later metaphysics was to call objectivity stems from the effacement of appearing in the appearance, visibility in the visible. The structure of the ontological difference, therefore, is finally nothing but its own erasure." (82)
Relation between aletheia and a-letheia as figure and ground:
"The relationship between aletheia as "correctness" (which is also how the Greeks understood it) and a-letheia as "unconcealment"is not one of latent and hidden meanings. The relationship between the philosophical word and the same word submitted to a Heideggerian reading is more like a very peculiar structure of figure ("correctness")and ground ("unconcealment"). The peculiarity lies in the fact that the ground here is nothing but its effacement in the presentation of the figure." (83)
Philosophy as the transformation of the history of philosophy:
"The trace, then, is precisely what may never appear as such. The ambiguity of the trace structure, granting the presence of the realm of entities in a movement of constitutive erasure, therefore inhabits the totality of the language of metaphysics since the Greeks. It is not a hidden meaning of any sort. Rather to read metaphysics with regard to the rift of the difference becomes the cultivation of an exact and difficult form of ambiguity. It becomes necessary to read the key terms of the philosophical tradition themselves as traces of being's double erasure. The thought that attempts to live at the limits of philosophy thus becomes a bizarre mode of reading; philosophy becomes the transformation of the history of philosophy."
Nice to quote the Geschick as the result of a bizarre mode of reading the history of philosophy.
Chapter 3
Also skipped.