Common fallacies in ethical and technical debates

@rhetoric @fallacy

There are formal and informal fallacies.

  • Formal: fallacy is solely based on the logical form of the argument
  • Informal: depend on the context and content of the argument

Recognizing fallacies can be important for countering misinformation, although this costs a lot of energy (cf. Brandolini's law ).

  • Ad hominem: attacking the author instead of the argument
  • Naturalistic fallacy (ought-is)
    • Something should be because currently it is that way
    • Wrong transition from descriptive statements to normative statements
    • "There has been war since the dawn of humanity, so it can't be morally wrong"
  • Straw man: attacking a (weaker) misrepresentation of the opponent's argument
  • Confusing ethics with law: "it it isn't illegal, its ethical"
    • E.g. lying to someone is not forbidden by law, but is nevertheless not morally acceptable.
  • Fallacy of desire / wishful thinking
    • "God exists, because I have complete belief that He does and I feel his presence everywhere"
  • Privacy fallacy: "If you have done nothing wrong, you have nothing to worry about"
    • Privacy does not only protect those who have something to hide
    • Erroneous information about you can ruin your life
    • Protection against discrimination
  • Ambiguity
    • Example from Ibo van de Poel and Lambèr Royakkers: A captain writes in his journal "The first mate was drunk today". In response, the first mate writes "The captain was sober today", using ambiguity in this phrasing to suggest that the captain is usually drunk.
  • Red herring
    • Trying to win a debate by not addressing the main issue

Fallacies of causal reasoning

  • post hoc ergo propter hoc
    • derive a causal relationship only because two things occur successively
  • slippery slope
    • a wild generalization based on a too specific and small cause

Fallacies of technological risk

Sven Ove Hanson identifies specific fallacies of risk in technological discussions:

  • Sheer size fallacy:
    • X is accepted
    • Y is a smaller risk than X
    • So Y should also be accepted

I think this fallacy also applies to self-driving cars: We should accept self-driving cars because currently driving is already killing a lot of people and self-driving cars are likely to decrease that number.

  • Ostrich fallacy
    • There is no scientific proof that X is dangerous
    • So X does not give an unacceptable risk
    • (The correct conclusion would be: we do not know and perhaps: better safe than sorry)
  • Delay fallacy
    • We take no decision about X now because we first need more data to understand the problem
    • This fallacy is interesting to counter with the paradigm of value-sensitive design
  • Price fallacy
    • We must weight benefits and risk of X
    • So X is something we have to put a price on
    • E.g. it is most likely not ethical to put a price on a life
  • "Eventual" fallacy
    • From Koepsell 2010
    • Someone will discover this dangerous technology at some point anyway, so we should do it first, since we have good intentions.
    • Can justify any type of research, however dangerous.
    • But why does this research need to be done now?