Digital Enlightenment
@digital @enlightenment
In what ways do ICTs promote or challenge Enlightenment values?
In Verbeek-Designing_Public_Sphere_Politics_of_Mediation.md Verbeek sketches new forms of technological mediation that challenge Enlightenment values:
At the same time it is often hard to see these mediations, because information technologies increasingly challenge the frameworks by which we have come to understand ourselves and the world we live in. Ever since the Enlightenment, we have understood ourselves as relatively autonomous subjects in a world of objects that we can investigate, manipulate, and appreciate. But the self-evidence of this metaphysical framework—in which subjects have intentions and freedom, while objects are passive and mute—is rapidly fading away, now that information and communication technologies have started to challenge it seriously. (221)
See Heiden-Technology_and_Formation.md for a description of how Stiegler subscribes to Enlightenment values of education
A second point of G-J's criticism is that even though Stiegler calls for a reform of education, his ideals and reference point of Bildung seem to be "the Enlightenment tradition as well as to the Platonic understanding of education" (62)
Stiegler's idea of education accordingly seems to make assumption that are typical for the Enlightenment:
In terms of the idea of formation or Bildung as developed in the Enlightenment, the fundamental requirement of coming to maturity is that teachers introduce students in the horizon of meaning that constitutes the culture in which they live: e.g., the students are introduced to the canonical texts of this culture, into the way in which they are read, in the practices that are needed for sound scholarship, and so on. Thus formation, in its common understanding, presupposes the idea of relatively stable tradition, culture, or horizon of meaning within which the young students are introduced to such an extent that they can develop their own critical attitude to it; and it presupposes the distinction between the mature teacher and the immature student. (62)
But the whole point of the current situation is that such a stable culture cannot be presupposed anymore through the pharmacological event of disruption.
the question of education and formation departs from a specific “short-circuiting,” that is to say, the question of education can no longer be understood as the introduction of children or immature humans in a relatively stable culture by mature humans. (62)
See Stiegler-Aufklarung_Philosophical_Engineering.md for Stiegler's description of how the internet on the one hand is compatible with Enlightenment ideals, while emphasizing we must also think its shadows.