Functional Stupidity, Entropy and Negentropy in the Anthropocene
Introduction to the 2015 book "Automatic Society 1: The Future of Work" by Bernard Stiegler, trans. Daniel Ross.
Published separately in "La Deleuziana – Online Journal of Philosophy – issn 2421-3098 n. 1 / 2015 – Crisis of the European Biopolitics"
What transpires between 23 June and 23 October 2008
Stiegler opens with a display of various data-heavy approaches that are not explicitly guided by a theory (e.g. Google's "linguistic capitalism") or rather by an occult non-explicit theory.
Stiegler gives the example of the financial crisis and the involvement of automated subprime and high-frequency trading, according to Alan Greenspan.
The idea of "data without theory" (my phrasing) is put forward by Chris Anderson in The End of Theory: The Data Deluge Makes the Scientific Method Obsolete.
Kevin Kelly objected that, behind every automated understanding of a set of facts, there lies a hidden theory, whether there is awareness of it or not, and, in the latter case, it is a theory awaiting formulation. What this means for us, if not for Kelly himself, is that behind and beyond all fact, there is a law. (123)
Kelly reference: Kevin Kelly, “On Chris Anderson’s The End of Theory”, Edge: The Reality Club (30 June 2008), available at: http://edge.org/discourse/the_end_of_theory.html#kelly.
What does it mean to plead for a law? Pleading for a law means "asserting the law of the exception" (123). However many data and facts there may be, their coherence may be invalidated by a single exception, however improbable that is. Cf. induction problem of the black swan.
Some interesting references:
@linguistic @capitalism
Kaplan, “Linguistic Capitalism and Algorithmic Mediation”, Representations 27 (2014), pp. 57–63.
This article argues that linguistic capitalism implies not an economy of attention but an economy of expression. As several million users worldwide daily express themselves through one of Google's interfaces, the texts they produce are systematically mediated by algorithms. In this new context, natural languages could progressively evolve to seamlessly integrate the linguistic biases of algorithms and the economical constraints of the global linguistic economy From Kaplan's abstract:
This article argues that linguistic capitalism implies not an economy of attention but an economy of expression. As several million users worldwide daily express themselves through one of Google's interfaces, the texts they produce are systematically mediated by algorithms. In this new context, natural languages could progressively evolve to seamlessly integrate the linguistic biases of algorithms and the economical constraints of the global linguistic economy
see Kaplan-Linguistic_Capitalism_and_Algorithmic_Mediation.md
@black swan theory
Nassim Nicholas Taleb, The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable (New York: Random House, 2007).
Mettre Paris en bouteille
@capitalism
Mettre Paris en bouteille. “with ifs, one could bottle Paris” Translator’s note: this is a French proverb: “Avec des si, on mettrait Paris en bouteille”.
Nevertheless, the defense of Alan Greenspan was not that there was no proper theory behind the automated trading machines, but rather that they had been trained on data that was limited: the last 20 or so years had been years of economic prosperity. For balanced decision making by these machines, they should have been exposed to times of economic stress as well.
And this model developed precisely in order to conceal the systemic insolvency of consumer capitalism (that is, of “growth”), a form of capitalism afflicted for over thirty years by the drastic reduction in the purchasing power of workers, as demanded by the conservative revolution – and by financialization, in which the latter fundamentally consists, and which makes it possible for countries to become structurally indebted, and hence subjected to an unprecedented form of blackmail that indeed resembles a racket (and which we can therefore refer to as mafia capitalism). (124)
See maffia capitalism.
@nihilism
We shall see that, as contemporary capitalism becomes purely computational, concretized in the so-called data economy, this aporia is exacerbated, this contradiction is “realized”, and in this way it succeeds in accomplishing that becoming without future referred to by Nietzsche as nihilism – of which Anderson’s blustering assertions and Greenspan’s muddled explanations are symptoms (in the sense given to this term by Paolo Vignola). (125)
What is hidden in France Ten Years From Now
@automation @employment
Various influential people have discussed the thesis that due to automation processes employment will drop drastically in the coming twenty years.
E.g. "Bruegel argues, through Jeremy Bowles and by taking note of the figures given by Benedikt Frey and Michael Osborne at the Oxford Martin School, that Belgium could see 50% of its jobs disappear, England 43%, Italy and Poland 56% – and all this, according to Le Soir, “within one or two decades”." (127)
This topic, which promises to fundamentally transform macro-economics and society, is not addressed properly by governments (in this case, Stiegler focuses on the French government).
One problem, pointed out by Hakim El Karoui, is that the tax system is not suited for collecting wealth generation from the digital section in such a way that this wealth will be redistributed over society. (see 127)
How can we redistribute this wealth in when the promises of automation come to fruition?
Entropy and negentropy in the Anthropocene (but actually: about automation)
@entropy @negentropy @disautomatization
Main question of Stiegler's book:
Is a different future possible, a new beginning, in the process of complete and generalized automatization to which global digital reticulation leads?
Neganthropoce: the exit from the Anthropocene which has, according to Stiegler, established "generalized proletarianization" (128)
The escape from the Anthropocene constitutes the global horizon of the theses advanced here. These theses posit as first principle that the time saved by automatization must be invested in new disautomatization capabilities, that is, of the production of negentropy. (128)
Analysts have been predicting the end of wage labour for decades, from Norbert Wiener in the United States to Georges Friedman in France, after John Maynard Keynes himself warned of its imminent disappearance. Marx, too, explored this hypothesis in depth in a famous fragment of the Grundrisse known as the “fragment on machines” or the “section on automation”. (128)
The overall point is that time saved by automation must be
1) "invested in new disautomatization capabilities" (production of negentropy) 2) "put at the service of a culture of automata capable of producing new value and of reinventing work"
Stiegler does not explain his use of entropy and negentropy. He did so elsewhere, but doesn't refer to it. At this point I do not know the technical meaning of these terms in Stiegler's work. However, this is the logical structure behind their use:
1) Automation has produced massive entropy throughout the entire world (129) 2) Automation that promotes a culture of disautomatization promotes negentropy
Claims in terms of organology:
This pharmacological toxicity becomes a common consciousness, a sense that factors that, hitherto, we believed were progressive, have now inverted their sign and are a precipitating cause of the spread of human regression. The Anthropocene, whose history coincides with that of capitalism, thus presents itself as a process that begins with organological industrialization (including in those countries thought of as “anti-capitalist”), that is, with the industrial revolution – which must accordingly be understood as an organological revolution. (130)
The completion of nihilism and the entry into the Neganthropocene
Industrial capitalism:
- "an era in which calculation prevails over every other criteria of decision-making" (130)
- "and where algorithmic and mechanical becoming is concretized and materialized as logical automation and automatism" (130)
- "thereby constituting the advent of nihilism, as computational society becomes an authentic and remotely controlled society." (130)
In what way exactly is nihilism linked with automation? This is not explained and remains unclear to me. It is simply stated.
Later on page 11 a possible explanation of this link can be found.
- The Anthropocene is, according to Stiegler, "the geological era that consists in the devaluation of all values"
- Automation is thus linked with nihilism insofar as it is a full expression of the Anthropocene, "concretized as the age of planetarizing capitalism." (131)
- Likewise, the move beyond the Anthropocene must be a "transvaluation of values"
@Leroi-Gourhan @Canguilhem @homonization @artificialization
Stiegler posits some sort of a program in these two paragraphs:
(...) what philosophy had denied in a structural way for centuries has now become clear, namely, that the artifact is the mainspring of hominization, its condition and its destiny. It is no longer possible for anyone to ignore this reality: what Valéry, Husserl and Freud posit between the two world wars as a new age of humanity, that is, as its pharmacological consciousness and unconsciousness of the “world of spirit” [34], has become a common, scrambled and miserable consciousness and unconsciousness. Such is ill-being in the contemporary Anthropocene.
What follows from this is an urgent need to redefine the noetic fact in totality – that is, in every field of knowledge (of how to live, do and think) – and to do so by integrating the perspectives of André Leroi-Gourhan and Georges Canguilhem, who were the first to posit the artificialization of life as the starting point of hominization [35]. This imperative presents itself as a situation of extreme urgency crucial to politics, economics and ecology. And it thereby raises a question of practical organology, that is, of inventive productions. (131)
Quite unclear so far. Later we find another passage that elaborates on this program, and again in terms of overcoming nihilism, here now not in the form of automatism but as consumerism. But the reference to Marx clearly does point towards his critique on automation and machines:
Reading Marx and Nietzsche together in the service of a new critique of political economy, where the eco-nomy has become a cosmic factor on a local scale (a dimension of the cosmos) and therefore an eco-logy, must lead to a process of transvaluation, such that both economic values and those moral devaluations that result when nihilism is set loose as consumerism are “transvaluated” through a new value of all values, that is, by negentropy - or negative entropy [36], or anti-entropy[37] (131-132)
The references here are:
- [36] Erwin Schrödinger, What is Life?: The Physical Aspect of the Living Cell (1944), in What is Life, with Mind and Matter and Autobiographical Sketches (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992).
- [37] Francis Bailly and Giuseppe Longo, “Biological Organization and Anti-Entropy”, Journal of Biological Systems 17 (2009), pp. 63–96.
The Anthropocene passes through the Web
@www
The transition into the Neganthropocene apparently therefore also apparently requires a reimagination of the world wide web.
The web as a new epoch:
We argue that this question and these productions necessarily pass through (and we will show why) a complete reinvention of the world wide web – the Anthropocene having since 1993 entered into a new epoch with the advent of the Web, an epoch that is as significant for us today as were railways at the beginning of the Anthropocene. (131)
@grammatisation
Emerging from thermodynamics about thirty years after the advent of industrial technology and the beginning of the organological revolution lying at the origin of the Anthropocene, both with the grammatization of gesture by the first industrial automation and with the steam engine [38], the theory of entropy redefines the question of value, if it is true that the entropy/negentropy relation is the vital question par excellence. (132)
The question of fire and the advent of thermodynamics
This whole section is quite incomprehensible to me.
The Anthropocene as succession of technological shocks and the neganthropic role of knowledge
Again, quite abstract.
This passage was relatively interesting to me. It is about a "doubly epokhal redoubling" that firstly destroys "established circuits of transindividuation" and then allows the creation of new circuits.
A techno-logical epokhe is what breaks with constituted automatisms, socialized and capable of producing their own dis-automatization through appropriate knowledge: the suspension of socialized automatisms (which feed stupidity in its many and varied forms) occurs through the putting in place of new, asocial automatisms, through which the second moment of shock (as the second redoubling) produces new capacities for dis-automatization, that is, of negentropy itself fostering new social organizations. (134)
So:
- There are various constituted/socialized automatisms (underlying stupidity),
- We have seen before that these automatisms need to be shaken up and replaced with "asocial" automatisms. This seems to be a destructive movement to free up energy (entropy?) so that it becomes available for reordering (binding the free energy again: negentropy?) social bodies in a way that supposedly supersedes the issues with automatization/capitalism/blabla.
Knowledge always proceeds from such a double shock – whereas stupidity always proceeds from automaticity. (134)
From the following citation I for the first time more or less pick up the meaning of Neganthropocone:
The Anthropocene is a singular organological epoch inasmuch as it generates the organological question itself. It is in this way retroactively constituted through recognizing itself, where the question posed by the Anthropocene is how to exit the toxic period of the Anthropocene in order to enter the curative and care-ful – and in this sense economizing – epoch of the Neganthropocene. (135)
So, insofar as the essential point of the Anthropocene is how to exit the Anthropocene into a new social ordering, it is called Neganthropocene.
What this means in practical terms is that in the Neganthropocene, and on the economic plane, the accumulation of value must occur exclusively with respect to investments that we shall call neganthropic. (135)
We call neganthropic that human activity that is explicitly and imperatively governed – via processes of transindividuation that it implements, and which result from a criteriology established by retentional systems – by negentropic criteria. The neganthropization of the world breaks with the care-less and negligent nthropization of its entropic effects – that is, with the essential characteristics of the Anthropocene. (135-136)
Back to the topic of automation :-).
@accelationalism
As said before, Stiegler frames Anthropocene in terms of its need to overcome itself. It thus "bears the structure of a promise" (136).
At the same time this promise is made untenable by "the establishment of the complete and general automatization and automation made possible by the industry of reticulated digital traces" (136).
Q: Is there an important difference between automation and automatization?
Q: What does "reticulated" mean in this context?
reticulate: resembling a net or network, having veins, fibers, or lines crossing. Also: involving evolutionary change due to genetic recombination when populations interbreed.
So the promised social transformation is limited by the capitalist processes of automation.
@automation @deterritorialization
Would be interesting to compare entropic or hyper-entropic movement to what Deleuze and Guattari called deterritorialization.
We have seen before that Stiegler argues that the nihilistic and capitalist elements related to automation must themselves be overcome by forms of automation (albeit, different ones)? In this section, Stiegler really takes an accelerationist position by arguing that automation must be completed and that the completion of automation will show the necessity of a social reorganization.
To be honest, apart from the abstract terms, this story makes sense to me: general automation will show decisively that work can no longer be the measure of value, or have inherent value, as it has been completely automatized.
To hold on, that is, to hold good to this promise, is to hold on, precisely, starting from those neganthropic possibilities opened up by automation itself: it is to think this industry of reticulation as a new epoch of work, as the end of the epoch of “employment”, given that the latter is ultimately and permanently compromised by complete and general automation. And it is to think this industry as the ‘transvaluation’ of value, whereby «labour time ceases and must cease to be its measure, and hence exchange value [must cease to be the measure] of use value» [48], and where the value of value become neganthropy. Only in this way can and must the passage from the Anthropocene to the Neganthropocene be accomplished. (136)
Cf. [48]: Karl Marx, Grundrisse: Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy (Rough Draft) (London: Pelican, 1973), p. 705.
Smartification
@smartification @destiny without destination
Since 1993, a new global technical system has been put in place. It is based on digital tertiary retention, and it constitutes the infrastructure of an automatic society to come. We are told that the data economy, which seems to concretize itself as the economic dynamic generated by this infrastructure, is the destiny of this automatic society to come. We shall show, however, that the “destiny” of this society of hyper-control (chapter one) is not a destination: it leads nowhere other than to nihilism, that is, to the negation of knowledge itself (chapter two). (136)
This destiny without destination, leading nowhere, is an "entropic catastrophe", of a toxic combination between capitalist consumerism and a digitalized society, namely the "industrial exploitation of modeled and digitalized traces"
The current system of the industrial exploitation of modeled and digitalized traces precipitated the entropic catastrophe that is the Anthropocene as a destiny that leads nowhere. As 24/7 capitalism and algorithmic governmentality, it hegemonically serves a hyper-entropic functioning that accelerates the rhythm of the consumerist destruction of the world while installing a structural and unsustainable insolvency, based on a generalized stupefaction and a functional stupidity (...) (136)
The need for ** hermeneutic ** digital technology!
We intend in this work to show that the reticulated digital infrastructure that supports the data economy, set into place in 1993 with the world wide web and constituting the most recent epoch of the Anthropocene, can and must be inverted into a neganthropic infrastructure founded on hermeneutic digital technology in the service of dis-automatization, that is, based on collective investment of the productivity gains derived from automatization in a culture of knowing how to do, live and think insofar as this knowledge is essentially neganthropic and as such produces new value that, alone, is capable of establishing an era bearing a new solvency that we call the Neganthropocene (chapters seven and eight).
The aforementioned society of hyper-control:
The current infrastructure is rapidly evolving towards a society of hyper-control founded on mobile devices such as the smartphone, domestic devices such as the web-connected television, habitats, such as the smart house and smart city, and transport devices, such as the connected car. (137)
Michael Price showed on 31 October 2014 that the connected television is a tool for the automated spying on individuals: (137)
137-138 nice section on how early computers were transparent and programmable by their users, but how nowadays all underlying functionality is closed off from the user. We have no way of verifying backdoors etc.
@Morozov @governance
Morozov on "algorithmic regulation" as a new form of governance:
Referring to the work of Tim O’Reilly, Evgeny Morozov talks about “smartification” based on “algorithmic regulation” that amounts to a new type of governance founded on cybernetics, which is above all the science of government, as Morozov recalls [54]. I have myself tried to show, provisionally, that in a way this constitutes the horizon of Plato’s Republic[55].
- [54] Evgeny Morozov, “The rise of data and the death of politics”, The Guardian (20 July 2014), available at: http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jul/20/rise-of-data-death-of-politics-evgeny-morozov- algorithmic-regulation.
- [55] See the courses of pharmakon.fr from 2012–13 and 2013–14.
The claim of Morozov: algorithmic regulation suppresses disagreement and conflict.
"Morozov’s central idea is that the way we currently organize the collection, exploitation and reproduction of what we are here calling digital tertiary retention rests on the structural elimination of conflicts, disagreements and controversies:
[A]lgorithmic regulation offers us a good-old technocratic utopia of politics without politics. Disagreement and conflict, under this model, are seen as unfortunate byproducts of the analog era – to be solved through data collection – and not as inevitable results of economic or ideological conflicts.
We shall see how Thomas Berns and Antoinette Rouvroy have analyzed, from a similar standpoint, what they themselves call, in reference to Michel Foucault, algorithmic governmentality – whereby the insurance business and a new conception of medicine based on a transhumanist program both have the goal of “hacking” (that is, “reprogramming”) not only the state, but the human body [57]. Google, which along with NASA supports the Singularity University, has invested heavily in “medical” digital technologies based on the application of supercomputing to genetic and also epigenetic data – and with an explicitly eugenic goal [58]."
[57]: See Jean-Christophe Féraud and Lucile Morin, “Transhumanisme: un corps pieces et main-d’oeuvre”, Libération (7 December 2014).
Morozov's remark is particularly interesting because the possibility of disagreement is absolutely for any real dialogue. A digital hermeneutics should thus absolutely counteract that movement:
where this is also a matter of redesigning the digital architecture and in particular the digital architecture of the web, with the goal of creating a digital hermeneutics that gives to controversies and conflicts of interpretation their negentropic value, and constitutes on this basis an economy of work and knowledge founded on intermittence, for which the model must be the French system designed to support the so-called “intermittents du spectacle”